��ࡱ�>�� ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������q` �R�R�bjbjqPqP2�::)J�������4444444(� NNNNThN� �f�(O$LPLPLPLPLP"nR�:Sh f f f f f f f$�ghEjN0fu4�ULPLP�U�U0f44LPLP�fhWhWhW�U 4LP4LP fhW�U fhWhW44hWLPO �>ڐ�N�V�hW�bT�f0�fhW�j �S,hW T$0Tr�S�S�S0f0fRW�S�S�S�f�U�U�U�U   ��0�   �0H$l�$444444���� >yO���N�S�l�[$R�N�R�v*NHhxvz \O�: HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm" \t "_blank" RNgf | �S^�e��:2007-12-14 9:32:28 | ���pe: 1926 >yO���N�S�l�[$R�N�R�v*NHhxvz HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn1" \o "" [`$]  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/" \t "_blank" RNgf ��T\�n�]N'Yf[ �lf[b� �ў��_l �T\�n 150001 � Research on the Interaction of the Public Opinionand Judicial Judgment Liu Li-ming (School of Law , Harbin Institute of Technology , Harbin,15001) Xd����S�l;m�RN>yO���X[(W�N�R0,g�eǑ�S*NHhxvz�l �Џ(u�|�~���St ��[ُN>yOǏ z�v�Q(W:g6RۏL��c��R�g ��_�Qb�V�S�lЏ\O�|�~�vN,�!j�W---ёW[TX!j�W0l��W�egb�V�v�l�_6R�^Fh�gN�Si�-N O�~�eSKN��X[(W�w�v �@b�N�^S_��BlN�y�fwQTt'`�T�s�['`�v�S�lckIN �sSOSFU�WckIN0>yO���N�S�lKN���v�N�R/fo�'`�v ��OO�S�lT@w�f�[�U0W�O�b�NlCg)R�v�eTbaoۏ � T�e�c�R@w�l�_ĉR,g���Su�Si� �v^1udk�OۏOSFU�W�S�lckIN�v�[�s0 sQ.�͋��S�l�[$R�>yO�����S�llQck Abstract� There are interactions between judgment and public opinion. In this thesis, the structure of public opinion lies in legal affairs (pyramid model) and the intrinsic mechanism of the social process that social consensus affects judicial judgment were analyzed in detail by using individual case method in case sociology and theory of system control and minus feedback to search for the justice that should be after in the changing era in our country, named consulting justice. The interaction is so good to push the public makes law more powerful to protect civil right by the consultation and interplay with judicial department and political department. They are also reforming the law itself so that the consulting justice can be realized. Keywords�Judicial Judgment; Public Opinion; Justice N0��v�c�Q�T��gxvz�v�����S�[�e �N ���v�c�Q �S�l�[$R/f�[�s>yOckIN�vN�y;N��b__ ��S�lckIN_N/f>yOckINg͑���vh��_KNN0t�`-N�v�S�l� yO�V }0�V:N�N�N N�S/f�q�~Џ(u�l�_�b/g�v�l�_�N ��N�N_N/f>yO�N ��e�l)u_�N�N�vX[(W �sS�N�N�v O�~�T�eS �ۏL��S�l;m�R0�S�l;m�R;`/f(WN�[�v�ezz NۏL��v �T�y>yO�V }�e�l�N-N�cd��Q�S � ��_6q(W�l�_Џ\OǏ z-N�ɉ N�ɉ�vSO�s�Qeg0vQ-N �>yO����[�S�l�[$R�v�]'Y�S�R�Tq_�T1\/f�_�z�Q�vN�O0 �[>yO����S�R�[�S�l�[$R�vq_�TZP�QxvzASR�_�� � ��V�Q�s g�v�vsQxvz'Y���S�N�ZSO�vcwN�S�l�r�z�S�S�llQck�vsQ�|�N�~�|�v�lʑ�lf[b�e��f[�v҉�^eg�c��ُ*N� � N�_�>yO��� �1\/f�[�ZSOċ��vz�z�YUO�[�S�l�Nuq_�T_N���� NY0��HN ��NwQSOHh�O�Q�S ��N�l>yOf[�vxvzƉ҉ �Sb4x�N�_\�S�l�[$R;m�R�ba�S0�~�|S0^y#WS�T�N:NOKN1��y>yOu;m��S�v��{ �\vQ�~eQ>yOu;mKN-N �\O:NN*N>yOǏ zegxvz ��f(Wُ*N>yOǏ z-N�l�_ag�e@bSO�s�v�l�_�eS�T>yO���ُ$N�y N T�v>yOaƋb_`/f�YUO T�e\O(u�N g@wY�y>yO҉r��v�l�[ ��c:yُ*N>yOǏ z�vЏL�:g6R �\ASR�_��0 (�N)xvzFh�g�T�e�l 1.xvzFh�g �[�N�S�l�[$R�v>yO����S�R ��V�QYf[�'Y��/f�N�e���ZSON�S�l�vsQ�|҉�^ۏL�xvz�v0�VY�s g�v�vsQxvzYpe�V�~�e���bS��[�Nɋ���~�g�vq_�TۏL� � gt��R�g �_N g�[��xvz ��l͑�N�[�l�[�v�_t�T�`a�vR�g �FO/f���l gR�g>yO���ُN�V }�[�S�l�vq_�T,nxR�v�l g\ O�ZN���:SR_eg01u�Nb�V�v�V�`�T�S�l�s�r ��V�Q�v�vsQxvz��/f�N�e���vcw�T�S�l�r�z�v҉�^�S�c�� �Ypef[���:N���~�b�S�l�r�z ��Ǐ�^�g6R�^eg�ĉ��e���vcw0�N�N N T z�^�v���b�e���bS��T>yO���I{ Tw�eg0�SY ��V�Q�vsQxvz�vxvz�e�l_N�v�[USN0 ,g�e͑(WЏ(u�|�~���vN,��St�[ N T{|�W�v>yO���\O(u�N�S�l�[$R�v>yOǏ zZP�c���TR�g �v^;`�~�QُNǏ z�vN,�!j�W ��f>yO���N�S�l��X[(Wo�'`�N�R �ۏ ��cBlb�Vl��W�eg�^S_��Bl�v�S�lckIN0Ջ�V(u�T�l��e�vlQqQ���Wt���S�l�s�N'`t������ck/f�S�l�T���KN���v�v�N�[݋0�l�0teTOb�V�v�l�_ĉ�4x�e�z�e ���eg��wQ gTt'` ���eg���cяwck�v�S�lckIN0 >yO���clQO�[vQsQ�_�v�Nir0�N�N0�sa��T‰�_�v�O�_0`�^�Ta���v;`�T �wQ gN�[�vN�'`0:_�p z�^�Tc�~'` �v^�[ gsQ�N`�v�SU\�Nuq_�T0,g�e@bxvz�v�S�l�[$R �/fc�S�l:gsQ�N�NeQ0R��QN*N�l�_�N�N�vhQ�Ǐ z0b�V�s�N>yO-N�l�_�N�N-N�v>yO��� �/fYCQS�v �HT�s�Q O�~�ZSO0�wƋLu0Q�~lQO�gb�v N�g!j_ � N��gb�N N����z�vFh�g0 N�KN���^�z�N�Oo` N�e�v�v�N O�N�S���vt�`!j�W0ُ�y!j_�v>yO�Onc/fS_�N>yOFd1��NNCQS�vb_` �ۏeQ�NYCQS>yO0�N{|�c�S�N Ype;NIN �vs^I{�v8nbĉR � �[݋;NSO _N�_6q�Q�sYCQ'`0ُ�y N�g!j_�v>yO,g(�/f>yO�vRS0>yO���_(�S�vh��s �b_b�N�S�l�[$RǏ z-N�vYCQ�[݋0 [1] 2.xvz�e�l ,gxvzǑ�S�v;N���e�l/fHh�N>yOf[-N�v*NHhxvz�l �(WN�[�eg�Q�1997t^ 2007t^ �(W�V�Q gq_�T�v�ZSO N�bS��vxQ�WHh�OۏL�6eƖtetv^Џ(u�|�~���e�l\O!j�WR�g0 ��HQ/f�V�Q gq_�T�v�ZSO�v ��b0,g�eR+R(WBg�_0Q�~�e��0�b�~05uƉ�ZSO0Q�~��[WI{�Q*N�ZSOb__-N ��b�N NT�u;mhT R0�ejm�e��Q0WS�ehT+g0-N.Y5uƉ�S�e����S�0)Y�m>y:SsQ)Y6� �ُ5*N�_ gq_�T�v�Nh�'`�ZSO\O:N ��bHh�O�v}�SO �vQ-N�e g O�~�ZSO_N gQ�~�ZSO ��e g;NAm�ZSO �_N g�k����Y�S�Q�r�z�X�v�ZSO0vQ!k/f�[Hh�O�v ��b �gTnx�[��2�[�ZSO���f�~�N�bS�bċ���vHh�O:Nxvz*NHh0(W ��Q@b gHh�O-NۏNek ��b>yO���NHh�N�v�[tsQ�|�[R�v ��V�Qg gq_�T�v8*N*NHh0gT/fD��e�vhQb�dƖ �[�Nُ8*N*NHh ��N�NT�Q N'YϑdƖ�vsQD��e0 �N0*NHh�N�~Nċ�� 1u�N,gxvz�Q�[�T�e�l N�vyr�k'` �@b�N g�_��(WُN�R\@b ��b�v8*N*NHh\O�{���v�N�~ ��S g�bHh�N�veg���S �0�SU\Ǐ z�SYt�~�gU\�s�Qeg �v^�bHh�NYtǏ z-N�y�y>yO����N�ST�eb��[����v�S f�c:y�Qeg �Mb���f}Y�vt�ck�e�vxvz�TR�g0 1.�lWS _ё�gR�T�N����NHh 1997t^�Sѐ�]^lQ�[R@\@\� _ё�gR�T~�f��d{k0�d$OTN�N0 0'Y�l�b 0�sHQ�bS��NُNHh�N �w���[��Bl�b'}�e��%N���gY �lQ_���b ��Q N�Yo`04*NgT �ѐ�]^-N�~�Nl�lb�$RY _ё�g{kR0(u _ё�g��]�v݋� ��N/f=h(W�N���Kb̑0 2.�l�]�NvY�~bHh 2001t^ �Ğ�g���zW�1V\"��NW�Yu�~�N�`�N _f[� �v^ۏL��NlQ��0Ğ�g�SNT �vQ�Y��&O���b�~\vQW��N�N�N _f[�0 _B��cw�ɋ�� �1u�NHh�N�vyr�k'`_w���Y�ZSO�vsQ�l ��f_�S�N�l�_Lu�v�o�p�N��0N�[�lb�$R�[�W�1V�eHe �W��NR_��&O��@b g0 _f[��cw� Nɋ ��N�[�~c�N�S$R0 3.Y[�_RHh 2003t^R �Y[�_R�V*g:d&^"�fOO��"��6e�[ �(WQe�b�z���kSb�{k0 0WS�e��^�b 0��!k�b2��NُN�mo` ���T'YQ�zl�}�T �_w��N:_�p�S�T0Q�~ N�v|T�X �N�eb��c�R�N�[Hh�N�v�O�g�T�[�vsQ�NXT�vYt ��SN�eb��OOlQO�NUS�~�v*NHh�vcw NGS:N�[6R�^�v(��u0f[��N�^���[ 06e�[c���R�l 0ۏL�ݏ�[�[�g0�NMOf[��Sh��Xf ��c��hQ�V�N'Y8^�YO1\Y[�_RHh�S6e�[c��6R�^�[�e�r�Q/T�Ryr+R��g z�^0)n�[�[;Nc�S_�V�Rb�8^�RO�� ��Ǐ�N 0Qe�R�{t�R�l 0 ��^bk 06e�[c���R�l 00;N�rTN�g�NEea$O�[j��Y�Q0 4.Ng`!`Hh 2003t^ �NgBh���VL��z���b�� �1u�N�RHh�NXT�v N\O:N �NgBh���vsY?QNg`!`�r��{k(W�[-N0�V�]�ZSO���Ǒ���Ndk�NT(W�b>y�S�R N*g���S�Q?z�N �B�(WQ�~�S�Q�e�z ��zsS_w��N^�lsQ�l ��N�N(WQ�~ N��S�v�~�~�~�_`!`0�Nl�lb�lQ_�[tdkHh ��mHh�vlf��N�m�Z�s�_L��[j���cw�lQɋ0 5.ĞY�Hh 2003t^ � ĞY�Hh �~Q�~ O�dT �(WhQ�V_w��N^�lsQ�l0dkHh_w��NlQ�[萄v͑Ɖv^b�z�NNHh�~ �v^MRT�N!k�[ĞY�{k�VۏL��Nt��[0vQ7u�S�Y�Ofk�N�m�Z:_xYj��.�Uc0�Vt^T�lb�lQ^�[t�~�g�Y���ejʑ>e0ĞY�Hh�f2��Nb�V�s g�v�S�lt��[6R�^�v�mqN �v^_w��N gsQ�蕄v�la02005t^2ghQ�V�N'Y8^�YO�Ǐ�N 0sQ�N�S�lt��[�{t��v�Q�[ 00 6.R�mHh R�m�V��c�c�r g�~�~0���[ў>yO'`(��~�~jI{j �N�[��$RY{kR0�N�v�_^�����N�V�Qg�w T�vR�l�TR�Nɋ���lN�[�[R�mNHhۏL����� ���:N�O�[Ǐ zX[(WR��<��O ������~�g/f"R�m�ej"0ُ*NN�[a��fNb�N:NR�m���b�v g�RfkhVKNN0�N�[�lb�9e$RvQ{k �N�l g�[YlQ^vQ9e$R�v��~t1u �_w����'Y�T ���YN�[�d�e�Sh� w�l0R�mHhg�~��gؚ�Nl�lb��c�[ �$RYR�m{kR ��zsSgbL�0 7.Y['YHSHh l%�ON�[Y['YHS ��V�m�Z ^��l8T6elQOX[>kj ��.�Uc0dkHh_w�>yO N�v�g'Y�N��0f[��N�~�~(WN�N O�~�ZSO�TQ N�d�e�c�Q��]�va��0)YR�~Nmxvz@b1\Y['YHS�N�N�S_{|�N�^�O0 NMO�_^�c��hQ�V�N'Y8^�YO�ʑR�l,{176agI{I{0�_4l�S�Nl�lb�lQ_�[t �$RYY['YHS gg�_R3t^ �g4t^gbL� � T�e�N�~10NCQZё0f[�1\dkHh�c�N�N�c��hQ�V�N'Y8^�YO�[�g 0^��lё��:g�g�T^��lё��N�R;m�R�S�R�l 0�v�^��fN0 8.�T\�n�[l��d�NHh 2003t^ ��NINCgNς�y�e�Nu�Ngb0ς Nf� ��z6q�[l�f�TMR�Q�Q �\R�_���NKN�Y ��d{k �12 T�O���d$O0�lb��Nς�r�N����NjN�[$RYvQ gg�_R2t^0R3t^0ُN$R�Q�~�g_w����'Y�T0��:NϑR*Y{� �$R�Q NlQck ���Bl͑�e�[t0f[��~�~�d�e����勋N�N0�T^�R�ZSO6e0R gsQ�蕄v �S?z��w 02004t^3g ��Hh��g0 Y�g�]\O�~�g�yN�[ϑR&{T�l�_ĉ�[ �lQO�S f�vvQ�N�GW NX[(W02004t^ў��_lwP�%��[XT�Bh��=�l�0 gQ�S��:N��[l�Hh_w��N-N.YؚB\���[�f-N{_�g ��Bh��/f=h(WQl�� N�N0 b�N�i��0W�N�~�N,gxvz@b ��b�v8*N�z�Q�S f�N>yO���N�S�l�[$RsQ�|�v�l�_*NHh0�^�� ��Nُ�N*NHh-N �b�N�k�N�_�NUO�eP���fnZi0W w0R�N�S�l�[$RL�:ǸT@b��+T@w�v>yO����V } �vQ���\O(u(W�g�Nyr�[�v�l�_>yO�`�X N/f�YdkKN'Y ��YdkKN�_�Y ��N�Nb�N�e��`7h0O���� N�{ǏR06q � ��^��f�v/f ��g�N*NHh1u�N�S�e����� O�d�v�y�yP�6R ��N�Sxvz��[*NHh�v�N�S'`�v:ON ��N�S�S�l�NXT�_tǏ z�|�~�v���N��[ �O�_��Y�[xvz�eg�_͑���v�S�lN����N�RsQ�|-N�v�g�N�~����υ�Nw�eg0ُ>f6q�~b�N�vxvz�]\O&^eg�N�V�� �FOsSO�Ydk �YpeHh�O-N؏/fTb�N�c�O�N��Y�v�vsQ�Oo`0 N0>yO���q_�T�S�lL�:N�v�N�NR�g Nb�\�[8*N*NHhR+RR_{| ��[ N T{|�W�v�l�_�N�N-NT�y�V }�v�N�N\O(u;u�QAm z�V �Џ(u�|�~���v�e�lۏL��=\R�g0 ��HQ � g�_���N�~N Nُ�yR�g�e�l�vt���W@x0 cgq�|�~���v`�` �>yO1\/fN*N_>e YBg�v�]�|�~ �/fN*N��~�~�|�~ ��N�v���R'`0�v�v'`;m�R�S�S�N�[ُ*N��~�~�|�~ۏL�TNNĉ�_�v��c0[2] T7h ��N�l�_�N�N�v�Su�~Ǐ�S�l�[$R0RgT�l�_T�g�Q�s �ُNǏ z_N�S�N w\ON*N��^\�N>yO?e�l�|�~�vN*NP[�|�~ �,g�e�yKN:N �S�lЏ\O�|�~ 0Ջ�V�^�zN*N>yO���q_�T�S�l�[$RL�:N�vN,��|�~!j�W0 �Oo`�S��(W�NUON*N�|�~-N��/fN�ynfM��sa� ��Oo`�S���vh��sb__/f�_�s'`�v ��S��1\/f�|�~�v���QN��eQKN�� ��N�S�|�~�v N T�� }0 N TsQ�|���v�v�N\O(u0�c6R�|�~R:N_�s�|�~�T핯s�|�~ �(W_�s�|�~-N ��c6R�|�~�v���Qϑ Nq_�T�|�~�v�c6R\O(u �sS�|�~���Q�zN��eQ�zKN���e�S���S��(W핯s�|�~-N ��|�~�v���Q�T��eQKN��X[(W�S���S� �sS�|�~�v���Q�[�c6R\O(u g�v�cq_�T [3]0�|�~��`�`�]�~��^�l�^(u0RT*Nxvz���W �6q �vQ(W�V�Q�l>yOf[xvz���W�v�^(utS^�8^\ �,g�e\Ջ\vQЏ(u�N>yO���N�S�l�[$R�N�R�vxvz-N0 �S�lЏ\O�|�~/fN*N핯s�|�~ ��l�_�N�N�v�Su�SƉ:N�|�~�v��eQ � �gT�v�l�_T�g HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn2" \o "" [a$]�SƉ:N�|�~�v���Q0�Q�ُ*N�|�~�v��eQ�T���QKN�� �sS�l�_�N�N�T�l�_T�gKN�� �X[(W@w�S���v�S� � �N(W��|�~�Q萄v���� }KN��_NX[(W@w�v�N\O(u �sS�Oo`�v�S��0 �N ��S�lЏ\O�|�~�v�R`�~�gR�g 10S��_N�l�v�Q�z� _f[��~bHh (W�l�_�N�N-N�m�SS��_N�l�v�Q�z�v�eP �(WHh�N�[tǏ z-N8^8^O_�S:_�p�v>yO���0�l�] _f[��~bHh1\/fN�O0 �Y�V1@b:y �S_�l�_�N�N�SuT �(WۏeQ�S�l�[t z�^�v T�e �_N_w��N�Z �N�N �ZSO�bS� �[t 0W�e��� f[����� �V1 �S�lЏ\O�|�~�~�g�V� _f[�Hh � Fig.1 Structure of the justice operate system�case of Zhang Xueying � SO�vsQ�l0�ZSO�bS��T�lb��v�[t_�S0W�e��� �0W�e����SǏeg_�S�ZSO�v�meQ�bS� �$N�qQ T�[�S�l:gsQ�v�[t�]\O�Nu�S�R�Tq_�T0�[t�v�~�g�S_�Y_�Sf[�(Wt�� N�v�c�� [4]0�[t�~�g�Tf[/g�c��\�S���Oo` O��~�|�~�v��eQsS NN*N T{|�l�_�N�N �v^q_�TvQ�[t�~�g0ُ/fN*N핯s�|�~ �(W�ZSO�bS�0>yO����T�[tǏ z N*N�V }�s���v\O(u��/f�N�N�v0 �ُN�N�NǏ z�S�[t�~�g�[�Nf[/g�c���v_�S/fUST�v ��[t�v�~�g�Tf[/g����\O:Nte*N�S�lЏ\O�|�~�v���Q�O�S ��v�c�S��0R��eQ�O�SN�z ��[ NN*N T{|�l�_�N�N�vYtw�0RN�[�v�c6R\O(u0 dk{|Hh�N�v&q�p(W�NS��_wQ g0W�W'`�T�e��'` �_N1\/f� Nnx�['` �@b�N�W�Ndk{|Hh�N@b�Nu�v>yO���,g��1\ g�]_ ��l�]S_0W����T�lf[f[��v�[�z1\/fُ�y�]_�vSO�s0�l�_�TS��_KN��sQ�| ��lf[�[�N�S�l�[�N gN*N�W,g�vqQƋ ���1\/f�S�l�[$R�^S_܏�yS��_$R�e0�V:NS��_wQ g Nnx�['`�T�v�['` �ُw��n�NS��_�v0W�e'`�T�e��'`0 ��l�[_N/f>yO�[��-N�v�N ����`Fd1�NRYLu�V }�vr^pb/f N�S���v �ُ/fN*N�_xQ�W�vHh�O ��[SO�s�Q�N�l�[ꁫ�S��_‰N�l�_ }{Q�v�Q�z �SO�s�Q�N�l�[ꁫ��v0W�WP�6R'` �SO�s�Q�Nl������[�S�l�v�]'Y�S�R�Tq_�T0 1u�NHh�N�m�S�v�S/f$N*N>yO0WMO�vS_�v�N�v)R�v�Q�z �@b�Nte*N�N����/f�V�~�s�N>yOS��_N�l�v�Q�z�TteTۏL� �v^�l g�m�S0R�NUOCg�R� �f[��v�c��_N�N�N/f(W�l�_t���vB\b� N0Cg�R�蕡l g(Wُ*NHh�N-N>f�s �_N�l g�~�ZSO�S�lb��e�R�NUO�v�S�R0 6q ��S�l�[$R-N �\O:N�S�l��v�l�[�~8^��MQO�S0RS��_�vq_�T �b�eg�NY萋S�R �b�egꁎN�Q�_�vS��_h�Q0�V:N�l�[�_{�\O:NN*N go��w�vgb�l�egL��R � g�e_NO cgq��]�v�O�N�T�N k�V�� �l��ؚo`y{ƖD�ё�]b:Nl%�ONy{ƖD�ё�v;N�� nS�0Y['YHS�v�_^��0R� �N)Y ����[$R�v N�^�/fY['YHS � ��^�/f-N�V�PS�vё���{tSO6R0 �N�N �ZSO�bS� Q�~��� f[��c�� Cg�R�� �[t 6R�^�O�U �V2�S�lЏ\O�|�~�~�g�V�Y['YHSHh � Fig.2 Structure of the justice operate system�case of Sun Dawu � �Y�V2-N@b:y ��l�_�N�N�SuT ��ZSO�bS�_�SQ�~����Tf[��vsQ�l �Q�~����Tf[��[Hh�N,g���T6R�^�v�c��b:N�ZSO�bS��v�[a� � N��N�N\O(u �HT�s N����zKN�R0>yO����v%`�b_b�Tf[��vTYp�|TT_�SCg�R�蕄v͑Ɖ �Cg�R���[�S�l�[$RǏ z��eQ�Oo` �g�~���Q�[t�~�g0�[t�v�~�g\O:Nte*N�l�_�N�NЏ\O�|�~�v���Q�O�S ��v�c�S��0R��eQ�O�SN�z ��[ NN*N T{|�l�_�N�N�vYtw�0RN�[�v�c6R\O(u0f[��[Cg�R���c�QsQ�N�O9e�vsQ�l�_6R�^�v�^�� �_N\q_�T@wCg�R�蕄v�vsQ�QV{ �vQgT�v�~�g_N\\O:N�|�~�v���Q�O�SKNN�Ǐ�S���[ NN*N T{|�l�_�N�N�vYtw�0RN�[�v�c6R\O(u0 dk{|Hh�N�v&q�p(W�N}Y�N�r�l �T�` NT�l� �N/f v`�l � �SO�s�Nl)R�vN No�6R�^�v�Q�z �@b�N �te*N�l�_�N�N-N���HT�sN��P�v�r` �T�y{|�W����v‰�pؚ�^�vN� ��[Cg�R�蕌T�S�l:gsQ�Nu�]'Y�S�R �ُ_N/fHh�NgT�~�gTNNla�vN*N͑���S�V0(Wُw�Hh�N-N ��eSO�s�N}Y�NN v`�l �v�Q�z �_NSO�s�N*N�NN6R�^�v�Q�z �(WُNHh�N�S�lЏ\O�|�~!j�W-N �Cg�R���SNvQ-N �v^w�0R�Q�['`\O(u0v^NCg�R��(Wdk{|Hh�N-Nv^*g�v�cp�0R�SMR ��S/f(WT�S����c�[0 30+��[6�B\�v�Q�z��[l�Hh�TR�mHh �[l��d�NHh�TR�mHh^\�N+��[6�B\�Q�z�vxQ�WHh�O0�[l�5��Y�T�Q(uf��Q�Y�]wQ g�N&{�S�vaIN0 �R�mf:N�gƖ�Vc��N��T�N'Y�Nh�0$N*NHh�N_w�:_�p�v�S�T �/f�V:N�vMRnfM�X[(W�vN�N>yO� ��k�Y�S�lP�%�0gb�l NlQI{I{ ��[�N�Nb_bN�y`�~�[�R��[XT�T�[�N�� gyrCg`�` �;`O�QPCg�R�Tё�����_�g�y sQgq 0(W+��[�]ݍ�b'Y�v�N)Y ��[$R�v:ONlQ_OlQO�[�[�N�N�T�S�l��]�~1Y�S�O�N �lQO N�v�O�S�l�O�["��R�[�k�`�k�v�S�eNƉ T�N0 N�{�N�[w�v�YUO �lQO;`/f��:ǸُT���[��υ@w N�SJT�N�vN�0ُ�[(� N/f>yO�`�~0>yO _�R�vN�y�b\0���`OlQO�[�S�l͑h�O�N �1\�_{����S�lǏ z�[hQlQck�TlQ_0�[l�Hh�TR�mHh��/f�V:N�S�l��(WYt�/f NYlQ_ ��f�R_�SlQO�v(��u ��Y�V3@b:y0 �N�N �[t �ZSO�bS� Q�~��� f[��c�� Cg�R�� �V3�S�lЏ\O�|�~�~�g�V�R�mI{Hh � Fig.3 Structure of the justice operate system�case of Liu Yong � �N�V3eg w �(W�mB\SO�s@w+��[6�B\�Q�z�v�l�_�N�N �ۏeQ�N�S�l�[t z�^T �1u�ZSO�bS��Qeg ��S1u�NHh�NS_�N�N�S�e"��[�[�R�v�`�k�]ݍ�T�S�l�[t�v�v�[:ONlQ_ � �_w�:_'Y�vQ�~���(��u�Tf[��v�c��0:_'Y�vl�����O?e�^�NeQvQ-N �Cg�R���[�S�l�[$RǏ z��eQ�O�S �g�~���Q�[t�~�g0�[t�v�~�g�Tf[��v�c��\O:Nte*N�l�_�N�NЏ\O�|�~�v���Q�O�S ��v�c�S��0R��eQ�O�SN�z0Cg�R�� T�e�[�ZSO�bS��TQ�~����e�R�S�R�Tq_�T �_�[�T�c6R���0 (Wُ$N*NHh�N-N ��[�[�N6�B\�T�S�l:gsQ�v N�O�N ��R N�S�l�[t�v�v�[:ONlQ_�TTg;NAm�ZSO�v1Y�XOlQO���zzMRN�0R�mHh-N�Q�s�v N�[a��fN /fN*Nyr+R�V } �,g�e�b�[\O:Nf[�����-N�vN�Regxvz0ُ�NN�[a��fN�TlQO���v^ NN� �u�*b6q�[�z �v^�[�N�[�[t�~�g�Nu�N�Q�['`\O(u0FO�[ NFO�l g�_0RlO�v���S�T�b�b ��S ��b�XNGr0�V:Nُ�QMON�[(W�QwQa��fN�v T�e �_N�_0R�N�vS_�v�~Nm)R�v �O�N�N���N��f��]�v�N f'`\O(u0�k�Y�T\�n^?e�^�e���RlQ�[lQ_h�`�y\�[�Hh_U\��g0 Y�g �=\�_�~�O0�e���ZSON*N�#��N�vT{ Y0(Wў��_lw�YfN��;Nc N �w�Y8^�YO���[dkHhۏL��Nxvz �nx�[1u?e�l:gsQ�O�lۏL���g0 Y�g0 dk{|Hh�N-N�v>yO����Q�s�T�SU\�v�R`Ǐ z_N gN�[�vyr�p01u�N�N�N,g���v?e�lOea'` ��ZSO�bS�ǏHh�NT ��S0RCg�R�蕋S�R1\O\Pbk�~�~�bS�0Q�~����Tf[��v�����e�l�S���V O�~�ZSO �(Wُ̑ � O�~�ZSO�[Q�~����Tf[��c���v�Oo` O�/fUST�v � �Q�~����Tf[��v����KN���v\O(u�N6q/f�N�N�v0 �Cg�R��_N(Wg'YP��^�Q�[Q�~���ۏL��{6R0 O�~�ZSO0Q�~���0f[������N N����z �(W�m�SOea�v?e�l'`��e �(WCg�R�蕄v�S�R NHT�s�Q�e�v`�R0 40 Cg�R6�B\Ns^l�v�Q�z�Y[�_RI{Hh _ё�gHh0Y[�_RHh0ĞY�Hh0Ng`!`Hh��SO�s�NCg�R6�B\�Ts^l�v�Q�z0 _ё�gHh�Su(W1997t^ �S_�eQ�~؏�l gnf�S �Hh�N�l g�m�SY\Q�~��� � g�v�S/f O�~�ZSO�v�bS��TvQ_�S�vl�����0vQ�N�v N*NHh�O-N �Q�~���R�S%c@w�vS_:_'Y�v\O(u01u�N _ё�gHh��Y�V4-1@b:y ��TY[�_RHh��Y�V4-2@b:y ����k��xQ�W ��S gT�yr�p �@b�N,g�e\US�rR�g$NHh�v�S�lЏ\O�~�g0ĞY�Hh0Ng`!`Hh1u�N gN�[�v�v yO�w�v �O?e�^�vb_a��TZ�O�S0R(��u �@b�NCg�R���SN0RHh-N �v^w�0R�N>f'`�vq_�T\O(u0�lWSw�YfN��I{w^ gsQ���[��Bl�[dk�N�b'}�e��%N���gY �lQ_���b � �Q N�Yo`0,gHh-N>yO����[�S�l�[$R�vq_�TwQ gN�[�v��['` �u� _ё�g,g�N��� ��]/f{k(W�N����vKb-N ��ZSO�vǏ!n2n�g���NOdkHh�Q�s N@g N��s^l$a �v@\b�0ُ�f�[>yO���_N�� gN*N�[‰�v��Ƌ �>yO���v^ N;`/f�Nh�ckIN � g�eP�ZSO����[T_NO g��0,gHhCg�R��v^�l gՋ�V�c6R�ZSO�v�bS� �/f�V:Nُw��N����NHh-N �����v�w4YN���cT _ё�gُ*NCg�RgbL��,g�N ��N�NLeƉ�v/fN*N ��Ux�v��R��vlQ�[@\�$*,�������        � � �ββ��β΄hQh5hQhQh6h~YGh~YG5�>*B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph)h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^Jph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5�B* CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph3�$� � � \ v � � � � �,>6N^R������ ��������������������������� $1$a$gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YGR��� � � � Z \ t v � � � � � ��*2<6JN\2z $����� � �!�!�#�#�$%�'�˴������������紂������i���������������0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph/h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^Jph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph)� �!�#�$J&�'b)b+�-�-.�/z1j3�3�34^4d4f4�������������������6kdE$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�#"Zgd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG�'�'v)x)�-�-�.�.�0�0�1�1�2�2�2�2p3�3�3�3�3�3^4d4f4h4r4���εΜΜ΀΀����ε���i\Ci0h~YGh~YG<�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJphf4h4r4t4v4|4~4�4�����Y�6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed# �Dgd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�ZJ>gd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YGr4t4v4|4~4�4�4�4�4�4�4�4�5�5(:@;B;D;F;d;�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=����������z�a�G�G��������3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG<�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ�4�4�4�4�4�4�4����YB$�hdP�d�d1$[$\$`�ha$gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed*o$hgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd>$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$edAy�agd~YG�4�4N5J7>9(:B;f;=�=�=�=�=�=�������������$d�$1$Ifa$ed@�Rgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$edlP�jgd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG �=�=�=�=�=�=�=���m�Y$d�$1$Ifa$ed�(�gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�"x?gd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd7$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a��=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=lBnBpB�B"E(E*E,E2E4E6E@EBEDENEPERE\E^E`EjElEnE�L�L�������������y�y������������������y3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG<�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ'�=�=�=�=�=�=�=���m�Y$d�$1$Ifa$ed� Kgd~YG6kd0$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�Zqgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a��=�=�=�=�=�=>�>�@lB�B"E���maaaaaaa $dP1$a$gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�/,&gd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a� "E(E*E,E2E4E6E@E����Y�E$d�$1$Ifa$ed�Cgd~YG6kd|$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�Bgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd)$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�E�`gd~YG@EBEDENEPERE\E���m�Y$d�$1$Ifa$ed >bYgd~YG6kd"$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$edxG gd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�\E^E`EjElEpE�EF�G���mVJJJ $dP1$a$gd~YG$�hdP�d�d1$[$\$`�ha$gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�N�Kgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kdu$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a��G�I"K�L�L�N�N�N�N�N���������$d�$1$Ifa$ed�7Ybgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed��gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG �L�L�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�N�NSST~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�Ͷ�������������w�]�[Ͷ������������U3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(0h~YGh~YG<�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6h~YGh~YG5�>*B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph#�N�N�N�N�N�N�N���m�Y$d�$1$Ifa$ed�Ah4gd~YG6kd�$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed&B�,gd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kdn$$If�r ���6��������3�4�a��N�N�N�N�N�NO�O*Q���mVJJJ $dP1$a$gd~YG$�hdP�d�d1$[$\$`�ha$gd~YG6kdg $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed��ygd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a� ����KNŏs_NO _ё�g(WN�[-N1\��$RY{kR0te*NHh�N�N�[�{US ��[tǏ zlQ_ ��N�N�l g�S�lP�%��v(��u ��[t�~�g yO����v N�g!j�WHT�s�Q�TR�m0�[l�Hh�v T�v`�R0sS1u O�~�ZSOTQ�~����T�wƋLu�v�Oo` O�/fUST�v ��e�S���S� �ُ/f1u�N�N�N�v?e�lOea'`O�_Cg�R���[ O�~�ZSO�TQ�~�ZSO�e�R�S�R ��N � �b�N O�~�ZSO�v1Y�X0 �Q�~����T�wƋLu�vKN���v\O(u/f�N�N�v ��N��v�N�v�NAm�TM�T�]��Yb_b a��lP �_�[@wte*N>yO����vp�T0 ,gHh-N�v�S�lЏ\O�|�~-N ��y�y�V }�v�N�N\O(ug�~�Ob�N�l�_6R�^�v�O9e�T�[�U �OvQb:N�|�~�vN*N͑�����Q�O�S0ُ�]�~�� g�vf[�Ɖ:Nb�V�elCgЏ�R�vN*N�=N�v_�Y0 �N�N Q�~��� Cg�R�� �[t O�~�ZSO�V4-3�S�lЏ\O�|�~�~�g�V�ĞY�I{Hh � Fig.4-3 Structure of the justice operate system�case of Huang Jing � �Y�V4-3 �ĞY�HhNNg`!`Hh��:N�v yO���N�S�l�[$R�v�N�RǏ z-N �>yO���\O(u�N�S�l�[$R�vg'YaIN�TgO�~�g0 ��N �>yO���N�S�l�[$R�v�N�N\O(u 10>yO����[�S�l�[$R�vq_�T �Ǐ�N NR�g �>yO����[�S�l�[$R�vq_�T�]�~>f �f�� �}�6q,gxvz�e�l�[>yO����S�R�~�S�l�[$Rvz�z �bY'Yq_�T\OϑSR�g �FO�]�~�S�N�S�sُ�yq_�T�v�W,g{|�Wyr�_0>yO����[�S�l�[$R�vq_�T�eS�b�v�cq_�T�SS�b���cq_�T ��e g�[Hh�N�[t�~�g�vq_�T_N g�[�[tǏ z�vq_�T0 �YMRb�mQ*N�S�lЏ\OǏ z�~�g�V@b:y ��QNN�k*NHh�N-N>yO����[�[�S�l:gsQ�[tHh�N �bN�[�v�v�cq_�T �؏ g�Q*NHh�N-N �>yO����ǏؚB\Cg�R���[�S�l�[$R�e�R�S�R ����cq_�T�S�l HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn3" \o "" [b$]0*N+RHh�N-N �vQ�v�cq_�T�T���cq_�T T�e�S%c\O(u0 >yO����e���[�[t�~�g�Nuq_�T �_N���[Hh�N�v�[tǏ z�Nuq_�T0�[�[t�~�g�vq_�T_N g}YOWKNR0�[‰eg w � _ё�gHh�T _f[��~bHh-N����[�[t1\�Nu�N No��v�S�R�Tq_�T0>yO����[�[tǏ z�vq_�T �N*Nf>f�v�OP[sSY['YHSHh�v�^�[ �/fxQ�W�vZP�y0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn4" \o "" [c$]ck/f�V:Nُ/fN*N�S0RlO0�ZSO�TؚB\sQ�l�vHh�N0 20�S�l�[$R�[>yO����vur_ >yO���N�S�l�[$R�v�v�NsQ�|/f�N�N�v ��S�l�[$R�[>yO���wQ gur_\O(u0 �S�l�[$R�[>yO����vur_ ���HQ/fN�yƉ�~ N�vur_0\O:N���;NSO�vlQO �/f�(W�v�[�NY�>yO gN�[�vqQ T�wɉ �b��[wQSO�v>yO�sa��T� g�vя w�l�v�N�0����v�[SO/f�s�[>yO ��N�ST�y>yO�sa�0�0����[SO N T z�^0WwQ g�N��'` ��[�N�v�c ��_�0W_�SlQO�SN���� �b_bY�y>f'`���0�l�_�N�N �$\vQ/f�N���k��'Y�vƖ-N�S f>yO�w�v�v�l�_�N�N ��_�[fur_\O:N���;NSO�vlQO�vƉ�~�T�la�R0�V:N�l�_�N�ǸTSO�s@wN*N�V�[�v�ef z�^�N�S�[lO�vTy�Cg�v�v�O�b z�^��S�l�[$R�vǏ z��Y�S f�QlQCg�R/f&T��ckS_L�O �lQs^ckIN/f&T��Y�[�s0ُNlQO-N�v�k*N*NSO�v)R�v��o`o`�vsQ0@b�N �'Yĉ!j�v�s�N>yO�����Y�vƖ-N(W�l�_�N�N�SvQ�S�l�[$RKN-N0 vQ!k ��S�l�[$R�[>yO����vur_ �؏h��s:N�S�l�[$R�v z��N �[>yO����v�o�S0�S�l�[$R�v z��N g�eSO�s:N�~�g�vz��N�_NS�b^�z��N'`�vN� � � g�eSO�s:NǏ z�vz��N �ُ�N���Oۏ�N>yO����R���S�vh�v�[�s �OvQb_bN*N�v�[3z�[�v!j_ ��N ��o�S�NlQO�Ǐ>yO����[�s݋�Cg�T�SNlQqQ�Nir�~�blCg�v�p�`0 �Q!k ��S�l�[$R�v�~�g g�eP��Y9e�SlQO�v�g�NN�s�N'`�v̀�y�v O�~‰�_ ��[>yO����v�Q�[w�0R\o�y؞S�vur_\O(u0 g�eP��Y9e�S>yO����vsQ�l͑�_0 gT ��S�l�[$R�[>yO����vur_ � g�eP�ǏCg�R���[����v_�[b��v�c T>yO����l��[݋���c�v�[�s0 � N ��S�lЏ\O�|�~�vN,�!j�W  ёW[TX!j�W }�6q�l�_�N�NCS�]N+R � N T{|�W�vHh�N�v�S�lЏ\O�|�~�� gvQ�ryr�v�~�g �FO�N�S�N;`�~�QN*NN,�!j�W0�ǏMR�e�[�l�_�N�N-N>yO��� N�g!j_�vR�g ��T�[8*NHh�O-N�v�S�lЏ\O�|�~R{|+RۏL��v�R`�~�gR�g ��S�N�_�Qb�V�S�lЏ\O�|�~�vN,��|�~!j�W �sSёW[TX!j�W ��Y�V5@b:y0 A �S�l�[$R �B O�~�ZSO �C f[��c�� �D Q�~��� �E Cg�R�� �V5�S�lЏ\O�|�~�vN,�!j�W Fig. 5 Model of the justice operate system te*NёW[TX1\/f�S�lЏ\O�|�~ �v��pA�Nh��S�l�[$R �v��pB�Nh� O�~�ZSO �v��pC�Nh�f[��c�� �v��pD�Nh�Q�~��� �8h�_�pE�Nh�Cg�R�� �v^N�_�_/f�V�[ؚB\Cg�R��0A0B0C0D0E:N�|�~�v8h�_�N�� }0S_6qN*N�S�lЏ\O�|�~-N � N�[OX[(W@wvQ�N�� } �FO���`\�S�lЏ\O�|�~R�g�{_ �1\�_{� �N�S���bOOvQ8h�_�� }egR�g ��[�NvQ�N�� }�fN�_eu N��0 �ǏMR�e�vR�g ���Y w�Q �ёW[TX!j�W-N�vB0C0D1\/f�S�l�N�N-N>yO��� N�g!j_�~�g-N�v N*N�g�p0 N��v�N\O(u �b_b>yO��� ��[AsS�S�l�[t O��Oo` ��e�Rq_�T0A�SǏeg_NTB0C0D�S���Oo` �v^�[ N��gb�v>yO���w�@wur_\O(u0 (Wُ*NёW[TX�Q萄v8h�_Y ���υ@w�S�lЏ\O�|�~-N�vN*N;N���� }E �sSCg�R��0ECg�R�� TB0C0D�Su@w�v�N�v\O(u �_N1\/f T>yO���(W�|�~�Q萐�'`�v�l��T�[݋0ُ�y�l��v�~�g � g�vh��s:NECg�R��OTA�S�l�[t�e�Rq_�T � g�vh��s:N�l�_6R�^�v�O9e�T�[�U0(W N�m�S0R?e�l�T6R�^�v3z�[�v�`�Q N �Cg�R:g�g�yr+R/f�V�[ؚB\Cg�R�� �N,�O�[�S�l���S%c��'`\O(ub N�Rr^�m � NO�Ǐ�ZSOp�0RMR�S�S_Hh�N�m�SCg�RP�%��b��lQO(��uX[(WCg�RP�%���e �Cg�R���yr+R/f�V�[ؚB\Cg�R�� �1\O�s���NMR�S �h���Cg�R�蕄v`�^ �v^�[�S�l�蕽e�Rq_�T0 ECg�R���yr+R/f�V�[ؚB\Cg�R�� �_NO�[�ZSOۏL��{6R ��R�V�c6R����[T0R�mHh0�[l�Hh-N�ZSO�v�z6q1Y�X1\/fxQ�W�v�OP[0�[�NDQ�~��� �Cg�R�� T7h/f(W�[L�@wg'YP��^�v�v�{0 O�ZlQqQ���W�v\Ջ ��Y�~��%N yOl��W6��k�S�lЏ\O�|�~@bX[(W�vg'Y�v�0ck�Yb�V'YYpef[�@b;N _�v�S�l�r�z� �t�`�v!j�W-N�[/f N�^�X[(W�v �S_6q_NS�b>yO����v�Q�s0FO/f � N��&T���v/f ��[�N(WS_MR�vu;m-Nnx�[/fX[(W�v0>yO����[�N�S�l�[$R�vq_�T(Wb�VYY�N>yO'YO�[�N�S�l�v N�O�N �lQO�vُ�y N�O�N�v�N�Q g�V ��[ N T>yO�egڋ�O�v��[h�f �>yOڋ�O�v�^���T4xOW�v;N�[�Rϑ��/flQCg)R0>yO���X[(W�N�s g�v�S�lЏ\O�|�~-N�vg'Y�vaIN(W�N ��[�N�S�lCg�R�TvQ�N�vCg)R�� g@w�vcw�T6Ra��v\O(u �sSO/f g�ePur6RؚB\Cg�R��eg_�[�S�l�� �FO/fُ(WS_MR_N/f gaIN�v0�V:N ��S gS_�S�lP�%��v�sa� g'YE^�^�v9e�U�T�md� ��S�lL�:N�W,g�����O�S�lڋ�O:NKN ��S�l��(W�^�zw��S�lCgZ�v�eP ��S�l�r�zMb��wck�vwQ g�s�[aIN0 �ُNR���S�N�Ǐ>yO����T�S�l�[$R�vo�'`�N�Reg�ek�v�[�s0 �V0>yO���N�S�l�vo�'`�N�R �T�l��e��:N�s�N>yO����v8h�_yr(�/f �[݋ �l� 0�s�N>yO-N ��l�l�V�[�v�S�lǏ z/f�l�_�[݋�vN*NxQ�0 O�~aIN N�v�[(�ckINb z�^ckIN�� gN�[�vΘi�'` �ُ(Wb�V�vMRl��Wg�v̀of N�f�Rf>f0b�Vl��Wg�^��[BlN�y�f�RwQ gTt'`�vckIN �sS OSFU�WckIN b��y:N �e z�^ckIN 0sS�S�l�[$R-N ��S�l:gsQ�T)R�[�vsQ�N�SlQO�Ǐ�v�N�v�[݋�Tt'`OSFU ��[�l�_�N�N�vYt��bN� �ۏ �b_b�l�_�vĉR, Mb��(WqQ Ta���vb_bǏ z-NN�v�OcckIN �Mb���c�R�[SO�l�_6R�^(WhQ��SN��vOSFU-N�e���[�U0(W OSFU�WckIN b  �e z�^ckIN -N �/UNnx�[�v/fĉRb_b�v�l� z�^�Tُ*N z�^�vckIN'` �sSOSFUǏ z�vckIN'` �sSُ�y z�^ckINp`p`SO�s�N �[݋ ,g��0 �Ǐ>yO����T�S�l�[$R(WSO6R�Q�vo�'`�N�R �OSFU�W�S�lckIN�v�|^yR���leQ0R�l�_�vgbL�Ǐ z-N0o�'`�N�R�S�NƉ:NlQqQ>yO�s�X-N>yO���N�S�lckIN�N�KN��(W�v�Nq_�T-N@b��b�v|_dkT\Ob�T��vt�`>yO�r`0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn5" \o "" [d$] �N ����N�S�l(WSO6R�Q�vck�TZS_ (W�l�_6R�^Fh�gRek�^�z ��S\ N�[�U�v̀of N ��e�vb�q�v�NT�Q�ZSO �(WN O�~�ZSO �$\vQ/f�b RKN���v�z�N0n�0�N�R�vǏ z-N �:N*N�N�~�bckS_Cg)R0:N�wƋRP[�SlQOh���a��0L�O݋�Cg�R-d�^w��NNYlQqQzz�� [5]0ُ*NlQqQzz���S�N g��]�v}�SO ��O�Y�b R0Q�~ � �N���e���c�y �Q�~�]�~b:N�vS_�1uh���lQO����X�v;N��}�SO0 g�v�ePlQl���O�r�v �/f�]���sL��l�_f�e�c�NlQl�vT�lCg)R � g�v�eP/f*g���l�_@b�O�b�vckS_Cg�v � g�ePvQckS_Cg�vp`p`�T�sL��l�_�v̀�y0(WS_�N�N�T ������� �vqQ T�R�R N �ُ�N�'YYۏeQ�N�S�lЏ\O�|�~ ��ǏSO6R�Q�vZS_ �sS�ǏT\ON��ϑ$N�y 8nbĉR N�v�N�R�e_ ����_�NN�[ z�^�v㉳Q0>yO����ǏN�S�l�[$R�vck�TZS_ �p`p`�ǏvQ�vcw\O(uO�6R�N�S�lP�%��sa��v�Q�s0ZS_��xvz�v͑�p/fT*Nt'`*NSO(WvQL�:N�Su�v�c�v�N\O(u�e�v�QV{NT�g�0ُ�yt���N�Q�zNT\O0�e�NN�YOS�v�[V{ ��b�SvQ�N�Rĉ�_:Nxvz�[a�0Џ(uZS_��egR�g>yO���N�S�l�[$R�vsQ�| ��Q N�N�N/fN*Nxvz�e�l�v��� ��V:N>yO���N�S�l�[$RKN���vsQ�|1\/fN*N YBg�vZS_Ǐ z0(WُNǏ z-N �>yO���\O:N SO6R�Q �v�s�N'`�V } ��S%c@wvQ�[�S�lckIN�[�s�vo�'`�c�R\O(u0�Nh�lONL�?e0�z�l0�S�lI{�V�[Cg�R:g�gۏL��l�0�[݋�TOSFU ��N ��[�slON�V�[KN���vo�'`�N�R0ck�TZS_�v,g(�yr�_1\/fT\ONqQb�0>yO����vcw�v�v(W�N�vcw�S�l0�Oۏ�S�llQck � ��S�l�r�z�v�v�v T7h(W�N�[�s�S�llQck �$N� g@wqQ T�v>yO�N yO;NIN�T�>yO�vۏ z-N �>yO����[�N�S�l�r�z�v�[�s�S%c@w�]'Y�v\O(u �@b�N>yO����vcw NFO N/f�S�l�r�z�v���x ��S �/f�vMRb�V�S�l�r�z�[�s�v͑���O��0>yO����v�vcwp`p`/fOS�R�S�l�[b�N�S�llQck�v�~�g�vh �(WT\O-N�[b�NqQb� �@b�N� �>yO���N�S�lKN���v�N�R/fN�yck�TZS_ � �ُ�yck�TZS_/f g�R�NR�^�T�>yOُNqQ T�v�SU\�vh�v0 v^^��Y�g�Nf[��b�_�v��7h �:_����N�S�l�v�N�ROr^���S�l�r�z0�S�l�v�r�z(WN�[ z�^ N���N�S�l�v�~�Q�\g�~�S�lP�%� �:NMR�c �>yO����ǏN�S�l�[$R�vck�TZS_ �p`p`�ǏvQ�vcw\O(uO�6R�N�S�lP�%��sa��v�Q�s0�S�lǏ z-N�v>yO��� � N�N�~>yOTLu�v gsQ�v�Oo` �_N T7h�~�l�[�v'Yϑ g�v�v�Oo` �����v�S�R�S���OO�N�f�R�[�NL��[ � �ُ�y�[݋�T�l��SO�X�R�N�vzfga �O�N�f�m;Rt�la�T�la0>yO����vcw�v�v(W�N�vcw�S�l0�Oۏ�S�llQck � ��S�l�r�z�v�v�v T7h(W�N�[�s�S�llQck �$N� g@wqQ T�v>yO�N yO;NIN�T�>yO�vۏ z-N �>yO����[�N�S�l�r�z�v�[�s�S%c@w�]'Y�v\O(u �@b�N>yO����vcw NFO N/f�S�l�r�z�v���x ��S �/f�vMRb�V�S�l�r�z�[�s�v͑���O��0�T�>yO�vN*N,g(��vyr�_1\/fYCQS �:_��v�NOS� ��R`s^a�0 >yO����vcwN�S�llQck/f>yO;NIN�T�>yO�v�Q(W��Bl0 ��N �OSFU�W�S�lckIN�v�`6q�[�s (W>yOl��Wg �S_�g�N�l�_6R�^ N�N N��^>yO��� ��S �;��x>yO�SU\�v�eP �1\Or�SN�NwQ gnfM�'`�v�l�_�N�N �_�SlQO�vsQ�l�T���� �ۏ �_�S�[��l�_6R�^X[�^�v�c�� ��Q1uf[�Ɩ-N|TTCg�R:gsQ�^bk�e�l �|TT��^��^�e�N�Bl�v�e�l0S_ُN�N�R�[b�v�eP �OSFU�W�S�lckIN_N�_0R�N�[�s � �ُ�N�N�N_N1\wQ g�NN�[�v&{�SaIN0�O�YY[�_RHh-N � NMO�lf[ZS�X NfNhQ�V�N'Y8^�YO ��^���[ 06e�[c���R�l 0ۏL�ݏ�[�[�g �g�~�Ob�N 06e�[c���R�l 0�v�^bk�T 0Qe�R�{t�R�l 0�vck_�[�e0Y['YHSHhT �f[��N�]�~�c�N�NsQ�N�c���[�g 0^��lё��:g�g�T^��lё��N�R;m�R�S�R�l 0�v�^��fN0 gf[��Sh�ċ��� �Ǐ�S6R���vN�NN^:W�~Nm�SR N�v��^�v�l�_�lĉ�N�_�Ocku�^bk �ݏ�S�Nُ7h�v�l �*g�_/fN�NOW�N0 �ĞY�HhR�c�R�NhQ�V�N'Y8^�YO�Ǐ 0sQ�N�S�lt��[�{t��v�Q�[ 0I{I{0�yΘ(W 0fN�Q-N�V�N�vCg)R 0-N�0R �lQO _N� N � N0W�SN�N�z�l�T�S�l �v^�ǏN�S�l0?e�l�蕄vOSFUN�N�R �O�l�_�v�[�eT@wQeNm�S�[�0�f�[�U0W�O�b�Nl�vCg)R�v�eTbaoۏ0 ��kN*N��S'`*NHh�v ^�a�VT�g b �n�QHe�^ �_N(W�c�R@w�l�_ĉR,g���Su�Si� �sSP�R�N?e�l�蕄vr^�� ��l�_SO�|��nۏ0W9eo��N 0 (W�l�_‰�_B\b� N ��Ǐ>yO����T�S�l�[$R(WSO6R�Q�vZS_ ��ǏlQqQ�wƋRP[�v�R�R�SN ��Ǐ*NHh-N*NSOCg)R�S0R�O�b �ۏ �OCg)RaƋ�f�meQl�_ � �OSFU�W�S�lckIN�v�|^yR���n�leQ0R�S�lǏ z-N0ck/f(W>yO����T�S�l�[$R�vُ�yo�'`�v�N�R-N �$\vQ/f(WN�NwQ g&{�S'`aIN�vxQ�W�l�_�N�N-N �(WlQqQ�wƋRP[�v&^�R N �lQO��eg����Y�N��Y�v�p�`�SN0R�[wQSO�N�N�v����-N �$\vQsQ�lvQ̀T�v gsQ>yOlQO)R�v�v�~�b0 ��kN!k�O�b�S�[�0�O�b�Nl)R�v0�cۏ�z�l�[�U�vo�'`�N�R�~�g ���OlO�S0R�o�R�T��0�S0R���vlQO\O�~�~�N�f'Y�v�p�`�beQ0R�[lQqQ�N�N�vsQ�l-N�S ��l�_�O�N\o�y؞S(WlQO�Q�_b_b0 � N ��S�lckIN�[>yO����vo�'`_�[ (W>yO����OۏOSFU�W�S�lckIN�v�[�s�v T�e �OSFU�W�S�lckIN�[>yO���_N�S%c@wN�[�vo�'`_�[\O(u0 ��HQ �OSFU�W�S�lckIN�[>yO����v�u�[\O(u0S_�l�_�N�NSO�s�N>yO;N���w�v�e �l�����'YYh��s:N(`� �(Wdk�W@x N1ut'`�v ����|� �c�Q��0l�����@bSO�s�Q�v N�n�`�~ �(WlQqQ�wƋRP[@b�Nh��v����|�v&^�� N ��_�_��Y(Wُ�yOSFU�N�R�vǏ z-N�S�_��T�Nt'`0 �ُ�y�l��T�[݋�S�S�N(WN�[ z�^ NOt'`�vl������_0R�n�� ��k�Y�Hh�N�vYt�~�g�O�b�N1_�R�v�S�[��vCg)R �b��N�N&{T>yO�SU\���R�v�l�_�lĉ�_�N�[�e0OSFU�W�S�lckIN N�N(Wُ�y�N�R-N�[�s ��SǏeg_N��Y��lO�v N�n�`�~�S�e0W�Ǐck8^ nS��S�l�Qeg ��_�_�S�N㉲Q�z ��md��g�N\o(W�v���` �(WN�[ z�^ Nw�@w >yO�[hQ� �v\O(u0 vQ!k �OSFU�W�S�lckIN�S�N�cؚ>yO����v(�ϑ0����v(�ϑ/fc���@bh����v�N yO6�B\0 N T�v�Su��V0 N T�v����[SOI{I{RRX[(Wzz���v � � N Tzz���v���;NSO�v�eS4ls^�T�Oo`�c�S���RASR�`�k [6]0'YO�P*N�NN7h g�eO g�v$R�e�Tt� �_N8^8^&^ g�_Y^�t'`�V } ��v�NKN��_NO gN�[�vRgk0FO(W>yO����T�S�l�v�N�R-N �(WOSFU�W�S�lckIN�[���vǏ z-N �>yO���-NRgk�v��㉒N�v�~ck �GdFd�v‰�p�N�v�b�m�NT �O�n���N�V�[0@b�N �(WOSFU�W�S�lckIN�[�s�vǏ z-N ���Yb��(W�N�v�Q�zKN N���_s^a� �ُ�yޏ�~ ��v�N�ve�EQ�nOgT�va���f�cя�N�[0 ,{ N �OSFU�W�S�lckIN�Oۏ����v�Z�N0WMO�v�cGS0(W�[�sOSFU�W�S�lckIN�vǏ z-N �>yO���ُNl��'`(��vCg�R�vcwD��n�[E� N�QNN/flQl>yO/UN��YN:_'Y�vlQCg�R�l��T�[݋0�[�\�T�ba��v�Rϑ�n�l0�S�N� �l�����(WُNǏ z-N ��S%c@w��eg��͑���v\O(u �>yO҉r�0WMO�n�cGS0 �S��e.s� [1]  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/" \t "_blank" RNgf  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/fyx/" \t "_blank" �Q�N�.�S�lǏ z-N�v���b__�SvQ�s�N'`yr(�[J]. �Q���S>yO�yf[, 2006�3 �. [2] O��[�h. �|�~��[M]. S�N�nNS'Yf[�QHr>y, 1995: 201 [3] ���m.ꁨR�c6R�b/g(W�s�N�{t-N�v�^(u[J].���[�] z�b/g'Yf[f[�b. 2003,(6): 32 [4] UO�Q. �laNl�`  �l6R�v6��h[M]. S�N��V�~�QHr>y, 2003: 136~140 [5] �yΘ. �elCgЏ�R�fN�Q -N�V�N�vCg)R [J]. 0FU�RhT R 0 �2004-1:5 [6] [A]C. H. Cooley. Social Organization[M]. Schocken Books, 1963:185   HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref1" \o "" [`$]�Wёy��v�2006t^ў��_lw>y�y�WёNy�y��v 0�T�>yO-N>yO���N�S�l�[$R�v�N�Rxvz 0(y��v�S06D028)6��k'`xvzb�g0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref2" \o "" [a$]ُ̑c�v�l�_T�gS�b�[$R�~�g�TvQ�NT�g ��O�Y�l�_6R�^�v�^d��T�^�z0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref3" \o "" [b$] ُv^ NN�S�l�r�z/f�v�`0ُ���~Tb�V�v�S�l�s�rwQSOR�g ��vMRb�V�NY�Nl��W�eg ��S�l�vP�%��T�S�l z�^�v NlQ_0Cg�R�[�N�S�l�vr^�mI{�sa�OlO���N�^�zw��[�S�l�v�O�N �ُ�y N�O�NMb/flO�_�_ ^gP�R�N>yO���eg��0R�S�llQck�vwck�S�V0>yO���/fN�yo��vcw ��vMRvQ�fY/f(W.^�R�S�l:gsQ�[�s�S�l�r�z0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref4" \o "" [c$]nc 0"��~�e�b 02003t^11g5�e�bS� � �_4l�S�[ُ!k�[$RۏL��N^�8^��w�~�v�QY �u��bN>k͑�eň�O�N�l�^0 021N�~�~Nm�bS� 02003t^11g04�e�[dkHh�v�bS�R�c0R � g�mo`� �:N�Nd}Yُw��[$R ��lb��fZP�N{| yO�yf[ �2006�3 ��35 eg�n:u��?e�lf[b�f[�b2007t^,{6g *Q�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�����M�6kd $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$edqD!Igd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd� $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed��gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~����Y�E$d�$1$Ifa$ed�sngd~YG6kd� $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed��gd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd` $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�w`sgd~YG�~�~�~�~�~�~�~���m�Y$d�$1$Ifa$edh'5gd~YG6kdY $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�I,7gd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a��~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~�~*�0�2�4�>�@�B�L�N�P�V�X�Z�d�f���Z� �B�D����������������������z�`�3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG<�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphh~YGh~YGCJKHaJ�~�~�~&�D���*�0�2���������Z6kd� $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$edb'gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG$�hdP�d�d1$[$\$`�ha$gd~YG6kd� $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a� 2�4�>�@�B�L�N�P������Y�6kd� $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�B))gd~YG6kdR $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$ed�3Xgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YGP�V�X�Z�d�f����������YMMM $dP1$a$gd~YG6kdK $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$edk0�hgd~YG$�hdP1$`�ha$gd~YG6kd� $$If�r ���6��������3�4�a�$d�$1$Ifa$edYo,gd~YG��� �D�b�d�H�n���ԍD�l���d�����������R���������œ2��&�x����������������������������� $dP1$a$gd~YGD�F�`� �� ����2�4�2�4�:�<�n�p���d����������������������ʳ���~�����~���ʳʳe����~��L0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph6h~YGh~YG5�>*B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJphx�l�����ְ��Z���J�R�^����V����������6���¿��(�P�R�������������������������� $1$a$gd~YG $dP1$a$gd~YG��ְ�����f�h�зҷطڷܷ޷F�H�N�P�����������������������6�8������Ϛ��Ϛ��e��ϚK�3h~YGh~YG5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph6j� h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h~YGh~YGB*CJH*KHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph8�<�>�D�F�������������¿Ŀ������������������������\�^�d�h���������(�P�R��̳����̳����̳����̳����̳��̳�蜕 h~YGh�&y-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h~YGh~YG>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h~YGh~YGB*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph#01�82P��. ��A!�"�#��$��%��S�� ��EDd,������ � c �:A�����Normal�Fax0��1C"�j����P���� src="/webcount/count.asp?newsid=38027"��b�!X�����N�B���D6n��X�����N�B���PNG  IHDR��fsRGB@�}�0PLTE���������������������������{��bIDAT�E�!�0Eq��^u�M&V��Up�\ �&���C|�������)"3.8̴����(6 jPtsʄ��&��)�N�U- \^�w�& �^ey��ƾ�_�c|_���^9IEND�B`�Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� Q$$If!vh5�r #vr :V ��6�,�5�3�4� �Dd��� �V � 3 �������C"��J��� �((����N@��N ck�e $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@���$ ؞���k=�W[SOBi@���B nf�h� *S*�Y(phb^`b ~YGnf�(Q�z)'$�hdP�d�d1$[$\$`�ha$CJKHOJQJ^J"W`�" ~YG���p5�\�)J����� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� �� "&� �� "&� �� "&� �� "&� �� "&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&��� �nMLHr!�$�'J+n0O4.9�=B�G)JwP�X5Ip � : H  �� �wIf�������'/) � d h r � f � �z%���������� /249;>@EGLMOb���������������������� M\6H��������������� � �!�"d#x#N$S$U$X$Z$_$a$f$h$m$n$p$�$�$�%Q'T'V'Y'['`'b'g'i'n'p'u'w'|'}''�'�'�(E)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�) *�*�+,",1,�,�-�.�.�."0�0�021H1�1�1�1�1)2�2E3O4R6a6�7�8�8�;6=F=M?k@}@�@�A%C�C�CQDxD�D�D EOEQESEF�F�G�HJ(J+J�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r �d�r s;�r s;�r }R*�r s;�r s;�r s;�r $��r ��!�r s;�r s;�r $��r ?)�r ��!�r Y� �r $��r s;�r Y� �r ���r ���r $��r ���r ?)�r ?)�r �d�r $��r ��!�r s;�r �v�r ?)�r $��r Y� �r s;�r s;�r �v�r s;�r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r �� �r s;�r s;�r $��r $��r ���r ���r s;�r �d�r �v�r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r �v�r s;�r s;�r ��!�r �d�r s;�r &�r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r �� �r s;�r s;�r �d�r $��r ?)�r �d�r s;�r �d�r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r �� �r s;�r s;�r �d�r c�2�r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r �� �r s;�r s;�r �d�r ?)�r Y� �r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r <�<��r s;�r s;�r �d�r ?)�r ���r s;�r s;�r ���r Y� �r ���r s;�r s;�r &�r ���r �v�r �v�r s;�r ���r �v�r s;�r s;�r s;�r ?)�r Y� �r $��r I@;�r s;�r &�r Y� �r s;�r �]�r }R*�r s;�r I@;�r ��!�r s;�r �v�r ��!�r &�r ���r s;�r �v�r s;�r �v�r s;�r s;�r s;�r �v�r s;�r �v�r s;�r ���r Y� �r �v�r ��r �wIf�������'/) � d h r � f � �z%���������� /2349:;>?@EFGLMOb���������������������������� M\6H�������������������� � �!�"d#x#N$S$T$U$X$Y$Z$_$`$a$f$g$h$m$n$p$�$�$�%Q'T'U'V'Y'Z'['`'a'b'g'h'i'n'o'p'u'v'w'|'}''�'�'�(E)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�) *�*�+,",1,�,�-�.�.�."0�0�021H1�1�1�1�1)2�2E3O4R6a6�7�8�8�;6=F=M?k@}@�@�A%C�C�CQDxD�D�D EOEQESEF�F�G�HJ(J+JI�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�#"Z��@0�� I�0�I�0�ZJ>��@0�� I�0�I�0# �D��@0�� I�0�I�0Ay�a��@0�� I�0�I�0*o$h��@0�� I�00�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0lP�j��@0�� I�0�I�0@�R��@0�� I�0�I�0�"x?��@0�� I�0�I�0�(���@0�� I�0�I�0�Zq��@0�� I�0�I�0� K��@0�� I�0�I�0�/,&��@0�� I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�E�`��@0�� I�0�I�0�B��@0�� I�0�I�0�C��@0�� I�0�I�0xG ��@0�� I�0�I�0 >bY��@0�� I�0�I�0�N�K��@0�� I�00�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0����@0�� I�0�I�0�7Yb��@0�� I�0�I�0&B�,��@0�� I�0�I�0�Ah4��@0�� I�0�I�0��y��@0�� I�00�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0����@0�� I�0�I�0qD!I��@0�� I�0�I�0�w`s��@0�� I�0�I�0����@0�� I�0�I�0�sn��@0�� I�0�I�0�I,7��@0�� I�0�I�0h'5��@0�� I�00�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0b'��@0�� I�0�I�0�3X��@0�� I�0�I�0�B))��@0�� I�0�I�0Yo,��@0�� I�0�I�0k0�h��@0�� I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0wIf�������'/) � d h r � f � �z%���������� /2349:;>?@EFGLMOb���������������������������� M\6H�������������������� � �!�"d#x#N$S$T$U$X$Y$Z$_$`$a$f$g$h$m$n$p$�$�$�%Q'T'U'V'Y'Z'['`'a'b'g'h'i'n'o'p'u'v'w'|'}''�'�'�(E)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�) *�*�+,",1,�,�-�.�.�."0�0�021H1�1�1�1�1)2�2E3O4R6a6�7�8�8�;6=F=M?k@}@�@�A%C�C�CQDxD�D�D EOEQESEF�F�G�HJ(J+JI�0)\S�`�d�h�l�I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0�#"Z)I�0- \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�ZJ>)I�00 \S�`�d�h�l�I�0# �D)I�03 \S�`�d�h�l�I�0Ay�a)I�06 \S�`�d�h�l�I�0*o$h)I�09 \S�`3�d�h�l�I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0lP�j)I�0E \S�`�d�h�l�I�0@�R)I�0H \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�"x?)I�0K \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�(�)I�0N \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�Zq)I�0Q \S�`�d�h�l�I�0� K)I�0T \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�/,&)I�0W \S�`�d�h�l�I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0�E�`)I�0` \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�B)I�0c \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�C)I�0f \S�`�d�h�l�I�0xG )I�0i \S�`�d�h�l�I�0 >bY)I�0l \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�N�K)I�0o \S�`3�d�h�l�I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0��)I�0z \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�7Yb)I�0} \S�`�d�h�l�I�0&B�,)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�Ah4)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0��y)I�0� \S�`3�d�h�l�I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0��)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0qD!I)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�w`s)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0��)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�sn)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�I,7)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0h'5)I�0� \S�`3�d�h�l�I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0b')I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�3X)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0�B)))I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0Yo,)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0k0�h)I�0� \S�`�d�h�l�I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0)I�0\S�`�d�h�lh�I�0�0(J� �'r4�=�L�~D���8�R�*-/15<fkmn� f4�4�4�=�=�="E@E\E�G�N�N*Q�~�~�~2�P���x�R�+.02346789:;=>cdeghijlR�,IM� CG�cg-�-�-.�.�.�7{88�C�C�C�C#D'DSE�E�EF�F�F�FHGLG�GdHhH�HbIfIyI�I�I�I�I�I)JX��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X���� _Toc76553167_ftnref1 _Toc76553163 _Toc76602533 _Toc76602540_ftnref2 _Toc76602541 _Toc76602542 _Toc76602543 _Toc76602544 _Toc76602545 _Toc76602546 _Toc76602547_ftnref3_ftnref4 _Toc76602548 _Toc76602549_ftnref5 _Toc76553188 _Toc76553189_ftn1_ftn2_ftn3_ftn4_ftn5w�  ����5g#�*",-.�.11�76=k@SEF�F�G�H+J � = �h���5w#-+#,�-�.�.11�86=|@�E�FMGiHgI+J����4�=��t�=��$\A���_A��pH�H+J��zH�H+J8*�urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags�City�9*�urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags�place�;*�urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags�chsdate� $## �04�11�2003�5�Day�False �IsLunarDate �IsROCDate�Month�Year  JMQUknw�DGJQRYZ]�����@C������ JJJJJJJ#J%J&J'J+J������i l � � � � � � � � � �FlIoIJJ+J:::::z:::zf �F+JM�F+J�;56�w�H�Pl�w�H�~��w�HxG �f�h�"<':""�w�H}vd�w�H�v��w�Ht3��w�H���w�H��7i=At��w�H�a�w�Hh'5lbE;�w�H�LU�w�H�o�w�H��w�H5)�w�H� � �w�H� �w�H Je �w�H � �w�H�v� �w�H�� �w�H�}� �w�HLf �w�H�_ �6HO��w�HUn�w�Hpt��h��U��w�H��w�H�yW�w�HF��w�HDX�w�H�1��w�H�L��w�H���_X{��w�Hh,?"O��/F�w�H� �w�H�(��w%^��"D�#�E'�w�H}C�w�H!��w�H�Ca�( UV�w�H�$��w�H5D��w�H�`�w�H�p�w�H�j�w�H"O��6H�n �w�H���w�H�-� �w�H/j7!�w�HO,n!�w�H*i�!�w�H d"�w�H�"�w�H"D�#�w�H4=&�w�H�/,&�L�b'J H:�6�'Z`�>��'�w�HWY�'�w�Ha�(�w�H�B))4jdYo,�E}1*�,�w�H&B�,k�7pR0�w�H�qt1pt� XsaF2�w�H�y2�w�H�@�3�w�H�Ah4J�T�!�4�w�H�e�5�w�H>�5�w�H�:6�w�H�I,7At��e�7�w�Hk�7�w�H�L�7�w�H<�9�w�H<':�6HJ H:�w�HPv�:�w�H�4�:�w�H7i=�w�H Z�=�w�Hw�=�w�H�ZJ>�w�HZ`�>�6H�"x?�Cs�+�?�w�H�`�?�qt1,>Zp@�w�H�B2�wAZ�B�w�H�A�C�w�H�JD�w�H�E�D�w�Hwl�D�w�H# �D�w�H14E�w�HK/fE�w�H7�F�w�H�6H�w�H�w�H�qt1,�< I�w�HqD!IK/fE%f�I�6H,V�I�w�H� KsaF2�N�Kq�i�L�w�H:(�Q�w�H�^�Q�w�H�o R�w�H�KR�w�H@�R�+�?V�R�w�H�_kT�w�HJ�T�w�H�p�T�w�H��T�w�H�3X/j7!j(BX�qt1�K�_X�w�H >bY�v� ^c�Y�w�H�i�Y�w�H�#"Z�w�H�-L[�w�H�O\�w�H�w%^�w�H�E;^�w�H~ l^�w�H�}�_�w�H�E�`�E;^oa�w�HAy�a�w�H�7Ybocihlb�w�H4jd�w�H� �d�w�H.ne�w�HdCe�w�H��e�w�H�gTf�w�H*o$h�w�Hocih�w�HMl�h�w�H�f�h�w�Hk0�h�Pl��hq�i�w�H�X�i�_ �Aj�w�HlP�j�_kTO �j�w�H�j�w�H{�k�w�H�Ml�w�H2;�l�w�H��m�w�H�sn1*�,�1"o�w�H'7�p�w�H wq�w�HK=�r�w�H@v�r�w�H�Cs�w�H�w`s2;�l#{ts�w�H� �t�w�H�qDv�w�H�Y4w%f�I2�w�w�HU�x�w�H�0y�w�H��yw�=�xq{�w�H�fW|�w�H�E}�w�H�}K}�w�H_�}�w�H�9�}�w�H�F~�w�H��~�w�HU �~�w�H'l�w�H�Zq�-L[�}��w�H��$:~YG�&y/2349:;>?@EFGLM���������������������������������������N$S$T$U$X$Y$Z$_$`$a$f$g$h$m$n$Q'T'U'V'Y'Z'['`'a'b'g'h'i'n'o'p'u'v'w'|'}'�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)�)+J������������������������������������@�(J(J�Ă(J(Jp ')JPP P@PPP(P2PFP~��Unknown������������G��:�Ax� �Times New Roman5��Symbol3&� �:�Cx� �Arial;���(�[SOSimSun 1��hA�&�B�&� ?%� ?%�!-!),.:;?]}����    & 6"0000 0 0 00000��� � �����=�@�\�]�^���([{�  0 0 00000��;�[����������JJ3�HX��?�������������������~YG2�� Administratoradmin�������Oh��+'��0`������� ��  ( 4@HPX�Administrator Normal.dotadmin2Microsoft Office Word@F�#@n.ڐ�@��;ڐ� ?����՜.��+,��D��՜.��+,���� X`lt|� ������%J� �  8@ _PID_HLINKS�A� `;&-http://law.hit.edu.cn/fyx/$3*http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/-~'ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref5-$ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref4-x!ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref3-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref2-zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref1;&http://law.hit.edu.cn/fyx/$3http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/9.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn59.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn49. ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn39. ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn2$3http://law.hit.edu.cn/llm/9.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn1Ihttp://law.hit.edu.cn/llm  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmno����qrstuvw����yz{|}~���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������Root Entry�������� �F�;>ڐ���Data ������������p1Table����x�jWordDocument����2�SummaryInformation(�������������DocumentSummaryInformation8���������CompObj������������m������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ���� �FMicrosoft Office Word �ĵ� MSWordDocWord.Document.8�9�q
Baidu
map