��ࡱ�>�� ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������q` �R� bjbjqPqP2$::�������������������R�R�R�R|^SL��{��St*\*\*\*\*\�cTjf�wyyyyyyyyyyyyy$�|h&N�y���h*\*\�h�h�y��*\*\�{qjqjqj�h�*\�*\wyqj�hwyqjqj��qj*\�S P�sMm���Rj(qjwy�{0�{qjt9jtqjqj�t�Sy$h*hqj8h Dh�hhh�y�yUjhhh�{�h�h�h�h����4����4�tX������������ �S�l�t�v�VE��XLu  |Q�� �VE��rj��SO�| \O�: HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq" \t "_blank" �[eP:_ | �S^�e��:2010-6-22 6:37:14 | ���pe: 453 [,g�ehQ�e�Sh�(W 0R�N�lċ�� 0�R�N�lf[CSSCI�n R �,{26wS �S�N'Yf[�QHr>y2010t^5gHr �,{499-532u�0W� T�lf[�[0S�N'Yf[�lf[b�H�tQo�Ye�c(W ;Nn}� -Nċ�NS��  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_�v 0�S�l�t�v�VE��XLu  |Q�� �VE��rj��SO�| 0N�e �/f�[�VE�R�lxvz�vN�y�mS �$\vQ/fՋ�V�^�g�VE��rj��SO�| �ُN}T��wQ gN�[�vf[/g�`a��R 0] �S�l�t�v�VE��XLu   |Q�� �VE��rj��SO�|  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn1" \o "" *  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_ HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn2" \o "" ** N0�e���e��� �S�l�t �v�VE��XLu  �S�l���Q�^&T�t ��['` ��]/ff[/gN�[�R�݋�� ���T{Hh_N/f���['`�v �iR N�v��O/f� �S�l�^S_�YUOEQR�t ��[ϑ ��N�Svz�z`7h � Mb�{ EQR ��e�l�� �0f[Lu�U"k����e݋�� ��m�_�݋����e݋�� yO�v�l�l�݋��YwQ g9h,g'` �vQ�[Ype�݋��܏*g�on ��R��㉳Q0�S�l���Q�^S_U\:ylQ_0lQs^0�f0t'`0ꁻlI{I{Oo��T f6qwQ gƉ�:1Y'` �_N/fASRW��a0{��N�[ �VE�R�N�lb�ɋ���efNhQ7h,g�[��xvz ��vMR�] gpeCS�N0peNu� ���R�lf[0�VE��lf[0�VE�R�lf[Lu �v^1\ �VE�R�N�l�_�efN�v�Q\Oyr�_�SvQ�N yO 0 �VE��l N �VE��S�l:g�g I{ � �VE� yrr�*YǏ��f �N �V�Q�l 0yr+R/f -N�V�l ݍ�yǏ܏ ��bU\ُ�yƉ�v^ۏL��m�^x��vz�zX[(WY'YaIN�ُ/f{��~8^m�G��v� �_N/f}Y� �I{�_}Y�v�VT{0ُ̑�S��X[(W��0��(W�N��VE��S�l�[���l g�VM| �_N���l g�l�|R_^\�T�V�Q�S�lĉ����N/yY�N�S�N㉌T�(u�VE��l � N�N㉌T�(u�V�Q�lN�k���l0�N�[vz�z`7hbT�T{HhR}Y�v�S0�VE��S�l�[Y/f�VE��S�l:g�g �~�V �c ��v �v^Ng�~ ��N���wQ g �l�|0L�Ǹof�T'`+R�vGWa�'` 0bc�KN ��VE��S�l�[ N/f�Qzz�Nu�v � �/f�V�[��l�| ��v�|��Nh�0�Ydk ��N/yY�N N�S���S�N��VE��l��v�S �Ype�`�Q N ��N/yY�N��HQ/f�V�Q�l�T�k���l�vN�[�T�|�0�S�a�VE�?e�lNY�N0u��S�aN,��VE��l�v �l�v b �Q�l�v �VE��S�l�[ ��S�S N gǏ �FOُ�e�]�� �VE��l�l �T �VE�R�N�l�l  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn4" \o "" [2]�v�e�N�[�R@b�mpl0ُ�y�VE��S�l�[_N N�S��(W�VE��S�l��S NYu N*Ya�7h�v $R�O W��N  :N�NHNُ7h�bT��S�VASR�{US��l�_ }{QN�b���v$��p;N��P͑�V�Q�l�T�k���lĉ�� ��VE��l�fY�v/f\O:NN�yyr�[ �l�_�wƋ X[(W � ��VE�?e�lNY�N�m{QN�VE��S�lꁻl�SR N/f�k N�vsQ01\/f'} _�[�z0 �tEQR �v�VE��S�l�efN�yr+R/f(WR�N0lFU0�NCgI{���W � �d��N���� �VE��l �v�vsQĉ�N�lt �Y��eIN�ʑY�R�R��/�v�v�� � ��fY�v�Q�[/fU\:y �t ��V g�v�V�Q�l�T�k���lo�~�R�R�N,�Cg͑��(W50%�N N �gؚ�v�S�N��0R80%�N N �0ck�Ydk �{�MbZW�[0W��:N��VE��S�l;N��1\/f�VE��S�l�[�v�V�Q�lN�k���l�R�R(W�VE��S�l��S N@bۏL��v�l�| �t yr�b�v�VE��zX[��mplb _lb �0ُ/fNLuHQۏ�l�|�S�l�|��N�v�VE� �b�Q'Y[� ��YUO�O`� EQR�t �����l�|c��v^Am��CS�S �ck/f�VE��S�l�[�N(W gP�0ؚ��0�r�z�Ng�Q�v�~�[�Q�R0�[ُ�y�~�k�|�zQ� ��Nu�v�S�lUx�gۏL���w��[ �w�vN�V�Q�S�lۏSNf[/gb� sQ�| N'Y T� {� N�N:N6q0�c�[ �S�l�t�v�VE��XLu �ASR�_�� �ASR͑��0{�xvz�eT@bP��ُ_N/f�mSxvz@b�_{��v � �,g�e�e�R\ �VE��S�l�efN �vhQof_ �t�XLu NQSb=\0�VE�R�N�lb�/fNLu N/UN8^���vR�N�lb� �vQ�VE��l;NSO0WMO��!kNT�T s^w�s^PW 0�1998t^���z02002t^uHe�Neg ��]�~ЏL�Yt^ ��[��t'`N$R�O�lR�cяb�q �����N

f6qwQ g8^ĉ'`�T�~xQ'`0�vMR�lb�qQ g�V*N�rj�`�R�l;NR�g0LNr^��0-N^�qQ�T�V0ς9N��\�[\ �08*NHh�N��h�[�[ɋbS�s�R ��h�[�[ɋaSfW�R�T] ��h�[�[ɋ�~u����h�[�[ɋ�<\0eY��0��KQ�~�N0eY�_wm�YZS�Tf�e��h�[�[ɋ!�ZS��h�[�[ɋ�T&O�T�^��_ ��h�[�[ɋ�] �\ ��h�[�[ɋ?�^��R�� � ��mHh�u�r/��JT14�N �{k�N1�N���KQ�~�N ���LNr^��?e�^�Q�Q�k � �0RHh5�N�bS�s�R0aSfW�R0]0!�ZS0�R�� � �(W�8�N��O�[d�Y ��?e�^�[XT3�N��T&O0�^��_0�] �\ � �N�NP��Nς9N��\�[\�`�R00RHh5�N-N �l;NR�g�`�R3�N�bS�s�R0aSfW�R0] ��1�N(W� � �-N^�qQ�T�V�`�R1�N�!�ZS � �ς9N��\�[\�`�R1�N��R�� ��3�N(W� ��LNr^���`�R�e�N0RHh�4�N(W� �00RHh5�N-N �3�N�|�V�Q.�Ucl��VE�.�Uc�bS�s�R0aSfW�R0] � �1�N�|�VE�.�Uc�!�ZS �1u�k)R�e?e�^.�Uc � �1�N�?a0RHh��R�� �00RHh5�N-N ��QNN��/f�S�Sfkň���� �/U g!�ZS�|S_�e-N^�;`�~^TX��v �WY.^�Q �FO�rj���SvQ�����N�e/fl;NR�g0W�e�S�Sfkň0 �lb��`�R NY0Hh�N NY00RHh�u�r NY �FO/f�VE��S�l w͑ h�b�ckIN � HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn5" \o "" [3]�l�[�Q�N�_�N ���Q �݋ �ɋ��_8^A~�Q ��efNim�Y�pwm0yr+R/fN�e�N�r0RHh ��l�^�zsSw�eQ�N���lmo ��~8^/f�eq\Owm0Y4Yv^ۏ �ɋ��/e�y4x�x0���NteT �R�^_N��� N�e�N}T �r�N�l�[ �u�N�^�[0�N,{NHh:N�O �IQ/f ck__�^�[$R ,g��1\�S����eJSt^u�Nt^ �1\ޏ;N�[�l�[��]1\�e�l���w �~�~�e ��^�[{U_�v�NpeN��^���N�`a�0ُ1\/f�VE��S�l�:N�N h�b�lQs^ � He�s �_{���ek0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn6" \o "" [4]b�S�f�ߏeg�vckIN_N/fckIN ��eeg�v^�ckIN N�S�[�_0�Ydk ��S�l�efNKNA~YN�Q� �_N1\�S�` ��w0 ߏeg�vckIN_N/fckIN ��[�N �[MR��b �T �[-N��b �S/f �OY � R�N�l�l KN�ej�c�[�v�W,g z�^�SR �_N/f �VE�R�N�l�l KN�ej�c�[�v�W,g z�^�SR � �� �>f�_aINyr+R͑'Y0 �[MR��b �T �[-N��b �vS_�N �QRZ �(Wb�V/f �SR �^� �OY ��Y�g ckINeg�_*Yߏ �yr+R/f �ejʑ>e � �O&^eg~p��'`T�g0�Vdk �1\-N�V�vyr�k틃X �� � ߏeg�vckIN_N/fckIN 1\^\�N �kw�0^��NS� YeIN0ُ/f v`'`�_�s ��V:N �kw�0^��NS�YeIN KN�['`�v;���MR�cck/f�e�^�c�S{_�^㉄g�v �[MR��b�T�[-N��b KN@b� �SR 0 X[(WsSTt N/f�NHN�e���s?Qa?Q �b�N�[dk�Y�~ؚ�^f��`��b X[(W Ɖ:N N�S�d�R�v �V�` �T9ei� MR�c �ۏ �~g�a0�mS0_Su�c�eHQۏt�_N�~xQ�SR �_N�\ g�QCSt^�v�S�S01\dk �� � ߏeg�vckIN_N/fckIN �ck/f���� �[MR��b�T�[-N��b KN@b� �SR �vf[tKN�  �l�l�V�[�vR�Nɋ��:NUO�S�N�eP�A~t�T�Q��1\/f�V:N�N�rY�l g�cMR ��w��VW �@b�N�N�r I{�_w�   b�N�S�c�S ckIN � N��I{YEN�b�N N�c�S ^�ckIN � N��eg�_Y�_0 N���S�lǏ z�vg�~�~�g�YUO �b�N`7hMb���e�[g�~Ώ�c�v/f ckIN � N/f ^�ckIN bT�ُ1\/f�S�l�_{� EQR�t �v9h,g�S�V0�S�l NFO��(Wg�~���Q-N EQR�t � �N���b�S�lǏ z�hQ0��01udk�S�� � �S�l N�t b �S�l NEQR�t ��mB\�S�V؏/f gj�c�[ ��~�g�S�V/f �N�l t�_0 {��]�[ �VE�R�N�l�_�efN�v�Q\Oyr�_�SvQ�N N{��Nf͑ �T{Hh�(WvQ-N0��HN � N�N{| N�v _��b gmQ�~h���v���Q�vU_ �l�^�vgT���Q�Ny� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn8" \o "" [6]�l gReQ �vU_ ���:NGY*`0N,���:N �wQSO���Q�Ny���~�� �/f���Q�vupB� �_N/fT�eS_�N�N�T�SN�N%`�NǏ�v�v�k=� ��Vdk(W �vU_ -N,g�^�N���v�e_R�Q0b�� g�N�V�^{�����Q�~����(W�efNgT � N(uR�Q���{�f~b0R0{� N�N:N6q ��S�V/f��VE�R�N�lb��v'Yϑ���Q ��O�Y���[R�^0�[$RR�^0 NɋR�^�v -N�� Nɋ ���QI{ �;`�~���v^D�8h�_a�� ��~8^/f�Q�s(W�efN_�{ �wQSO���Q�Ny���Y�g g �=�(WgT0�Vdk� ����Q�~��v^^���(W�efNgT �v^^�N�_�S�N {�f~b0R 0�Ydk͑���v���QtS���S�~���vU_ � kĉ�[�v��fh�Q& & & & & & & & & & & & .11 ��N ��l�^Ǒ(u�v��nc$R�e�e�l& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .12 10�]�b2���nc�v�vsQ'`�T��f�R& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..15 20�]�b2���nc�v�SǑ'`& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..16 30�]�b2��v�v�c�T���c��nc$R�e�e�l& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..17 40vQ�N��nc�Ny�& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..19 50�[�]�b2���nc�v�HhR�g�e�l& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 21 60�l�^�v�1u��ϑCg�SvQP�6R& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..22 � N ����e���[�c�ee�EQ��nc�c�Q�vb___���& & & & & & & & & & .22 �N0�h�[�[c�c�v�rj& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .25 �N �qS�[�N{|j& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .25 10qS�[�N{|j�v틃X�� }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..25 �1 ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..25 a.X[(W ;e�Q�NUOs^l�N�S �N�N& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .26 b.X[(W ^�lb g�|�~�v;e�Q & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .28 c.\Ov`��vL�:NN ;e�Q�NUOs^l�N�S X[(W�_��T��|& & & & & & & & .29 d. f�wُ�y;e�Q ��[�eqS�[�N{|j& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .29 �2 ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 30 a. MLC��(W2002t^10g26�e�2003t^3g15�eKN���[�e�N ���[l;NR�gs^l�N�S�v;e�Q& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .30 b.ُ�y ;e�Q /f ^�l�v & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .40 c. MLC�� f�w ُ�y;e�Q�|���[l;NR�gs^l�N�S�v& & & & & & & .45 20�gbqS�[�N{|j�vyr�[�� }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 45 a. �@g�vyr�[�� }�,{7y�c�c �& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .45 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..46 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..49 b.\O:NqS�[�N{|j�v:_xYL�:N�vyr�[�� }�,{1y�c�c �& & & & & & & .56 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..57 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..58 c.\O:NqS�[�N{|j�vw�RL�:N�vyr�[�� }�,{3y�c�c �& & & & & & & .67 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..67 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..69 ��N �b�Nj& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .75 10b�Nj�v틃X�� }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..75 �1 ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 75 a.X[(W^��VE�'`fkň�Q�z& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .75 b.aƋ0RX[(Wfkň�Q�z& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .82 �2 ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..83 a.X[(W^��VE�'`fkň�Q�z& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .83 b.\Ov`�aƋ0RX[(W^��VE�'`fkň�Q�z& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .91 20�gbb�Nj�vyr�[�� }& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..92 a.\O:Nb�Nj�v �@g�vyr�[�� }�,{6y�c�c �& & & & & & & & & & & .93 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..94 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..95 b.\O:Nb�Nj�v:_xYL�:N�vyr�[�� }�,{2y�c�c �& & & & & & & & & .96 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 96 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 97 c.\O:Nb�Nj�vw�RL�:N�vyr�[�� }�,{4y�c�c �& & & & & & & & & .98 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 99 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .100 d.\O:Nb�Nj�v_c�[*N�N \%N�vyr�[�� }�,{5y�c�c �& & & & & & ..101 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .101 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .102 e. \O:Nb�Nj�vm�R�vyr�[�� }�,{8y�c�c �& & & & & & & & & & .105 �a ��l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .105 �b ��l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .107 mQ0*N�NR�N#��N& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..114 �N � 0ĉ�~ 0,{25ag,{3>k,{1y�& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..115 10�l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .116 �1 � 0ĉ�~ 0,{30agĉ�[�v\Ov`��vEea�Tf�w�i�_& & & & & & & & .118 �2 �qQ Tck�r�[�[�e\O�[�[b�rjir(����N�vqQ T��R�v f�w�T�c�S& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..126 �3 ��u�r�[��YOvQNvQ�NqQ Tck�rOS�R�c6R�rjKN�[E��`�Q�vf�w& .126 20�l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .127 �1 �MLC��(W2002t^r^�m-N^�qQ�T�VKNMR(W2001t^ۏ{�-N^�qQ�T�V �T(W2002t^{�Nbl;NR�g�l��Y�]�l ��v�egL�:N& & & & & & & & & .129 �2 �(W2002t^r^�m-N^�qQ�T�Vg���b g�TRM�m�Rf����& & & & ..132 �3 �(W!�ZSHQu�N2002t^>mc���ۏ{�-N^�qQ�T�V�eMLC�� ��n�N hQCg�Nt�v�[���s�X �& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & 133 �4 �MLC��c%c�[2002t^(W��荊�eY��R_Lu�l ۏeQ-N^�qQ�T�V�e�vo��& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..134 �5 �MLC���XuQ(W2002�2003t^r^�m-N^�qQ�T�Vg�� �[���[�N�v�& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..135 �6 �!�ZSHQuN^TX�HQu�v�v�c�T8^ĉT��~�& & & & & & & & & .137 �7 �(W�Ǐ N T nS��]�~�wS�v^b���rj�[�e�v�`�Q N �N6q�~�~�[�eqQ T��R�& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..138 ��N � 0ĉ�~ 0,{28ag& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..139 10�l�_�SvQ�ʑ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .140 �1 ��u�r�_{�/f�Q�Nc%c�[b0WMO�vS_�& & & & & & & & & & & & & .142 �2 ��u�r�_{� gHec%c�T�c6R�Q���^\ � �b� gHe�{���T�c6R� N& 143 �3 ��rj�v�Su/f�V:N�u�r*g���Y�U�c6R�Q��� N �& & & & & & & .148 �4 ��u�r�wS�bt�^�wS�& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .151 �5 ��u�r*g��Ǒ�SNR�_���TTt�c�e �2�bk06Rbk�rj b�b��;N�{S_@\1\dk�NۏL���g�Tw�ɋ& & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..155 a.2�bkIN�R& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..156 b.6RbkIN�R& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..156 c.�b��;N�{S_@\1\dk�NۏL���g�Tw�ɋIN�R& & & & & & & & & & & & ..158 d.�_���TTt�c�e& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..158 20�l�^�v�z:W& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & .159 a.!�ZSHQu\O:N�Q�Nc%c�[ gHeL��Nv^�[�rj��ۏL� gHe�{���T�c6R& 160 �a �!�ZSHQu(WMLC���~�g-N�v�[�e0WMO& & & & & & & & & & & & .161 �b �!�ZSHQu gCg N���_{� g�N�v}T�N& & & & & & & & & & & & & & .164 �c �!�ZSHQu gCg�N}T0�cGS0M�NO0�d�0.�Uc0�bYu0ʑ>ec%c�[.165 �d �!�ZSHQu gCg2�bk06Rbk�rj�v�[�e& & & & & & & & & & & & & .166 �e �!�ZSHQu(W2002�2003t^r^�m-N^�qQ�T�Vg�� �[MLC���b g gHe�{���T�c6RCg�R& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..167 b.!�ZSHQu�wS�MLC��ck(Wb\���[�e�rj& & & & & & & & & & & ..172 c.!�ZSHQu�l g(WvQL�Cg��V�QǑ�SNR�_��Tt�c�e 2�bkb6RbkMLC���[�e�rj& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & ..178 sQ�N �vU_ B\�~ �O@bhT�w ��lf[xvzuf[MO���e0*N�NNW�bvQ�Nf[/g���e�v �vU_ �N,��S��� N�~h��0\O:N%N(��v�S�l�efN �,g���Q �vU_ h����0RmQ�~ ��N�N��`0�k�~�vU_h��KNT�� gwQSOu�xh:y ��efN�Q�tS����O)R0sQ�N �vU_ �Ny� ����Q�b�u�r�6q�r�Q0 z�^�S�S0�{��CgN�S�St'`0��fh�Q�+T��ncR{|0$R�eh�QN�e�l �0c�c�rj�+TN,��ltN�l�^���[ �0*N�N#��N�+TN,��ltN�l�^���[ �I{NQSb=\0�N N1\/f ,{NpSa� ���[0�~�0�[te0 ��N � �Q\Oĉ�{| f6q f�_!����r�x0JS*NN�~�Neg �f[/g_��ĉ��e���[�U ���[�v��l�]b��O0�S�l_��b��ck/ff[/g_��ĉ�c�~�[�U�v�Q(W��Bl0�l g��[_���v���e N�S��/f%N���v f[/g \O�T ��l g��[_���v�S�l�efN�e�e �Nt g�N 0 �KN�Q�Q �v�_h�0�S�l�ctǏ z;N��/f�[�l�N�[���nc0$R�OI{ �N�lĉ��v�_�^�co �}�6q yO�yf[���W�v [r��[�_ �b�N�[f�mBg���N ��[��;`/f���݋0 N�N�NKN0ُ,g��1\/fg'Y�v N%N(�0 �Y�g�[ �['` ��S�_�y�gb�g ��c Neg1\/f�[ �[ϑ ��v����01u�Nb�N�[MR�\�e�[�� ��Vdk�Y�g�~�~�[T�ۏL���[���� � e���N � sQ�N _�l�e_ ��lĉ�l gfnx��Bl ��W,gu��_�L��vf[/gĉ�0�vMR�L��v/f ��l_ �ُOMQ�S >\�l_ �v8h�[�p|`0��e�v�lx/fUS�~�v?��b/OpeW[0ޏ�~�S �-N�e�v�S�N�QWY NWWv^ c �ku��r�z�S �cR ��N RT�V�` 0 kĉ�[�@b g�e�N�^O(uA4 k�O!kĉ�[�N N{| �S�(u�v�l�_ �N/f,gb�8h�_�lĉ�0�VE��l�SR�TĉR0NLuN,��l�_�SR ��N/f,gb�$R�O�l�SR�TĉR � N/f�VE�b���v�NCg�QR0 N{| �l�_ �S g�z�l!k�^ N�v�]_ �v^�e�(u6�MO�v%N e_ۏL�T�l�v��{'Y��_N/f�Q\O�N�vCg)R0�VE�R�N�_^�N��/fNLuv��~'Y^ ��[f��{'Y�� �T�g N*X���`0@b�N �(W�VE��S�l-N ��e�N�{E^P�6R�vS_͑��0N,� �� ��l g�l�^yr+R�cCg}T�N ��vsQ�e�N�SvQ�V Y�� N����Ǐ�l�[P�6R0�Y�gN�[���z4x�l�[P�6R ��_{��NHQT�l�^3u��v^�S�_���S �=\�{HQ�eTOY�v�N�O�e g�Su0&TR ��N�N�V:N�{E^� �1\���NO��]=�eQɋ��4\,\�X0W0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn12" \o "" [10] 0�lb�ag�O 0���z�N N*N�{E^P�6RI{�~0 N����Ǐ100u��v�e�N g6�y�,{38ag,{1>k ���1 ��h�[�[fNb�3u�����[R�^�cCg(W gsQ�~�V�X�QǑ�S�g�N�c�e ��N�S��~�V�[���[R�^�v�V Ya����2 ��h�[�[9hnc 0ĉ�~ 0,{18ag,{2>k�c�Q�cCg��g3u���8h�g�V�Q@b� v^L� ɋ��� ���3 ��S�St'`�T�lb��[$RCg(��u��4 ��~�V�T�[tO��Bl���[R�^ Y���h�[�[ Nw�ɋ�Q�[��5 ��h�[�[��Bl���[R�^�cCgۏL�ck8^��g��6 ����[�N��BlT�P�vH���0 N����Ǐ50u��v�e�N_N g6*N�,{38ag,{2>k ���1 ����[�N1\�h�[�[3u�����[R�^�cCg��g\O�QH�����2 ��h�[�[��Bl�[�{��Cgb�S�St'`�ۏL����Q��3 ��h�[�[3u�����[R�^�cCg�OhQ��nc��4 ��h�[�[ gsQ�ryr��g:gO�v3u����5 ��SN�NT���[R�^�c�QǑ�SwQSO�c�e0�S^}T�N�T�cCgfN0�[Bl�V�[T\OI{��6 ���.�Uc�Nb���[j�N�vT�P��Bl0d� N��$N�y�`�QY �vQ�N�e�N�� N�_��Ǐ20u�0G� gyr�k�`�Q���>e�[u�peP�6R ��_{��S�_�l�^yb�Q0�,{37ag �dkY �,{36ag,{1>k؏ĉ�[� ���{u�peP�6R�e �h��0��l�T_(u�^���{(W�Q 0vQ-N ���l�T_(u���{(W�Q �O�_A~t_�l�eYυ��0,{4>kĉ�[� s^GW�ku� N�_��Ǐ300W[ �ُ1\O�_�[Ɩ'`0\W[�SL��e�e:g�SXN0,{2>k؏>e�[�N���{��Bl� +T g�W[_(u 0ĉ�~ 00 0ĉR 0b,gag�O�v�NUOD��N ��N�S +T g�SgqD��e0�l�_�Onc0{U_0ir���TvQ�N�vsQ^��N��Pg�e�v�NUOD�U_0D�U_ N�_+T ga��H��� ��� N�^���{(W�Q0,{3>k�[ "}_ ZP�Q�Nyr+Rĉ�[��SN�N�^�S�e�c�NN�N"}_ ��OfN���[�yb�Q �"}_�^S_S�b�vsQ�v�NT�Q���c�N�SD�U_�v�b����^0�Y�g g�_�� ��SN�N�S��BlR�^1\D�U_�v�Q�[\O�Q���Q0fN���[�yb�Q"}_b(WR�^���[�NT�^S_�zsSHT�ND�U_0 N0 �VE�R�N�S�l��$R�efN�~xQ7h,gVR�g    EQR�t �v�[(�pSa� �N � `7h�N�~�N�r�   EQR�t �vt�_N�N'`�W@x ���Q_�{�N�N(u�NN�k0 N0R�NL��e HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn13" \o "" [11]�N�~�N,gHh�N�r�6q�r�Q ��m�S�N�r�v�Y T0�VM|0�Qu�e�T�Qu0W06r�NNM�vP�Y T0�sL�N0�l�[�N �{-�v�W^t.�s�].!�ZSHQu �y|T�N�r ��l gO(u �N�r 0 �u�r I{/g�� HQu _N/f��e�v \�y ��vS_�NIl�-N�v T�_ bvQ�N�NHN �;`KN N+T g�NUO,�a0ُ̑_N�l g�NUO MR�y b No��TL� �N�~ �=\�{勺N MR�y �vnx�_Y�_͑ � �TL� _N� N NOo�0�Ydk�y�(W�lb�hQ��S�l�e�N-NN�N/�KN0�l g�OY0(W��U_��[�v�lb�hQ萭^��{U_-N �b�N_N�N*g�S�svQ�N�S4Y�y�0�VE��N�rN,�CN jv`KN$\ � NFO ��d�N{|o��w v^N�bUc Nf ��f g�epe���[�N�w@w@��~�v�S N�b0�zHh0��g0.�Uc0w�ɋ0�[$R0 Nɋ0gbL�I{I{��/fɋ���_�~�s�� ��k*N6��k؏ gOY�S�l;m�RN�N��0�Q�{US�v z�^�THh�N_NOubAS�NbpeAS�N�N N�l�_/�S�l�efN ��S�l�[ gIN�R�S�e0hQb�ub�efNv^tetbwS0vQ!k1\/f��Bl�S�l�[�[te0�S�e0WlQ_0����l�_/�S�l�efN0��HN Nub ���HN NlQ_ ���HN N��� �S_�N�NN�SN�N�YUO�wSf�T_����Y�gYpe�e�Nv^*g�O�lubb^\�NUS�e �y�[ ��S�l�[�S�YUO��YۏL���$R'`_���  lQs^ /f�VE��S�l�v8h�_�N

k �1u�N$N��JT@b(W0W0T Te\L�0WI{��(W TN^:S ��SJT��� ���~JTɋ �^-Nb���V��:S�lb� � �tS�� N�~�lb��S4Y�b�~ ��S}Yɋ��:S�lb�0UO�e_�^0UO�e܀ɋ0UO�egbL��w�ɋKN�e1\b�N�`Hh0 �{��_��_N}Y �3u���V�_N}Y ���/f�[�lb�0�l�[,g���v1Y�O0�Y�g��(��u� N����w�[�_0 EQR�t 0b` Y�O�_ �1\ ��j g�l b ꁨRe\L� �vsQ.�aIN �� �vQ�N���Q�Ny��SvQ �t /f&T؏ g�[E�aIN��b�~��~�N�_�T���� �{�� b �V� �N�� �1\S_�N�N�v NɋCg b 3uɋCg �� �_N/fN�y%N͑�v�S�l �bag   N�~�S�l:g�g gCg�~�~EQR�N�ُ{|ɋ����`�N�OhQb��[��0 ��V �  Sb�[�S1\/fSb��nc   �� ��fh�Q _N/f�l�[�vO}T  ��fh�Q �evidentiary threshold ��}�6q�O�e/f z�^݋�� �FO/fۏeQ�N EQR�t �v�[(�6��k0 N���z�l N�v ��fh�Q YHN�R,T ��NUO�l�_,g���� N�S���b h�Q ��0N,� �� � �� ;N��/ff[��vO}T ��Y�g؏/f�l�[�vO}T ��\ N/f���l�[ /}{k � �VE��S�l�[�v�VT{/f�m�g'`�v��� ��fh�Q _N/f�l�[�vO}T0���Q(u�r�z�v ,{�V�R �9�15u�057�k � HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn16" \o "" [14]�[ ��fh�Q 0 ��f�SR 0 $R�e�e�l I{ۏL��N��{'Y��0 EQR�t �/UP`S_�N�N Nf}v�l�[�[��nc�vt'`jR��`�0 ���Qc�Q�ɋ��6��k N T ��l�[��fh�QT_0�N N�� 0.�Uc�N 00Rnx��w�ɋ�Q0R�~�[$R�Q �ɋ����MRۏ ���fh�Q��ؚ0,g6��k�nx��w�ɋ ��v��fh�Q/f� /f&T gEQ����nc��f g�[(�t1u�v�O勺N�[�e�N@bc�c�v�rj 0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn17" \o "" [15]ُ̑�Q�s�N EQ�� �sufficient ��T �[(� �substantial �$N*Nb_�[͋ ��R�_�on ��l�[�v���p_N1\��KN �eg0�l�[ۏ �����9hnc 0[r%m͋xQ 0 � �[(� 1\/f ͑�� 0 ZW�V 0 ir(� 0 Sb �o�}Y 0 w�v KNa � N/f Z��g0�`a� �imaginary ��(u���[N�^�v݋� �1\/f �h�[�[�_{��c�OwQSO�v�T gb_�v��f �h�fvQyr�[;N _�v�ct`�npf�e� �9hnc�l�_ĉ�[ ��l�[���\O�Qnx��b Nnx�����Q��l�[:Ndk�_{�ZWc X[�u�e g)R�N��JT�SR �in dubio pro reo, �ej�c�[ �v�l�_ n�n �0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn18" \o "" [16](Wdk �:N�N EQR�t 0�on ��fh�Q ��l�[Ǒ(u�N͋�nf[0$R�O�l0ĉ��ʑ�T�l�_�{��V�y�e�l �ُN��_�~�vf[/g�e�l�QNN�l g�NUO�]_0  ��fh�Q nZi�N �؏�D�KN�N ��f�SR �evidentiary principles � ��l�[ۏ �c�Q�9hnc 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0Tag0,gb�$R�O�T�VE�lQ���v�NCgh�Q �,g�^\9hnc NR ��f�SR ���e�]�b2���nc0,{N ��vsQ'`�relevance �N��f�R���f�N

N�Q�Neg��]�w�T?S T���Nb���NH���Xd���v�v�Q��͋�eye-witness testimonies��v�c��nc �0�v�c��nc�c�O,{NKb�Oo` �q_�T�l�^O(u��~Ǐ��w�[�g ��Y�g�v�c��nc��O�Y�v�Q���N�vfNb�H��� ��e�vsQ�S�S`� � N��eg�UO�eS_�N�N ����NO�l�^K��NvQؚ��f�R��l�^�S��O�O�l�O`�ُ�yUSN�v�v�c��ncZP�Q�Q�e0���[6��k�S�NO(u?S T��͋�T��͋Xd�� �FO/f��f�R��NO ��V:N�[eR:Y�N���e(���:gO0���c��nc�v��f�R���v�c��nc:NNO �ُ/fNy��W,g�SR0�l�^}�6q N�b�~���c��nc�$R�O�l�R � �FO/f�R�_(�NaO(u��l�^ N��;N���Onc���c��ncZP�Q���Q0�l�^:SR�v�cN���c��nc � �N g�_�����[$R�e���c��nc�v�e�l0�l�^Ǒ�~ $Nekp��l �two-step approach ��,{Nek/fċ0O���c��nc�v�vsQ'`0��f�R�T�SǑ'` ��V:N�[�S��N�v�c��nc gsQ�,{�Nek/f$R�evQ/f&TX[(W |T�^'`��nc �corroborating evidence � � � N�Q�vQb__beg�n0�l�^�Vdk1\��nx����~TvQ�N��nc � gsQ��nc/f&TOteSO N���_ؚ��f�R0�l�^Џ(uُ�y�e�l1\�S�Nnx�O����c��nc-N�v�Oo`�S�N�_0RvQ�N��f�RbؚbNO�v��ncPO��0=\�{,gb� 0ĉR 0 NAQ����n |T�^'` �v�l�[��Bl�'`�f�R�rj$\vQ�Ydk � �FO/f,g�^��:N���`��bNy�;N _ ��N�N�O`�Ny���f�R��NO�v���c��ncv^ N�SL�0�Vdk �=\�{���[Ny�c�c�vhQ���nc��:ON�v�c'`0�N g���c��nc�/e�d �vQ��f�R_N���N�n�� ��fh�Q 0���l�[ZP�Q���Q0,{�V �vQ�N��nc�0��nc�v NN�'`�inconsistencies � NO�[��l�[�[���nc�vꁨR�b�~ �_N NO�Y�x�l�[�[�[�vO(u��l�[:N�NLu�[vQ��f�R �Oċ0Oُ�y NN�'`/f&TO�[���nc�vte*N�S�O�^�T�S`�'`�Nu�u�0�l�^O�[�g�k�N��nc�v�Q(WOS�'`�intrinsic coherence ���k�N��nc�S��O��fY*N� � NN�'`�S���SNyr�[� gsQ� N����fdk� �tS�S�N��f|_� ��Vdk NO�Y�x�l�^O(u0�l�^ NOꁨR�b�~;N��/f�W�N?e�lbvQ�N�R:g �eg�v���N\O�� � �/f���[vQ1\�[�_�k*N�_�[��v�S`�'`v^�~Tte*N��nc�ZP�Qċ0O0,{�N � �HhR�g�l �case-by-case approach �0�l�^��:N��k�N��nc^\'`�k_ � N Tc�c0�gb�� }0Hh�N�N�[�SvQ N TsQ�|yr'`T_ ��VdkMb��� �VHh6R�[ 0,{mQ ��l�^�v�1u��ϑCg�SvQP�6R0�l�^c�Q��l�^�N g^�l�v�1u��ϑCg�1uċ0O��nc �FOv^^��S�Nfk�eb�eP�6RL��N ��l�[�v�vsQ'`0��f�RN�SǑ'`��Bl1\/f N�S>����v��`l0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn19" \o "" [17] �l�^gT؏�[���e�vsQ_��ZP�N�V�^����e#�*`�c�eO(u S�bFO NP��N (u틂i�bc�c0�O�r���eCg)R ��l�^��:N N��b�z ��V:N,g6��k�S��Bl�c�e�c�O EQ�� � N/f hQ� ��nc0���e؏c#��c�eLu�[�rj�e:S荦^Ǐ'Y0�|�u ��mqN ��l�^��:N�c�ewQSOc�c�� g�|nx�e��0I{I{0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn20" \o "" [18] �‰���Q N�e � N�� ��fh�Q 0 ��f�SR 0 $R�e�e�l I{�gwb:N*NHh�wQSOc�c �R�g�vc�[�SR0(Wb�N weg �ُ�y �t f�_YHN͑��06q ��~‰ N�eMb�w�ُ�N�N/f�Qq\N҉0 ��N � �YUOۏL��[SO'` �t �   �rj��SO�| �v�VE�S��ck tete24u�070�kǏ�S � Rɋ�lf[� Ǐ���N>v ����Q�~�NۏeQ�[SO� �t 6��k0 R�lf[� �v'Y��b_�^U^& & �V0 �VE��rj��SO�| �e�    �rj��SO�| �v�VE�S��ck �N � �VE��rj��SO�| ��݋��N�eƉ�  �VE��rj��SO�|   N*NASR�N�v�e�e�0,g�eR6RُN/g� �v^^�_�`)Y_ ��f NO)Yl�L�zz0�bU\ �rj��SO�| �eƉ� �R6R �VE��rj��SO�| �/f{�c�~��[ �S�l�t�v�VE��XLu -N�v͑'Y�S�s0nx���rjKN@b�N��� SO�|'``�~ ���HN/f�Q�N ;��� �Q� ���HN/f�Q�N �~Nm �Q� �vQ�[g͑���v �1\/f�Q�N �N

e_RrR0�wƋ̀ofNf[�yR�]�Q�[ ��VE��lf[� N�S���meQ�c�� �VE��rj��SO�| � �u�[hQ N�a�����v+TIN06q �1u�N �rj��SO�| �f�~�Nv^�S���[�)R�v�QRrR0yr+R/f�YUO RT�V�` � �-N�VR�lf[�_N*g��1\ �VE��rj��SO�| �U\_���� � HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn21" \o "" [19]u:NW��a0vQ N ��VE�R�lCN�~T�l� z�^0�[SO0�~�~0�N�N0gbL� � � �[SO� �S�� N/fg'}도v� �{��N�� g�Nu:N j TLuR ��^\aIN gP�0ُ/f�VE�R�l�T�VE�R�lf[��v�`�T �{��~ N�� T0 1\ N���s�rN� ��� �xvz �VE��rj��SO�| ��y N_�V�Q�lN�k���lb�g�T�s�r�v g�Rc�[�bc�KN ��VE��lf[�T�VE�R�lf[,g�����N�[bُ�yx��06q �,g���ea�Q!kwSeQ �rj��SO�| �v�V�Q�lN�k���l�l�l � �/f�N�NPt�vQ-N�v �Ƌ � N�l�| �rj��SO�| �v'Y�yr�_ � �@w�Rx�� 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0�lĉ��SvQ$R�O�lRv^�S�s ĉR b�0ُ/f,g���vyr�kO}T�T!�.s0 b�� g�N�b�_�xvz7h,g/f&TǏ�N�r�z� N�� �~�� �YUO � nf�'` `7h�vQ�[ُ/fYQ�0��HQ � 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0/fď�N:Nbk1\�VE�R�l�[SO�ĉ�[�_g��[0gZfя0g8^ĉ�v�lĉ �_NgwQ g�~b'`�TR�e'`0��~�v 0�rj���N 0�fwQ g�~xQ'`0vQ!k ��YMR�e�,{N�� �@b�� � �VE��S�l;N��1\/f�VE��S�l�[�v�V�Q�lN�k���l�R�R(W�VE��S�l��S N@bۏL��v�l�| �t yr�b�v�VE��zX[��mplb _lb � 0�VE�R�N�lb��v�l�[t� ��f:N%N k,{1y� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn22" \o "" [20]�T,{28ag,{2>k HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn23" \o "" [21]ĉ�[�cw��vqS�[�N{|jNb�Njc�c�nx��9hnc,{28ag,{1>k HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn24" \o "" [22]ĉ�[�cw��vqS�[�N{|j� �@g0:_xY �Nb�Nj� �@g0:_xY0m�R �c�c ��b�~nx��9hnc,{28ag,{1>kĉ�[�cw��vqS�[�N{|j�w�R �Nb�Nj�w�R0_c�[*N�N \%N �c�c�\!�ZS�Ogqnx���vc�c��N�[$R�I{I{0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn25" \o "" [23],gHh�Ndk�~_g ���[ 0ۏeQ �[$R 0�VE�R�Nɋ����ǏNS�sQ.���i ��l�^N�l�[��sS 'Ybc@� 0,gHh���Q NX[(W�l�[ �r�za�� �separate opinion �N,�/f ^� T�~��0hQ�b�R�S�[�ctǏ z � ��f NX[(W\pe�l�[ �S�[a�� �dissents �;N��/f�S�[�~��0_N�S�[�ctǏ z ���Y�gX[(W$N� ����Nv^NYpea��ޏSOlQ_0,gHh�l�[�N�v�ctǏ zN�~��wQ gN�'`0�VE��rj�� }X[(W�V g�v YBg'`N YT'` ��Y�g�l g SO�|'``�~ ��_��ۏL��� }teTNnx��0��HN ����[�l�^�v�l�[�Nvz�z/f`7h �|�~0W �c�Rɋ��MRۏ�vbT��l�^�[�rj�gb�� }�vR�gSO�|vz�z/f`7h�vbT� 10 sQ�N {|j T �v SO�|'``�~ sQ�N {|j T � N�eeu g�N�N �_N1\/f 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0�v�V'Yj T �_N�S�N�y:NƖT'`j T ��vS_�Nb�V�v {|j T �_N1\/f�l�v�v Tbя f6q���R+RۏL��r�zR�g �wQSOR�g`Y N�j TN�qS�[�N{|j010틃X�� }�contextual elements ���1 �X[(W ���[�NUOs^l�v;e�Q ��2 �X[(W ^�lb�|�~'`;e�Q ��3 �\Ov`��vL�:NN ���[�NUOs^l�v;e�Q KN���vsQ�|�nexus ��20yr�[�� }�specific elements ���1 � �@g��2 �:_xY��3 �w�R0j T�N�b�Nj�10틃X�� }�contextual elements ���1 �X[(W^��VE�'`fkň�Q�z��2 ��[X[(Wfkň�Q�z�vf�w�awareness ��20yr�[�� }�specific elements ���1 � �@g��2 �:_xY��3 �w�R��4 �_c�[*N�N \%N0�l�[�[ *N�NR�N#��N �vR�g�r�zۏL� �'}�� �h�[�[c�c�v�rj KNT�#��NN�,{25ag,{3>k,{1y��qQ Tck�r#��N �0�1 �,{30agĉ�[�vEea�Tf�w�i�_��2 �qQ Tck�r�[�[�eqQ T��R\�[�[b�rj�vir(����N�vf�w�T�c�S��3 ��u�r�[��OvQNvQ�N TO�c6R�rj�[E��`�Q�vf�w0#��N�N�,{28ag�c%c�[b N�~#��N �0�u�r�1 ��_{�/f�Q�Nc%c�[b0WMO�vS_���2 ��_{� gHec%c�T�c6R�Q���^\ � �b� gHe�{���T�c6R� N��3 ��rj�v�Su/f�V:N�u�r*g���Y�U�c6R�Q��� N ���4 ��u�r�wS�bt�^�wS���5 ��u�r*g��Ǒ�SNR�_���TTt�c�e �2�bk06Rbk�rjb�b��;N�{S_@\1\dk�NۏL���g�Tw�ɋ0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn26" \o "" [24] b�N�N-N N���S�s�l�[R�g`v SO�| yr�_�vQN � j T HQL�0 #��N �kT0 j T /f�rj'`(� � #��N�b__ � /f �rjb_` 0 �rjb_` (W�VE�R�l-N�~�y �SN!j_ �participating model �0�Vdkُ̑@b� *N�NR�N#��N -N�v #��N � N/f'YF��l�| �rj��SO�| -N�v g#�'` 0�qQ T �ck�rNqQ�r �(W 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0-N��^\�N TN{| �rjb_` b �SN!j_ ��l�_N�[�R؏\O�N�f:NwQSO�vR{|0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn27" \o "" [25] c%c�[b N�~#��N R^\�N�SN{|�r�z�v �rjb_` b �SN!j_ �R_#��SRN�gb�� }NMR�:S+R�_'Y0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn28" \o "" [26](W���[�l�[ weg � #��Nb__ d� �_N^\�N �['`�� �����f\Pɋ��0�O��w�ɋ0͑�e,T��0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn29" \o "" [27],g���Qg�~&T�[�N #��NN �nx���N #��N�N ��Stck(W�Ndk0 j T N #��Nb__ �^\�N N TB\!k���� �ُ̑tS gR�g�^MOHQTKNR0��+T�vS�t'Y�i/f��Y�g j T ,g�� N��b�z ��c�� #��Nb__ v^�eaIN0ُ�y�ct`�>f6q�f+TN�y;����ۏsQ�|06q � � {|j T N #��Nb__ ,g����S+T;N�[‰�� } ��VdkdkY؏ N���_�Q HQ�[‰0T;N‰ �v�~��0vQ�N � 틃X�� } HQL�0 yr�[�� } �kT0�gb$Nj�O�l�����yr�[�v�T N T�v �rj틃X 0 �rj틃X �vS_�N �[‰YZag�N � T7h/f �@g �:1Y N���l�[ �rj틃X ��S�S�����gbvQ�N�rj�mp�y0�Oeuu�nf�R�N�rj ��wQY N�� N T�v�l�[ �rj틃X � TNL�:N��O�Y �@g s^l ��S��b�z N T�v�rj�qS�[�N{|jbb�Nj �0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn30" \o "" [28] yr�[�� } �[E�/fc wQSOj T ��[�R-N1\/fc wQSOc�c 0�l g�N�[�e wQSO�rj � {|j T 1\ N�S��b�z�b�z {|j T ��� wQSO�rj �=\�{؏��� �rj틃X /e�d� �rj틃X N yr�[�� } � wQSOj T �qQ T/e�d {|j T 0 틃X�� } �v^\'`�YUO�/f;N‰�v؏/f�[‰�v��l�_�l gĉ�[ ��S���Ǐ�[�R‰�[ ��~��/f �[‰�v 0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn31" \o "" [29] yr�[�� } �v^\'`�S�YUO�1\ {|j T �� �>f6q^\�N wQSO�v�[‰L�:N �1\vQ,g���v wQSO�gb �� ��[‰0;N‰�� }���_{�wQY0 틃X�� } /f�[‰�v � yr�[�� } RS+T�[‰0;N‰�� }0�Vdk �dkY N�� T7h�_�Q HQ�[‰0T;N‰ �v�~�� ��S/f HQ�[‰ �v�z:WR2��z*P06q � � N��$Nj�v 틃X�� } U\�s�N�VE��rj�gb�� }�v�z�Qyr�_�(W�l�[j�r-N � 틃X�� } B��_{�HQL�0�Ydk � HQ�[‰ �vZP�l�e^�/f�V�^�N�VE��rjN�z�lyr�_ �v^�e*YY�v SO�| ��ck�N f�_QŖ0��_ ��S��O��rjL�:N�� }/fir(��material �b�[‰�objective ��� } ��rja�V�� }/f�|^y/�_t�mental �b;N‰�subjective ��� } �/fb�z�rj�for a crime to be committed �@b�_��v$N*NsQ.��essential ��T*b6q N T/�r�z/npf�distinct ��v�� }0�ǏR�g ��l�^�v�[�g�~��/f���['`�v0sQ�N �rjL�:N ��l�^��:N� 0ĉ�~ 0�l gLu�[ �@g�[IN � 0�rj���N 0�c�O�N gP�c�[� �@g1\/fL�:N�N�\Ov`� �perpetrator �@g�[�killed ��l�[�ʑ:N�N �{k N͋�(u �N�NbY�N09hnc,gb�$R�O�l �b�z �@g��Bl���[�N�_{�{k�N0{k�N�_{�eg� �@gL�:N0 �@gL�:N�S�N/f\O:Nb N\O:N0���[�N�v{k�N��Y�N�[E��`b_-N�c�[�Qeg ��h�[�[�_{���f �@gL�:NN���[�N{k�NKN���v�V�gsQ�|�the causal link � HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn34" \o "" [32]0:N�N��fL�:N�N@g�[yr�[*N�N ��h�[�[ gIN�R�c�Oc�c�~���particulars � �FO/f N�_~b0R�Sb��f8\SO ��S�=\�S���|nx0Wnx�[ �@g0W�p0�S`��eg�TL�:N�e_ ��N�S�N�N�v�`b_�TL�:N�NN�rj�vT��|�link �09hnc���[6��k�v��fh�Q� �[(�t1u h�Q �  substantial grounds threshold ��N�S'Yĉ!j�rj�mass crime �Hh�N�v�[E� �ZWc ؚnx�['`h�Q �high degree of specificity � NR�[E�0:Ndk ��h�[�[ N�_���[�ky�@g�[�f���[�N�T�v�cL�:N�N�v���N0_N N�_�wS����[�N�vnxRpeϑ0ck�Ydk ��l�^MbO�Q� ��Y �many �b pe~v�N/!k ��l g�fyr�[peϑ ��v@g�[��nc0sQ�N �rj�_` ��l�^��:N� 0ĉ�~ 0,{30ag�vĉ�[S+T$N�y �ra �dolus � �_N1\/f ,{N�y z�^�v�v�c�ra �dolus directus in the first degree ��T ,{�N�y z�^�v�v�c�ra �dolus directus in the second degree �0ُ�y��Bl�(u�NqS�[�N{|j�Tb�Nj�vNRyr�[L�:N0 d�^��S gĉ�[ �ُ/fNy�NR�l�[�rj�vR_�T�SR�a default rule �0_N1\/f� �d�^� 0ĉ�~ 0b 0�rj���N 0��Bl�(u N T�vjǏh�Q�a different standard of fault � ��_{�nx�z� gsQ�rj�vir(��� }/f(W Eea�Tf�w �with  intent and knowledge ��v�ra/eM� N�[�e�v0ُ_N/f 0�rj���NN,�c�[�SR 0,{2>k�vĉ�[ �,{3>k؏ĉ�[ Eea�Tf�w�S�N�N gsQ�N�[�T�`���c�e 0:Ndk ��l�^�_{�nx�O�L�:N�Na�V�N{k�N�meant to cause death �b�aƋ0R�was aware ��N`�vN,��SU\O�[���~�g01\,gHhqS�[�N{|j-N�v �@g �� ��S�N�N�[^�fkň�NXTO(ufk�R�c�[�QEea0sQ�N sQ�| ��l�^��:N��h�[�[�_{���f(W �@gN;e�QL�:NKN��X[(WsQ�|�nexus � �_N1\/f��f�MLC���[�e�v �@gL�:N/f^�lb�|�~0W;e�QR�gs^l�v�~b�R0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn35" \o "" [33]�l�^��T�~�~R�g qS�[�N{|j �v :_xY c�c �`�~SO�|�l g9e�S0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn36" \o "" [34]��HN ��[ b�Nj � N T�rj �-N�v �@g �vR�gSO�|O g�NHN N TT��~��/f&T�[�v �dkY NX�0 30 sQ�N *N�NR�N#��N �v SO�|'``�~ sQ�N *N�NR�N#��N ��l�^�vR�g`Y N��l�^(W 0\Pbkɋ�����Q 0-Nc�Q�h�[�[�v�['` k,{1y� � �b��gbc%c�[b N�~#��N�,{28ag �0�Vdk �/U gMR� Nb�z�e ��l�^Mb{��~�~�[�gT�0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn37" \o "" [35]   sQ�N qQ Tck�r#��N 0ُ,g/f�h�[�[,{N!kc�c�v #��Nb__ �T���l�^��:N�S�� �['` g� v^ �f\P,T�� 0�h�[�[�v�Q!kc�c�OYu�Nُ�yc�c � T�e�X�R�N c%c�[�T N�~#��N c�c �y� ��NBl �S�Oi� 0�l�[dk!k�vg�~�[�g�~��/f��X�R�v�ec�cb�z ��OYu�v�c�c؏/f Nb�z0�Ogq8^t �1u�N�h�[�[��R � N,T�R;�� �f\P,T�� ���Q���20u� �S�t�]�~�_�_nZi �0$N!k�r� ��l�[�S�N�[hQ N�QtO�c�c �b�gY/f�{SYtT�v�c s��V �6qT�vTYb�z�v�ec�c0FO/f�l�[>f6q�l gُ7hZP0s��VS_�N�N��h�[�[�e/f �S�l'Y� 0�f/fS_�N�N �͑��ɋ����Bl ��VE��l�[ N�S�� N EQR�t �Ndk T�e ��l�[nx�z�N qQ Tck�r ;N‰R_#��vN,�`�~SO�| �v^�[,gHh9'Y�ۏL��N_8^�~�0�{_�vR�g0:N�N N�pbqN SO�| ��N N N�b�bRċ��0 �l�^c�Q��h�[�[P�R �rj�c6R�R�St �control over the crime ��SvQqQ Tck�rt��c�Q�:N�N�OkS^TX� �$N�N�b�[qQ T��R �g�~�[�rj��u�r(WMLC-N�v0WMO�N�S�[�[�eqQ T��R�v8h�_aIN�Q�[ ��N�c6R�N9hnc勡�R@b�[�e�v�rj0�u�r_N&{T�l�[�v �rj�_` ��Bl��N Eea�SNL��R 0 aƋ0R N TOqQ T�[�eN,�O�[�rj�vqQ T��R ��c�S�[�eqQ T��R�vΘi�0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn38" \o "" [36]FO/f�l�^ N�N:N6q�2009t^4g24�e ����ec#�e�EQc�c�v N�|nx'`�SvQ:w� �vQ-N1\S�b�u�r�v�SNb__�form of participation � �_N1\/f\O:NqQ Tck�r�co-perpetrator � �vz�z/f���cck�r�indirect perpetrator �؏/f�v�cck�r�direct perpetrator068�������� �     � � �ββ��βΆgMg1gM�6h�#�h�#�5�>*B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph3h�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph<jh�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJU\�^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph)h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^Jph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h�#�h�#�5�B* CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph3�0�� � � h � z�&� �(�)h*�*�*�/0<5�5�56Z6�6������������������������$dP��1$a$gd�#� $dP1$a$gd�#� $1$a$gd�#� $dP1$a$gd�#� �� � � � � � � � � � T V \ ` ^ ` b d h � � � DFDFLN������.!0!."0"6"8"�ββ��ββ}�β}��e��ββ}�ββ}�ββ}�/h�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^Jph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6h�#�h�#�5�>*B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph'8"�#�#�$�$�$�$�-�-�.�.�.�.&0(0&1(1.101�3�3�4�4�4�4�UVWWW W[[\ \&\(\vb�b�b�b\p^p^q`qhqjq,wRwTwnw���̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳������̳���/h�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^Jph3h�#�h�#�6�B*CJKHOJQJ]�^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph2�6�667�7�78\8�8�869~9�9:\:�:�::;�;�;<^<�<�<>=�=�=>f>�>���������������������������� $dP1$a$gd�#��>�>D?�?�? @h@�@�@FA�A�A$BnB�BCLC�C�C&DnD�DENE�E�E.FxF�F���������������������������� $dP1$a$gd�#��FGXG�G�G(HrH�HIRI�I�I(J^J�J�J0KzK�K�KDL�L�L"MlM�M�M6N�N���������������������������� $dP1$a$gd�#��N�NOfO�O�OFP�P�P$Q\Q�Q�Q*RvR.TPT4U�\8]_Ze|l,wTwpw�w�������������������������� $dP1$a$gd�#� $dP1$a$gd�#�nw�w�w�x�x�x�x�|�|�}�}�}�}������������B�D�D�F�N�P�������������^�~�������������n�p�p�r�z�|�z�|�|�~���������̳����̳����̳����̳����̳�����̳����̳����̳��3h�#�h�#�6�B*CJKHOJQJ]�^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3�w8{p|�|N~Ȁ��„�.�&���̌ڍƏ2�~���b����0�P�z�X��ԭ�������������������������� $dP1$a$gd�#� $dP1$a$gd�#��.�0�N�\�^�^�`�h�j�r�t�t�v�~���������������ֻػؼڼ������������������������������������� � � ����p�r�r�t�|�~� � � �����дд��дд��дд��дд��дд��дд��дд��дд��дд��дд0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph/h�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^Jph=ԭ.���зĸ�������V� �>���V�������$����D�H�v�v�v�v�y�{���������������������������� $dP1$a$gd�#����\�^�^�`�h�j��������������������.�0�0�2�:�<�&�(�(�*�2�4������2�x���� � � ���V�X�X�Z�b�d����� �"�V�X�X�Z�b�d��˴˴��˴����˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴������˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴���3h�#�h�#�6�B*CJKHOJQJ]�^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph< �01u�N�h�[�[�]�~9hnc�rj�c6R�R�St�c�QqQ Tck�r�v�|nx;N _ ����e�vc#�B� N͑�� ��l�^�S��[�gُ�y�SN!j_�mode of participation ��v9hnc0sQ�NqQ Tck�r�v�i�_ �bS�s�RHh�N�f g���Q� O T�N�N��[�e � �_{�N �c6R�rj �v�i�_�~Tt�0,g�^�l gt1uOP�y���[R�^�v�ct�e�lN`�0qQ Tck�rbO T�[�e�joint commission ��v�i�_�_{��NT�T�c6R�rj�joint control over the crime �:N9hnc ��_{��n���[‰�T�as well as �;N‰�� }��Bl0$N*N�[‰�� }/f��u�r�_{�/fNN�NbY�N��b�vqQ T��RbOS���vN�R��u�rN TO�_{�OS�R�[�rjir(����N�v�[bv^w�sQ.�\O(u0�l�^��:N�1u�N NR �rj�_` �� } N���n�� �B��e�_����~�[�g�[‰�� }0�n���[‰�� }v^ N��Y � 0ĉ�~ 0v^ NAQ���Onc%N k �h�Qeu gOP�y0yr�[�rj؏���yr�[�v�vba�V�specific purpose or intent � �ُ1\ N�N���n���N,� �;N‰�� }��Bl �؏���n����Y��Bl  _N1\/fyr�[a�V�specific intent/dolus specialis �0�l�^��:N� 0ĉ�~ 0,{30ag,{203>k/f�N �� }R�g�l �an element analysis approach �:N9hnc�v �ُN �rjR�g�l �a crime analysis approach �R}Y�v�S  N T z�^�v�_`�� }M�n�~�k*Nyr�[�rj�vir(��� }�N�O�[��0(W NR�`�Q N ��rj�vN,�;N‰�� }���_�n����1 ��u�r ga�means to ��SNyr�[L�:N � ^g/a�V�with the will//intent �_w��rj�~�g�v�Sub��\/faƋ0R,g N ^g�Su�v�undesired ��~�g Ock8^�Su ��2 ��u�raƋ0R N�y�`b_b�~�g\Ock8^�Su 0 Eea �T f�w �S f�v��/f �ra / jǏ �dolus � ���BlX[(Wa�_�volitional ��T�as well as ���Ƌ�cognitive ��V }0N,� �� �9hnca�_�V }�[�vis-a-vis ���Ƌ�V }�vq_�T�strength � ��ra/jǏ�S g N�yb_`�forms ���1 � ,{N�y z�^�v�v�c�ra �dolus directus in the first degree �b �v�cEea �direct intent ���2 � ,{�N�y z�^�v�v�c�ra �dolus directus in the second degree � �_N1\/f ���cEea �oblique intention ���3 � ���c:kȋL�:N /�S���ra�dolus eventualis � ��8^/fc;N‰����b/ ga�u�_/Ǐ�N��O�subjective or advertent recklessness �0,g�^��:N� 0ĉ�~ 0,{30ag,{203>kS+T$N�y z�^�v�ra/jǏ� ,{N�y z�^�v�v�c�ra b �v�cEea ��Bl��u�r�wS��know �vQ\O:Nb N\O:NO�will ��Nu�bring about ��rj�vir(��� }v^�and �&^@w�Nu�bring about �勯rj�v��Yir(��� }�v�e�[?ag/a�V�purposeful will/intent ��[�eُ�N\O:Nb N\O:N0(Wُ�y�ra-N ��8^X[(W�prevalent �a�_�� } ��V:N�u�ryr+R ^gb?aa���_�purposefully wills or desires to attain ����l�_�ybk�v�~�g0 ,{�N�y z�^�v�v�c�ra v^ N��Bl�u�r�[E��b g�Nu�rjir(��� }�va�Vb?ag ��S/f��Bl��u�raƋ0R�aware �ُ�N�ir(� ��� }�QNN/f�almost �vQ\O:Nb N\O:N�v�_6q�inevitable ��~�g ��O�Y ��u�r aƋ0RN,�O�Su�~�g 0(Wُ�y�`�Q N �a�_�� }'Y'YM�NOv^����Ƌ�� }�����overridden � ��O�Y ��S�aƋ0RvQ\O:Nb N\O:N O �will ��[��cause � N�`�Su�v �undesired ��ybk�~�g0�N,{ N�y�rab_`b��NUON�y�f:N{��_�vjǏb_`�form of culpability � ��l�^��:N,{30ag-Nv^ NX[(W ��V:N 9hnc�N`�vN,��SU\�Su �will occur in the ordinary course of events ��v(u�1\I{�N�cd��NvQ�N�rab_`09hnc�eIN��e,g ��ʑ � ��~�g �O�Su �will occur �1\/f(u�Nh���N�y N�S�MQ0W/�_6q0W �inevitably ���g�_�expected ��v�Nir0 O�Su N 9hnc�N`�vN,��SU\ �v�~TnZi0W�f�@b��Bl�v�Suh�Q�cяS_6q/nx�[�certainty �01\dk ��� ��l�^?aa�bُ�yh�QLu�[:N �[E�nx�[ �virtual/practical certainty �h�Q �_N1\/f���~�gO�Su  �cd�;�bk�rj�[(��� }�Su�v*g���`0*gg�_�vr^pb0�k�e�u� �ُ�yh�Qؚ�N ���c:kȋL�:N �v��h�Q  ���� N?a�Su�v�~�g��N�N/fN�y�S�� �likelihood/possibility ��v�z��Su0�Vdk ��Y�g�z�l�Ջ�V�m�v ���c:kȋL�:N �1\OO(u �S���Su �may occur �b 9hnc�N`�vN,��SU\�S���Su �might occur in the ordinary course of events � �ُ7h1\�S�NS+T US�~�v N�SKm'`b�S��'` �mere eventuality or possibility � � � N/f�NP��N �cяS_6qb�[E�nx�[ �near inevitability or virtual certainty �0��[ 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0�z�l�S�S � dolus eventualis �nf��l(u� ��T advertent recklessness HQ�Q�s(WI�Hh-N0T�S�� Rd� � �N؏3ufMR�N 9hnc�N`�vN,��SU\O�Su h�Q N T �_NnZi0Wh�f�z�l��ea(Wdk�m�vُ�yjǏ z�^�degrees of culpability �0�Vdk�l�^��:N�d�^���f�u�r�\/faƋ0R9hnc�N`�vN,��SU\0�Sudk{|�rj^\�N�[�eqQ T��R�v�[E�yr�[�~�g�virtually certain consequence � �&TR1\ N���u�r ga�have intended to ��[�e�NUOc�c�rj0,g�^�ea(u de lege ferenda �S�N �[(W�l �de lege lata � �:N�Nib'Y�ʑ,{30ag �ib _��ɋ�lQ0,{�N �qQ Tck�r�[�[�eqQ T��R\�[�[b�rj�vir(����N�vf�w�T�c�S09hncqQ Tck�rt���theory of co-perpetration � �����n���v,{�N*N;N‰�� }/f��1 �qQ Tck�r�v�NaƋ�mutual awareness �0R ��[�eqQ T��RO�[�rjir(����N�v�[b��N�S�2 ��N�N;Ra�with the purposeful will/intent to �Ǒ�SL��R0_�S�rjir(��� } �b�aƋ0R9hnc�Nir�vck8^�SU\ ��[bir(����N1\O/fvQL��R�v�[E�yr�[�virtually certain ��~�g0,{ N ��[��OvQNvQ�N TO�c6R�rj�[E��`�Q�vf�w09hnc�c6R�rj�vqQ Tck�rt�� �gTN*N����n���v;N‰���N/f��u�r�[��OvQNvQ�N TO�c6R�rj�[E��`�Q�vf�w0ُNh�Q��Bl��1 ��u�raƋ0R��](W�[�e�rjǏ z-N�v8h�_\O(u��2 �9hncُ�y8h�_\O(u ��u�r��Y;�bk�frustrate ��rj�v�[�e�implementation � ��Vdk_N1\��Y;�bk�rj�v�[b�commission �09hnc N��h�Q ��l�^�v��[�~��/f��u�r:ON�[�e�rj�v�_��a�V�the requisite intent � ��Vdk_N1\�l g�_���~�~�Q�/f&T&{TqQ Tck�r�i�_-N�vvQYO$N*N;N‰�� }0�h�[�[�c0R9*N�� }P�N��f�u�r�v�rj�_`0�l�^��:N�sS�OX[(W qQ T��R �qQ Tck�r�v,{N�[‰�� } � ��u�r�v�rja�V_N*g��nx�z0,{N ��h�[�[�y�(W,gHh^\�e�{��:S��KNMR�200102002 � ��u�r�f�~>mc� �eP �unpaid ��vMLC�� ��[��Su���[s^l�v:_xY0m�R�rj� �N@b�rjL��N*gm�0R�`Z �vQ-N g*N�Q�N�l�^ϑR{��_0��T�Sf�MQj�r0,g�^��:N��u�r�v�rja�V N���NvQǏ�S�vL�:N\O�QN,�'`�co0(W�eg�N�N-N�Su�Nyr�[�rj �v^ N�_6qasT@wOS_6q0W�Q!k�Su T{|�rj0dkY �(W{| mc� �eP �vMLC���v��l � N��:N�O0_N�_ N0RHh�NwS�[/ec0�l�^ w N�Q>mc��eP��N �@g�T:_xY gUOT��|�sSO�S��N m�R gsQ �_N�_ N0R,gHh��nc/ec0=\�{���l g�sё �FO/fu;m9�(u؏/f1uL��Rc%c�[��b�ُ1\�e�l�c�[�u�raƋ0R9hnc�Nir�vN,��SU\ �m�RO/fN�y>mc����v�[E�yr�[�~�g0�h�[�[_N�l g�ʑ�d��N �eP �NY �؏X[(W�NHN {| f:ON�|nx'`0,{ N �>mc� hQCg�Nt �carte blanche ����0�h�[�[�y��u�r�[hQ�N���(W2001t^�v�rj �2002t^�Q!k>mc� �1\I{�N�bُ�y��n�N hQCg�Nt �vAQ���s�X N �AQ���[�e:_xY0w�R�Tm�R � gj NZ0�c�e(Wdk�N�N�O`�N*N���N�,{15�S � �����N_N�c0R hQCg�Nt N͋ �FO/f����N�v�݋틃X N��/ec�c�e�c������N����S/fh����[��L����v'`(��T z�^�v�bċ0O � N���S f�u�r,g�N�v�NUOnZib NnZi�v�cCg����N�vċ0O�N�N/f s�` �suppositions �ُ/f���N��]�v(u� �  >mc���t��VY�bQeqS��;`�~�;N��O}T �1\I{�N���_�NaL��R�v�cCg ��� �S���S�SvQo��w�gP��T��Lu�v�c6R 0�l�^��:N����v;N��O}T/ft�Y�V�bQeqS��;`�~ �v^ NasT@w1\ꁨR���_�rj�cCg�>mc�Qe�c��_N N���1\/f�[�rj�vf�w��0R�[E�yr�[ z�^0,{�V �����ǏLu�l�ec%c�[�vo���0�h�[�[�y�����ǏLu�l�e �MLCc%c�[fnxc:y��@g.b-N^�s^l �v^�N,{47�S���N���Xd���summary statements �:N��� (W-N^��v�sR_ �`O�N�l g6r�k0�YP[�Ti[P[0`O�N/f�SSb�N0`O�N@g.bv^gd�kNR& & �s�].!�ZS>m`O�N�S@g.b � N/f�S�s�v 0�l�^��:N����Xd���v��f�R�]�~�_NO �؏NvQ�N��nc�e�lOS�N��dkY ���͋_N�l gR_�T�N�s�] �v^�l g>f:y�s�](W:Wb�Ydkc:y0�f͑���v/f � N����͋_NN�c�e,{40�S���N��͋�w�v����v;N���N�R/f�1 � �t�hQ�Le�N 0�2 � �OkSl �;`�~ �,{6�S���N_N��f �;e�Qs^lݏ̀ �OkS;`�~Cg�R �v�[E�O}T0�Vdk ��c�e N����f�u�ra�V����(W-N^� gd�kNR 0`\@gs^l0,{�N �MLC�XuQ�[���[�N�vH����0�c�e�Onc,{22023�S���NH���c�y� (Ws^lm�G��k�[�e �MLC�XuQ�[���[�N���e6q`O�N/f1uMR�S�Sfkň�c6R�vs^l �`O�N1\^\�N�S�Sfkň ��VdkMbOm�0R;e�Q 0vQ�[ ����N�S/f�^TX�HQu��S-N^�;`�~ �}T�N`\@g2-10�\KN���v?Q�z ��Vdk ��/f�s�]�Ydk}T�N �1\/f�c�[ ����e_N�c�Q�b���MLC�XuQ�XfN�s�]KN���l gsQ�|0�c�e؏�c_,{47�S���N��͋Xd������[�N��JT�w � a"��s�] �b�N gx^N-N^��YsY'`�N 0���e�c_��Y��͋�N�N�S�Q0�l�^��:N�,{47�S���N��͋Xd��,g����f�R gP� ��Y�g N��NvQ�N��nc�v�NpS�� � N��:N�O�MLC�XuQ�Xf,g��v^ N��nZib+T�|0Wh�f�s�] gǏ:_xY�cCg� N����f�s�] gdk�ra0,{mQ ��s�]N^TX��v�v�c�T�~8^'`T��~�0�c�e��:N��s�]N^TX��~8^T��~ ��wS�v^a�V�rj�Su0FO/f�c�e>f6q��nc N��0hQ��vsQ��nc>f:y��1 ��Ǐ�[0Wċ0OO�V�S^TX�� N�v�bJT �^TX����w�Su�Nm�R�T:_xY�rj��2 �(W�s�]�T^TX�KN���\�SuǏ$N!k5u݋�N���3 ����N�N N�wS�5u݋�N��vwQSO�Q�[ ��S g,{37�S���N�^TX�|TT�s�]>mc����X�c0�Vdk ��l�^ N��nx�O^TX�JT�w�N�s�] gsQ�rj�N�[ ��c�e;N _�l g�Onc0,{N �=\�{�NT�y nS����`�rj�N�[v^�N�Nb��0tS�N6q�~�~�[�eqQ T�rj��R�01u�NMRmQy�;N _GW Nb�z �@b�NvQYO3*N;N _ N;e�4x0�c�e P�R��gc�v&q�p݋��0 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0�e g�~b0�f gR�e �ĉ��v��[ z�^�S�eMR�O06q � �=\�{�g�N�l�[�b #��Nb__ Ɖ:N �rj�['` � �FO/f weg 0�rj���N 0�v6R�[� N�N:N6q  0�rj���N 0-N�l gĉ�[ N T #��Nb__ �v�gb���N0ck�Ydk ��YUOnxRt�N�ʑ gP��vĉ� �1\b:Nf[��T�S�l�[�v�N�R0,g���Q�v EQR�t �e�uwQ g�~xQaIN0:N�N N�pbqN SO�| ��N N N�b�bRċ��0 �l�^c�Q�qQ Tck�r#��NNc%c�[b N�~#��N N T0:N�N�f}Y0Wt�T� � gNag�SR1\/f��` g(WX[(W�l�[\O:NIN�R�e �Mb�S�N�c�[�Q N\O:N�vR�N#��N0,{28ag�S:SR�Q$N{| N�~�SvQsQ�| �_N1\/f�Q�Nb{| NgbL��Q�Nc%c\O(u�v �FO/f�Ǐc%c��ag�N�[ N gHe�c6R@w�VSO0�VE�yr���l�^�MRWS�l�^0bS�e���l�^ ���1u$R�O(WHQ��S���N�[ Nb�l�_ Nb:N� gc%c#��N�v N�~ ��l g ck_�l�_�cCg �formal legal authority � N��b:N�cd�R�N#��N�vt1u0�Vdk �ُ�y{| f2�b�S f�N gHe�{�� 0��-N�v c%c /fc �{���authority/Cg�R � �yr+R/f�c6Rfkň���vCg�R � � �{�� 1\/fc N��}T�N�T:_6RgbL��vCg�R�power �bCg)R 06q � ��e6q�e,gO(u b \$N���_ �:N�N㉳Q�e,gh�b��QX�� ��l�^�S����:N$N�X[(WN�yя mc����T���e�d�V���vCg�R0�l�^c�Q���f�u�r gHe�c6R ��_{���f/f(Wyr�[�v�e���k�time frame � �&TR1\ NEQR0ُ1\/f gHe�c6R N�rjL�:NKN���v4N�e�]T�temporary coincidence ��0yr���l�^�vb�O/f��_{�(W�rjL�:N�Su�eX[(W gHe�c6R0,g�^��:N��\(W�rjsS\�Su�e ��u�rX[(W gHe�c6R0@b� *gۏL��S_�c6R h�f�(W�rj�SuKNMR � N�~�]�~�c6R��0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn44" \o "" [42],{ N ��rj�v�Su/f�V:N�u�r*g���Y�U�c6R�Q��� N �0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn45" \o "" [43]�l�^c�Q�,{28ag,{1>knx�[�NN�y sQ�| �link �� \O:N& �v�~�g �as a result of �1\/fcُ�ysQ�|�relationship �0@b�N �ُ1\/f(W N�~�v�u�_#��N�the superior s dereliction of duty �N gsQ�rjKN��S+TN�y�V�gsQ�|�causality �0ُN%N k,{2y�ĉ�[�N N�yIN�R�2�bk06Rbk�T�c�N�rj �T$Ny�IN�RX[(W�N�rjKN-Nb�rjKNT0TNN;����v�~���O/f� N=\T$Ny�IN�R �1\Ob:N�Su�rj�v�V�n'`�S�V�retroactively cause �0�Vdk�l�^��:N��V�gsQ�|�� }�the element of causality ��SNc%c�[2�bk*geg�rj�Su�vIN�R gsQ06q � � N�~(W�rjKN-Nb�rjKNT�b Ne\L�6Rbk0�c�NIN�RN�Su*geg�rjKN��X[(W�V�gq_�T�causal impact �0�V:NRZwQ g2�bk*geg�rj�v�V g:g�� �@b�Nc%c�[�b N�`ZǏ�S�v�rj1\�S���likely ��X�R�Su*geg�rj�vqSi��risk �0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn47" \o "" [45]t��N,{28ag,{1>k�l g��~ĉ�[�V�g�^�the level of causality � �1\�S���(u but for test  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn48" \o "" [46]h�QۏL�$R�e��Y�g�l g N�~�b Ne\L�Ǒ�SNR�_���TTt�c�e2�bk�rj�Su�v�N�[ ��Q��v�rj1\ NO�Su0FO/f �N�y�g\O:N�positive act ��v�S���v�Tir(�He�g N T � N\O:N�omission ��vHe�g N���_0Rnx�['`�[��0bc�KN �b�N�e�l�|nx��Km��Y�gc%c�[e\L��N2�bk�rjIN�R�SO�Su�NHN0�e�nx�z$N�KN���v�v�c�V�gsQ�|�direct causal link �0�h�[�[�S���f�c%c�[�v N\O:N�X�R�N�[�e��c�c�rj�vqSi�0 HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftn49" \o "" [47],{�V ��u�r�wS�bt�^�wS�0,g�^͑3u� 0ĉ�~ 0�l gĉ�[%N kĉ�[�N$N*Nh�Q�vjǏ�� }�,{N�y�|1u �wS� �knew �h��� ���BlX[(W�[E�f�w�actual knowledge ��,{�N�y�|1u t�^�wS� h��� ��[E� N/fN�yǏ1Yb_`�form of negligence �0,{N�y �wS� N�S �c�[ �presumed � ��v�S ��_{� g�v�c�vb���c�cKm�v�circumstantial, ^��v�c�cKm�v ���nc0�VE�yr���l�^�v�~�� y �2010t^5g�QHr0   HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref1" \o "" * ,g�e�v�Q\O�_0R\O��r�z;Nc�_N/f/UN�S�R�N ��v-NNS�NlqQ�T�VYe��萺N�e>yO�yf[xvzy��vD�ёD��R������S�08JA820008 ��,g�e؏/f\O��r�z;Nc�_N/f/UN�S�R�N ��v�S�l��y��vyb�Q�S�07SFB5015 �0-N�V�lf[O������S�D08052 ��N�Sў��_lwYe���S�y��v�S�11534046 �0\O�;Nc�v�T\�n�]N'Yf[�lf[b�2009t^��J\Ye^R�e�Wё� ��hQw�l�_�efN�v�Q\OĉR�SvQ�N y2008t^Hr �,{90-101u�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� �VE�R�N�S�l�efN�v�Q\Oyr�_  �N�VE�R�N�lb��`�R�THh�N�e�N:N�O �}� 0-N�V�lf[O�l�_�efNxvzO2007t^f[/gt^O���eƖ 0 �,{82-92u��I{I{0{�؏(W,gO2008t^t^O�N�SvQ�NT�y�V0�QY͑��f[/gO�� NY!k�c�Rُ�y�VE��l�_�efN�[��xvzv^_�S T�N^�ltQ��0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref4" \o "" [2] {�R6R �c�VE�R�N���W�v�l�l�r` ��|�SH�tQo�Ye�c R�N�l�l t�_/T�S �ZP�v�VE�U\_ �_N/f{���[�VE��S�l�efN�vt�_�W@x0�S���S�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� �T�NLu�v �VE�R�N�l�l   �[�VE�R�l�v�N y2006t^Hr �,{516-549u�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� �VE�R�N�l�l��T�NLu�v�^�~�O�� �}�u��y�_[;N]� 0�T�NLu�vR�N�l�l 0�-N�VR�lf[O2006t^t^O�eƖ �� NwS � �-N�V�NllQ�['Yf[�QHr>y2006t^Hr �,{116-124u�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� 0�VE�R�N�S�l6R�^��� 0 ��T\�n�]N'Yf[�QHr2006t^Hr �,{313u��SvQ�N N�I{I{0 �VE�R�N�l�l _N/f �VE�R�l�Tf[ �v8h�_}T��0 �VE�R�l�Tf[ ,g��_N/f,g�e\O��vR �0�S�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� �VE�R�l�Tf[�b_`0}T��N�z:W �}�H�tQo�[;N]� 0R�N�lċ�� 0,{20wS �S�N'Yf[�QHr>y2007t^Hr �,{566-609u��I{I{0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref5" \o "" [3]  Appearance of justice �_N�Sы�y h�b�ckIN 0�S�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� �VE�R�N�lb��h�[�[�:N h�b�ckIN �b  |Q�� h�b�ckIN �i�_�Tt�_�v_ۏN�c!P �}�H�tQo�[;N]� 0R�N�lċ�� 0,{22wS �S�N'Yf[�QHr>y2008t^7gHr �,{578-618u��I{I{0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref6" \o "" [4] �VE�R�N�lb� NɋR�^�l�[��:N� He�s_N/flQs^�v�~b�R 0FO/f�Nɋ����`��[ � lQs^CN�VE��S�l�v8h�_�N

yO�v �S�l;m�R �_{��N ���Q �݋ � g ;m�R �_ g ���Q ��l g ���Q �v;m�R N����Ɖ:Nck_�v �S�l;m�R 0�VE��S�l�[Yeg��l�l>yO �`N�` N�S��9e � 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0�lĉ�_N/fُ7h��Bl�v0vQ!k ��VE�R�N�S�l�S�S N�0 MR�y �SvQ�N���_Y � �l�l RRw�ek ����(�Na�^�g0�Ydk �l�lR�~6��k � N/f �l�l/T��6��k � � lQs^ �v W\�e �Oag�R�_HQL� �'Y� He�s �v �l�e�~ 6��k\*g0Reg0N�_e�܏0 N�� 'YÍۏ �?e�l0�~Nm�Ydk ��l�l_N�Ydk��V�Q�l�l�Ydk ��VE��l�l�f�e�OY0gT � �VE��S�l N,�/f�S�l�vgؚ��S � lQs^ �v�XLuvz�z�YUO �N,�/f�l�l>yON�N�l>yO�vqQ TsQ�lN8h�_sQ�l0ck�Y�g�VE��l�[o��@b�� �[�N�VE�R�N�S�l �� �lQs^1\/fNR �vQ�N���S�Nbaba xd"} 0  �VE��S�l �Ydk � �VE�R�N�S�l �f�^�Ydk ��V:NR�N�S�l^� TN,�0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref7" \o "" [5] ICC-01/04-01/06-803-tEN, 14-05-2007�l;NR�g�`�R ��h�[�[ɋbS�s�R����Q���157u� �; ICC-01/04-01/07-717, 01-10-2008�l;NR�g�`�R ��h�[�[ɋaSfW�R�T]����Q���226u� �; ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009�-N^�qQ�T�V�`�R ��h�[�[ɋ!�ZS����Q���186u� �.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref8" \o "" [6] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 184-186. wQSO���Q�Ny�NqQ8y�0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref9" \o "" [7] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 3-4.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref10" \o "" [8] �S�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� 0�VE�R�N�S�l6R�^��� 0 ��T\�n�]N'Yf[�QHr>y2006t^Hr �,{85-190u�0ُ/f�V�Qf[Lu�[,gHh��!kU\_�v�|�~�T�S�Y'`xvz0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref11" \o "" [9] �S�� HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/" \t "_blank" �[eP:_� R�l�wƋb_`�vteT��[ �}�H�tQo�[;N]� 0R�l�wƋb_` 0 �nNS'Yf[�QHr>y2009t^3gHr �,{�N�z �,{29-57u�0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref12" \o "" [10] �N�tEQR�v��Bl҉�^��[ �b�N�v��Bl y2007t^Hr0�fN�vnx�l g tet �Q{| k��l gĉ�[ �l�N b USMO �rj ��20ck�r �S�bUS�rck�r0qQ Tck�r0���cck�r�,{3>k,{1y� ��30qQ�r �S�bYeU�r�,{3>k,{203y�� �N^\� ��Nck�r�eB�b*gB�:Nb�zag�N �0.^�R�r//e�R�r�,{3>k,{304y�� �N^\� ��Nck�r�eB�b*gB�:Nb�zag�N ��40����r/}q�R�r�,{3>k,{5y���v�clQ6q}q�R�N�Nmp�y ��50*gB�-Nbk�,{3>k,{6y�� N c*gB�YZ �0�Ydk � �l�N�rj 0 �rj��Y 0 ��Y-Nbk 0 *gB�-Nbk �N�S ��YYeU 0 ��Y.^�R I{ ��� N/f�rj0ُ�kb�V�l�[ �rjb_`W ���z�_Y0�N N�l�[ �rjb_` -N�v jǏb_` ��/f Eea �S�b �v�v�r � � L�:Nb__ ;N��/f \O:N 0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref28" \o "" [26] 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0,{28ag/f c%c�[�TvQ�N N�~�v#��N Nag �=\�{(W�[�R-N�vЏ(u�S���f:N��A~0SO�s�VE���ɋyrr� �FON,{25agĉ�[�v *N�NR�N#��N �~xQ!j_�6q N T0ck�Ydk ��l�[�[T�� #��N�N ��vR�g���[�N�fY�v;NSO0�{��0Cg��0�r`I{ �[‰�� } �ُ_N/fĉ�aIN N�v�l�[��Bl0dkY �(Wُ�yyr�k�v �rjb_` -N � jǏb_` �e g Eea �N,�/f �wS� 0yr+R/f t�^�wS� �T Eea NtO �_N gǏ1Y�sS N2�bk0 N6Rbk0 N�c�N �_N1\/f�s�_L��[b�a `L�#� � � L�:Nb__ _N;N��/f N\O:N �yr�[�v���N�T�r`�� }Nyr�[�v Eea �T N\O:N �~T(WNw� �1\b_bdk{| �rjb_` b �SN!j_ �v�z�Qyr�_0ُ/f�z�l��r��Nag0:S+R���N�v9h,g�S�V �_N/f�l�[���[ #��Nb__ N T0�rj_N N T �v�l�[t1u0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref29" \o "" [27] 9hnc 0Wl�ĉ�~ 0,{61ag��[$RMRnx��c�c �,{7>k�vĉ�[ ����[�l�^g�~�S�N�O�lZP�Q nx�� b �b�~nx�� c�c�T �f\P,T�� Ny� N T���Q0 �f\P,T�� �vt1u�T��Bl�S g$N�y�#��Ne�EQ>N��b��g� �O9eNy�c�c ��V:N@b�c�Q�v��nc>f6q�gb�SNy�,g�lb��{���Q�v�rj 01\T� �� �f[t N�{�dkMR�N6q �N,�O��:N�z�l�/fc j Td��N �v�`�Q ��O�Y�b qS�[�N{|j \O:N mp�yj c�c  ُ_Nck/f�[tON�y^X�e�T,g�lb��[ς9N�rj�`�R�v�['`Rgk ��S NǏ�N��(WɋMR1\㉳Q�N0FO/f,gHhɋ����`��f�_NS�b #��N!j_d��N �v�`�Q0�V:N�l�^dkMR@b� �V�h�[�[c�c�['`�� ��f\P,gHhnx��w�ɋ,T�� �1\/f�W�N #��N!j_d��N 0�l�^��:N�9hnc�>k,{1-2y��T,{3y���Bl@bZP�Q�v�Q�[ �(W'`(� N�[hQ N T�,gĉ�[�v;N���v�v(W�N\Pbk,T�� ��N�O㉳Q��ncb�N�[�v�l�_�['`:w� �ۏ ��MQ�l�^(W,g6��k1\�[(�� N��g�~���Q��l�^(Wdk6��k N�_��f N T�rj �v��Bl�~�[���_�n�� ��l�^�S�ۏL�N�y h�b� �prima facie �$R�e�c�c�e�N�[ gsQ�N�[�v�l�_�['`X[(W�u�0sQ�N N T�rj �v�i�_ ��[ NFO�m�S�l�[j T �؏�m�S#��N!j_��SN�rj�v!j_ N T ��rj�v�[(���[‰ ����N1\O�[hQ N T � �rj �v�~�g N T �\O:N;N�r0�N�rb N�~�v*N�N#��N_NO N T�\O:Nɋ���v�S�l�O���N�judicial guarantor of the proceedings � ��l�^�_{�nx�O�c�c�e�N�NsQ,gHhɋ��;N�� �G� g͑'Y�S�f�_{�JT�w�S�eS_�N�N �9hnc 0ĉ�~ 0,{67ag,{1>k,{1y����JT�N�vCg)R ��vĉ�[ ��Y�g�l�^ N�Q�#��N!j_ �1\O�NulQs^� ��V:N��JTO��eR:Y �N��JT�N�Sf�TO(u�v틇e �ŏ�����~JT�wc�c�v'`(�0�S�V�T�Q�[ �v�l�[Cg)R ��N�S���_�c�Na��:gO�vCg)R�sQ�N �Q��O��c�c ��ag�v�v(u�wQ g�[~g'` ��h�[�[�Q�[/f&T�O���vsQc�c ��l�^�ea�O�r�h�[�[�vL��� ��b�[�YS_�vc�cb�^���h�[�[�YUOg}Y0Ww�I�c�c�e�N N/f,g�^�r^�v;m?Q ��YUO�Onc�l�[L�#�Sb �Nnx�[�build and shape �w�ɋHh�N/f�h�[�[�vL�#� ��l�^�vL�#�/f(W���[ɋ��-NL�O�S�l�vcwL���v^�O�l N�����Q�9hnc >f6q h�Q �\O:N z�^'`���Q ��l�^ N�[��ncۏL��meQR�g �ُ̑�S��c�Syr�[��ncbT�e�z:W �_N NO���Q�[(�� �/U g�Ydk ��l�^Mb�S�N�MQ1\ gsQ�ۏL����Qb���e��l�^��:N�,{28ag���[�v#��N!j_� N T�v�rj�SN!j_ �v^*g�_0REQR㉳Q ��s g��nc>f:y ��N�r�gb N T�v�rj�#��N!j_ � �_N1\/f,{28agĉ�[�v#��N!j_��l�^gT���Q��f\P,T�����Bl�h�[�[P�g�Q��O��c�c�e�N��S���v#��N!j_ �v^�meQR�g�]�c�N��nc������e0���[�eP�g�V�^�ec�c�60�e�vnx��w�ɋ���Q~{�SgP��gTa��6e0RKN�ew�͑�e���{0See ICC-01/05-01/08-388, 04-03-2009.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref30" \o "" [28] 0�rj���N 0 N,�'`�[� ,{9>kĉ�[� Ny�L�:N�S�gbNjbpej 0ُ/f jpe ��v�l�[�SR �vz�z�YUOt� ��VE�R�l�vf[t\*g�~�U\_09hnc %N y1996t^Hr �,{152-153u�0ُ̑�v Ny�L�:N �^S_/fc Ny�wQSO�rj b Ny�yr�[�� } � N�S��/f N{|L�:N b Y*Nj(��v T�vL�:N ��f N�S��/f Y*Nj(� N T�vL�:N � cgqb�N�v��l �1\/f NL�:N 0 NL�:N  �S�gbNj �b�N�[ft�� b  �S�gb  pej ��~�[���Qb�N�vt��\ z0gqdkt� ��Y�g Ny�L�:N ��O�Y �@g s^l � T�e/f(W qS�[�N{|j �T b�Nj �v 틃X�� } N�[�e�v �1\�S�� T�eb�z$Nj  -N�V��J\ �VE�R�N�lb�!j�b�l�^'Y[� �vYpe ɋ�r ��/fُ7hZP�v �{�S_sSsQ�lv^(��ُN� � �vQ�Nċ�[�l�[S_�e��HN*g�la0��HN� q N�0��HN�NTRgk%N͑ ��vnx fW�yr�_ ��Vdk���N�R�gvQ^\'`0 �rj틃X ,geg/f �[‰�v �FO/f�l�[0S_�N�N��c���S�e ��T�SN�N����[�N0�l�^KN�S0�V�[�l�_�Nt�NI{ ���/f �N 0�S�S��/f�N�Q�v � �rj틃X �i�e�OY0�Q/f�N�Q�vN��� N�S���MQ;N‰'`0��HN � �rj틃X R�gvz�z^\�N�[‰�� }؏/f;N‰�� }��Y�g^\�N ;N‰�� }R�g �,g�e�v8h�_�~��KNN�HQ�[‰0T;N‰ �1\����&T0�Vdk ��_{�㉳QُN�0b�N��HQۏL� ĉ� �V~�0 0�rj���N 0 N,�'`�[� ,{7>k(Wu��_ HQ�[‰0T;N‰ �v�SR N ��b �vsQ�v̀of�`�QR(WgT � ,{NagqS�[�N{|j  �[� ,{2>k,{N�Sĉ�[ � �ky�qS�[�N{|j�vgT�Ny����N�c��L�:N�Su�e�v�_��̀of�`�Q � ,{kQagb�Nj  �[� ,{3>kĉ�[{| f06q � ��VE�R�N�lb��vɋ���efNNɋ�� z�^RR}Y��P�N ĉ� !k�^� �rj틃XR�g HQL�0{���:N�ُ�yR�g`�/fTt�v ��V:N�[�f&{T��}Y0W�f�VE��rjN�z�l�vyr�k��Bl �v^NُN�l�|`�~yr�_�W,g�esQ � �N�N�vN,�t'` gsQ0dkY �{�؏��:N� �[‰�� } N �[�[‰�� }�vH��� /f$N*N N T�Nir0�Vdk �iR N�v��N�N/f� �rj틃X ,g��vz�z/f�[‰�v؏/f;N‰�v��N �(WH��� �SvQ `7hH��� �N,g�e�����e�m0{���:N� �rj틃X ,g��/f�[‰�v � N/f;N‰�v� �[�rj틃X�vH��� _N�^S_=\ϑ�[‰0�MQ;N‰0�N�[ N �(W�VE�R�N�lb� � N��/f�h�[�[؏/f�l�[_N��/fُ7h��:N�v�2008t^6g20�e ��c�e�[ aSfW�R�v�Nt�N1\�h�[�[�v�b2�IN�R�Sh� w�l � T�e�c�Q\Pbkɋ���v�vsQ3u�� �N�N�V�^ �(W�0R�h�[�[:N�N��gte*N�rj�`�R �����Oo`�n^�l�c�OD��e�e ��h�[�[�� @b���S�v�Oo`�S�NO�c�e��g`Y�[(W�[‰�W@x N�on an objective basis � ��[hQ&{T�c�e�O�lnx�z�N�[�vL�#� 0ICC-01/04-01/07-619, 20-06-2008, pp. 4-5, para. 5, lines 7-9. 2008t^12g2�e ��[$RN�^ N�� sQ�NƉ,T���R�visual aids ��v���Q �vQ-N�c0R�c�e�f�~;N _ �:N�N�O�N�l�^t�@bc�c�rj�v틃X�[‰�� }�the contextual, objective elements of the crimes alleged � ��^S_AQ��O(u Ɖ,T���R ��ICC-01/04-01/06-1371, para. 11 �ُ�y��l�_0R�l�^���S0See ICC-01/04-01/06-1528, 02-12-2008, p. 5, para. 9.b�N�S�N N^� T�N�N H����rj틃X �v�e_�e�l �FO/fb�N�~�[ N���Vdk&T�[ �rj틃X,g��/f�_N�^S_/f ��[‰�v 0iR N�v��N�N/f��[‰�v �rj틃X ��/f �[‰�� } T�9hnc�VE�R�N�lb��l�_�efNwQSO�c���Q�[��[ �b�vT{Hh/f�Ype��/f �=\�{ NN�[hQ/f0@b� Ype��/f �1\/fc;N��/fH����l�[�v�T�[‰�v �vsQ/�_��̀of�`�Q �@b� NhQ/f �1\/fc:N�Nޏ/�0�Y�U0WH����l�[�v �vsQ/�_��̀of�`�Q �*N+R�v NxQ�W�~��_N N��weu ��v�v؏/f:N�N���MR�0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref32" \o "" [30] �la�ُ̑�v sQ�| �nexus � N^\�N �rjL�:N ,gSO�� } � �/fcwQSO�v �@gL�:NN {|j T @b��Bl�v 틃X�� } �^�lb�|�~0W;e�Qs^l �KN���vsQ�| ��VdkN �V�gsQ�| �causal link � N/f TIN0 NX[(Wُ�y 틃X sQ�| ��S��b�znf�@g�NjbvQ�N�rj �FO NOb�z qS�[�N{|j �v �@g 0 kĉ�[� �rj���NN,� cgq NR�SR�~�~��1 ��rj���N:_�N�k�y�rj�vsQ�vL�:N0T�g�T�`�Q ��VdkN,� cdkz��^_R��2 ��_���v�_t���N �>e(W�SvQq_�T�vL�:N0T�gb�`�QKNT��3 ��vsQ�v̀of�`�Q>e(WgT0 ُ1\/f N,�'`�l�[��Bl 0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref34" \o "" [32] �la�ُ̑�v sQ�| ^\�N �rjL�:N ,gSO�� } �/fN�y�~xQ�v�V�gsQ�| ��eN 틃XsQ�| N^\�N TN�Nir �_N N/fnx�z c%c�[b N�~#��N @b��Bl�vyr�k �V�gsQ�| � �rjqSi��X�R �0/f&T�S�N��(W��Y�`�Q N ��VE��rj�v�V�gsQ�|wQ g YT'` � �V�g�_ �SvQ��fh�Qv^ NN�0ُ�y YBg'`/f1uL�:N�N�v N T �SN!j_ �participating mode ��Q�[�v0�Vdk � N���b�VE�R�l-N�v�V�gsQ�|��{USS�(W TNHh�N-N ��[�V�gsQ�|�v��fb�fwQ g�]_'`0S_6q؏{��la � sQ�| _N N��/f �V�gsQ�| � N��N 틃XsQ�| �m T0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref35" \o "" [33] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 45-56.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref36" \o "" [34] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 56-67. ُ1\�f��[�v Tj T N�v N TwQSO�rj�vR�gSO�|�Oc%N f�v�u� �B�(Wck_���Q-N�~_�[‰�� }0�vTY;N‰�� }0ُv^���f�l�[(W Hh�`Omȉ0�[�g Ǐ z-N_N T7h/f �~_�[‰�� }0�vTY;N‰�� }   ُ�[E� N_N N�S�� ��V:N�h�[�[�vc�cfNv^ N/fُ7h�c�^�v ��l�[_N N�S�� �~_ 0�YUOOmȉ0�[�g/fN�V�N ��YUO���Q/f�SN�V�N0���Q�vfNb�;��� NI{�NOmȉ0�[�g�v�[E�;��� �=\�{$N��~8^N�0���Q/f`��~�g�vfNb�h��� �yr�p/f �vTY���[ � �Omȉ0�[�gǏ z1\ N�S��ُ7h �yr+R/fOmȉ0�[�g YBg�v�VE��rjHh�N0,g�e�����v �VE��rj��SO�| �;N���v�v/f��_n �^S_�YUO`� �Omȉ0�[�g �0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref40" \o "" [38] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 114-139.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref41" \o "" [39] �V�Qf[��Y HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/ldq/" \t "_blank" R'Y�0>��Q�Q0bS gf[I{ ��VY�fY �U` N��~_��0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref42" \o "" [40] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, p. 142, para. 408. f[��f(W�g͑���VE���[W N�c�Q�T���� �VE�w�ɋ�T�[$R/f&T�N�N���[ 'Y�Nir �/f&TOb_bNy��VE��`�O� �v� �,g���Q�]�~�~�QfnxT{Hh0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref43" \o "" [41] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 142-143, paras 409-410.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref44" \o "" [42] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 143-148, paras 411-419.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref45" \o "" [43] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 148-151, paras 420-426.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref46" \o "" [44] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, p. 149, para. 423. FO/fُN,gHh �l�^KN�S 'Yf��VE��T�h�[�[�v�z:Wv^ NN�0'Yf��VE���:N��V�gsQ�| N/fc%c�[#��N�� }09hnc`N�`�VE��l � N�~#��N��Bl��1 �X[(W N N�~sQ�|��2 � N�~f�w� N�[�e�rj��3 � N�~*g��6Rbk02�bkb�`Z�rj0(W N�� N���N $R�eh�Q-N ��l g��Bl N�~�v N\O:N�v�c�[�� N�rj0�v�S � N�~ N\O:NN gsQ�rjKN���vsQ�|�S/f�S gHe�c6R��Bl�v6R�~  N�~wQ gq_�T� NL�:N�v�[E����R  � N/fN�y�r�z�v�V�gsQ�|�� }0ICC-01/05-01/08-406, 20-04-2009, pp. 19-20, para. 30. 'Yf��VE�؏c�Q� N\f[���� 0ĉ�~ 0 ���:N�l�_���[�NN�y�e�v�V�gsQ�|0�[E� N ��l�_�l g��Bl N�~ N\O:N�[�� N�rj � 0ĉ�~ 0�l gOP�y`N�`�VE��l0sSO���ۏL��V�gnx�� �cknx�v�ʑ/f� N�~�v N\O:N�X�R�N� N�rj�vΘi�0ICC-01/05-01/08-406, 20-04-2009, p. 20, para. 31. 2009t^4g27�e ��h�[�[�V Y'Yf��VE� �l�^KN�S a��v^h�:y^� T�,{28ag�l gĉ�[��Y�v�V�gsQ�|�� }0 N�~KN@b�N�R�N#��N �1\/f�V:N�l gۏL��c6R0_N1\/f�� N�~�wS�b�^S_�wS��rjck(W�Sub��]�~�[�e �tS�b NǑ�S�c�e�N�N;�bkb�`Z0ُ1\/f@b� \O:N�b NۏL��Y�U�c6R�v�~�g �v;N��+TIN0ICC-01/05-01/08-412, 27-04-2009, p. 3, para. 4. �h�[�[؏��:N��Y�g^�����f�V�gsQ�| ��h�[�[�S���f N�~�v�b N\O:NL�:N�X�R�N� N�[�eyr�[�rj�vΘi���Y�g�(u�fؚ�vh�Q �1\O�����l�[�V�gsQ�|��Bl0ICC-01/05-01/08-412, 27-04-2009, p. 4, para. 5.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref47" \o "" [45] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, p. 150, para. 424.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref48" \o "" [46] ��V�V�gsQ�|t�� �SB\!k�S�V -N�v �N�[�S�V h���lQ_� �Y�g�l gA�B0C& �1\�l gZ �RA�B0C& �1\/fZ�Su�v�N�[�S�V 0ُ*NlQ_/f�V�gsQ�|t���v�[‰�W@x �v^ N/fR�l�V�gsQ�|�v�[IN0�lQ_ N��㉳Q YBg�V�gsQ�| ��O�Y qQ T�S�V b �S�V���vb�Ǐ'Y ��vS_�N ag�N� ��0�S���P�i i� 0��VR�l 0 �S�N'Yf[�QHr>y1996t^Hr �,{64-65u�0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref49" \o "" [47] ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 150-151, para. 425. ُN'Yf��VE��T�h�[�[�v�z:WN�0  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref50" \o "" [48] ُN'Yf��VE��z:WN� �T���:N� 0ĉ�~ 0:_S�Nc%c�[#��N ������N`N�`�VE��l0�Y�g N/f �[E��wS� �actual knowledge � �/U g(W��JT�w�on notice �� N�rj�e �`N�`�VE��lMbb��c%c�[#��N0FO/f � 0ĉ�~ 0�X�R�N �^S_/t�^�wS� �should have known � �ُ7h1\�b`N�`�VE��l-N�v �m�g�JTh�Q �the passive notice standard ��Sb���Ǒ�S�c�e�N�� N�rj�v�f:N�y�g�vIN�R�a more active duty �0ICC-01/05-01/08-406, 20-04-2009, p. 3, para. 3.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref51" \o "" [49] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 151-155, paras 427-434.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref52" \o "" [50] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 155-159, paras 435-443.  HYPERLINK "http://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish" \l "_ftnref53" \o "" [51] See ICC-01/05-01/08-424, 15-06-2009, pp. 159-184, paras 444-501. eg�n: 0R�N�lċ�� 0,{26wS d�����DFFHPR *�!�!""�"�"#`#�#�#�+�+�+�+<-\-F/d/v/�/n9�9�C�C�D�D�D�DFFGG G"GKKLL"L$LFNHNHOJOROTO�W�����谗��������������������������谗��谗��谗��谗��0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph3h�#�h�#�6�B*CJKHOJQJ]�^JaJphU-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph;�W�W�X�X�XY4Y6Y6Z8Z@ZBZ�[�[�\�\�\�\__````�`�`�a�a�a�a c>d@dHdJd�g�g2i@i>k@k@lBlJlLlDnFnFoHoPoRo:t uFuHu�u�u�v�����������������������������͚͚������������������3h�#�h�#�6�B*CJKHOJQJ]�^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph<�v�v�v�v�v�v�v�v�v�v�w�w�wxbx�x�y�y�z�z�z�z�{�{�|�|�|�|�|�|(}*}0}2}�}�}�}�}�}�}��䴛������g�����������������/h�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^Jph6jEh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphy(-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph( � ��������� � �l�n�ց؁ށ��l�n�ւ؂ނ���������������$�&�,�.���������ĆƆ��|�~�����D�F�J�L�R�T�8�:�>�@�F�H�����������8�:�>�@�F�H������������������������������������������������������������0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJphG��D�8���8����������������6�ƢV��D�f�����x�8���P�r�r����������������������������� $dP1$a$gd�#�H����������������� �"�(�*�������������•ĕ,�.�4�6���������ėƗ�� �"�*�,�����������������"�$�������������� �&�(�0�2�������������6�8�>�@����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳�����0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJphF@�H�J�ƢȢΣУأڣV�X�^�`�h�j�����&�(�D�F�L�N�V�X�f�h�n�p�x�z��������������������x�z���������8�:�@�B�J�L������� � �j��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴˴��˴-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph?j���P�R�X�Z�b�d�r�t�z�|������������� �`�l�r�t�z�|�����p�r�x�z���������������������������������"��ββ��ββ������ββ��ββ��Ιββ��ββ��β�3h�#�h�#�5�B*CJKHOJQJ\�^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph3h�#�h�#�6�B*CJKHOJQJ]�^JaJph2r�p��������$������T�X���|��8���.�"�V �   ������������������������ $1$a$gd�#� $dP1$a$gd�#�"�$�,�.�������������$�&�,�.�6�8�������������� �&�(�0�2�������������������$�&�T�V�\�^�f�h�X�Z�`�b�j�l�������������|�~������������� �"�8�:�������������������������������������������������-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJphG:�@�B�J�L���������.068@B������"$*,46��� � � � V X ^ ` h j �   �̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳����̳�蜘h�&y-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph0h�#�h�#�>*B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph6jh�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJU^JaJph-h�#�h�#�B*CJKHOJQJ^JaJph+01�82P��. ��A!�"�#��$��%��S�� ��EDd,������ � c �:A�����Normal�Fax0��1C"�j����P���� src="/webcount/count.asp?newsid=39260"��b�!X�����N�B���D>n��X�����N�B���PNG  IHDR��fsRGB@�}�0PLTE���������������������������{��bIDAT�E�!�0Eq��^u�M&V��Up�\ �&���C|�������)"3.8̴����(6 jPtsʄ��&��)�N�U- \^�w�& �^ey��ƾ�_�c|_���^9IEND�B`��Dd��� �V � 3 �������C"��J��� �((����N@��N ck�e $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@���$ ؞���k=�W[SOBi@���B nf�h� *S*�Y(ph"W`�" �#����p5�\���$����' ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� �� "&� �� "&� �� "&� �� "&� �� "&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� ��"&� �� "&� ��!"&� ��""&� ��#"&� ��$"&� ��%"&� ��&"&� ��'"&�H� 4 �9 �$K*�.�3>9>�B�IEO]S4X�^�fklrpxXT�{�c�L����w�ͳ�l���������������E � ^ > ���.���`��� ���. �)� �!%"�#�$�%&{Zd����H u `�4HV� ��� -Rv��� .Sw��� .Sx��� /Vz���3X}���4Y~���7\����7\����<a���� 9 ^ � � � � !/!T!s!�!�!�!�!""G"l"�"�"�"�"#A#g#�#�#�#�##$H$m$�$�$�$�$%;%&(&�&K*�*�+�.>2�7�7�7�7�98:U:';d<D>a>@�@�AFBfB�B�C�F?NEO1PQP�P�P�P�P�QR�RU�U�WbX�Xq\�\j]�`�g�h�h�i�kBnauwu�v�wH���B�D�F�����N����h���h��!�%�ع��T��ۼ��g�/�����n�����K���������������Y�3�����[����������S���������]�*����������r s;�r ?)�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r $��r I@;�r �]�r /�C�r ��T�r ���r 6� �r s;�r s;�r �{?�r s;�r ��.�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r �d�r s;�r Y� �r .L�r Y� �r $��r ��T�r ƒe�r Щ��r s;�r s;�r s;�r &�r ?)�r s;�r �v�r &�r �7�r s;�r ��!�r ���r $��r ?)�r s;�r ���r Y� �r ��.�r 3s��r ���r $��r s;�r �v�r s;�r s;�r s;�r $��r Y� �r �d�r c�2�r ?)�r �{?�r ���r s;�r �7�r s;�r �d�r /�C�r �2��r �d�r s;�r &�r ?)�r .L�r Щ��r s;�r ���r }R*�r '7�r &�r �&��r s;�r �v�r s;�r �d�r ���r ?)�r c�2�r ���r �7�r ���r s;�r s;�r �v�r �v�r �v�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r Y� �r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r s;�r &�r &�r w�~�r ����r M���r $��r ���r $��r s;�r �v�r s;�r �v�r &�r s;�r s;�r Y� �r s;�r s;�r s;�r .L�r s;�r ?)�r �v�r �d�r s;�r s;�r s;�r ��r �{Zd����H u `�4HV� ��� -Rv��� .Sw��� .Sx��� /Vz���3X}���4Y~���7\����7\����<a���� 9 ^ � � � � !/!T!s!�!�!�!�!""G"l"�"�"�"�"#A#g#�#�#�#�##$H$m$�$�$�$�$%;%&(&�&K*�*�+�.>2�7�7�7�7�98:U:';d<D>a>@�@�AFBfB�B�C�F?NEO1PQP�P�P�P�P�QR�RU�U�WbX�Xq\�\j]�`�g�h�h�i�kBnauwu�v�wH���B�D�F�����N����h���h��!�%�ع��T��ۼ��g�/�����n�����K���������������Y�3�����[����������S���������]�*���������I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0�������������������I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�00I�00I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�@I�0I�0I�0I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�@I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0I�0{Zd����H u `�4HV� ��� -Rv��� .Sw��� .Sx��� /Vz���3X}���4Y~���7\����7\����<a���� 9 ^ � � � � !/!T!s!�!�!�!�!""G"l"�"�"�"�"#A#g#�#�#�#�##$H$m$�$�$�$�$%;%&(&�&K*�*�+�.>2�7�7�7�7�98:U:';d<D>a>@�@�AFBfB�B�C�F?NEO1PQP�P�P�P�P�QR�RU�U�WbX�Xq\�\j]�`�g�h�h�i�kBnauwu�v�wH���B�D�F�����N����h���h��!�%�ع��T��ۼ��g�/�����n�����K���������������Y�3�����[����������S���������]�*���������I�0�@I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�00�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�I�0�@hI�00��� 8"nw��d��W�vH�@�j�"�:� ~�����    �6�>�F�N�wԭr� ������  �OS� q���*./���"&�SW�   � TX�gk���sw�&�'�'�)**.4�4�4�7f8k8r:�:�:Q?�?�?!C�C�CHD�D�D�ENFSF�M8N=N�N>OCO.T�T�T�X:Y?YHY�Y�Y�YlZqZ�ZT[Y[�_z``La�a�ab�b�b�b9c>c�de e�e/f4fyj�j�jk�k�kp�p�pt�t�t�t,u1u v�v�v�x,y1y�{o|t|��A�F�֐W�\�W�ؓݓ�p�u�řF�K�f�������N�ϝԝ�����j���k����o�t��j�o�����F�ɩ˩��'�)���#�'�+�`�d���ƬʬN�ѭխ�M�Q��������7�;���˯ϯ)�^�b���*�.�U������q�u�h�����(�,�h����������ܷ�!���������%�����ع\�a�����T�ػݻ�����ۼ_�d���#�(�g���/�������{�����Z�_�n���������������K������������l�q���L�Q���x�}�������� ��������������!�&�Y�����3�������b�g�����[������������������z����|�����E�J�����S�������l�q���,�1���g�l���<�A�]�����*�������{�����X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X��X����j_ftnref1_ftnref2_ftnref3_ftnref4_ftnref5_ftnref6_ftnref7_ftnref8_ftnref9 _ftnref10 _ftnref11 _ftnref12 _ftnref13 _ftnref14 _ftnref15 _ftnref16 _ftnref17 _ftnref18 _ftnref19 _ftnref20 _ftnref21 _ftnref22 _ftnref23 _ftnref24 _ftnref25 _ftnref26 _ftnref27 _ftnref28 _ftnref29 _ftnref30 _ftnref31 _ftnref32 _ftnref33 _ftnref34 _ftnref35 _ftnref36 _ftnref37 _ftnref38 _ftnref39 _ftnref40 _ftnref41 _ftnref42 _ftnref43 _ftnref44 _ftnref45 _ftnref46 _ftnref47 _ftnref48 _ftnref49 _ftnref50 _ftnref51 _ftnref52 _ftnref53_ftn1_ftn2_ftn3_ftn4_ftn5_ftn6_ftn7_ftn8_ftn9_ftn10_ftn11_ftn12_ftn13_ftn14_ftn15_ftn16_ftn17_ftn18_ftn19_ftn20_ftn21_ftn22_ftn23_ftn24_ftn25_ftn26_ftn27_ftn28_ftn29_ftn30_ftn31_ftn32_ftn33_ftn34_ftn35_ftn36_ftn37_ftn38_ftn39_ftn40_ftn41_ftn42_ftn43_ftn44_ftn45_ftn46_ftn47_ftn48_ftn49_ftn50_ftn51_ftn52_ftn53q/��� � ���&�).4�7r:Q?!CHD�E�M�N.T�XHY�Y�Z�_Lab�b�d�eyjkpt�t v�x�{��֐W��řf���N��j�k�����F�����N����h���h��!�%�ع��T��ۼ��g�/�����n�����K���������������Y�3�����[����������S���������]�*�����  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghi��'X Yl�x�'*�4l8�:�?�C�DTF>NDO�T@Y�YrZZ[�`�a�b?c e5fk�k�p�t2u�v2yu|G�]�ޓv�L���՝����u�p��̩*�(�֭/�v��-��������b��޻��e�)������`����������r�R�~��������'�����h����������K����r�2�m�B�����������3�S�, ��������;*�urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags�chsdate� \`� �15�2009�6�Day�False �IsLunarDate �IsROCDate�Month�Year PSW[ps|��������������� ������������������������h�����:��-������������� i gpZH�gpZH_U�gpZH@��}��gpZH�PgpZHEX;gpZHLbgpZH(��>I!)�gpZH4|6gpZH*'P\� d4�\8)�cBvLr�M�`gpZH�Hhv�t�gpZHQg�R�A�MgpZH�K�gpZH� #gpZHWkZ�cB�o+,m|>�gpZH� �cB�-� t�b�1I gpZH�� gpZH�/� gpZH�qA �^�$�is �cB�ev D %5�n� gpZH�� gpZHx=f �jN�{)gpZH��D\�s[Jh�cBlRgpZHRz�ex�MDF�gpZH�d�gpZH> gpZHup�cB\w�gpZHM�gpZH�=��\n�.�cBwu��cB�,�gpZH�e��EGv66��T$7gpZH�V�Sz2Z��gpZH�bgpZH R� <=N~�gpZH�^�gpZH�VgpZH^b$gpZH�!�gpZH�h�gpZHwl3R+CIxgpZHHI�bG�ggpZH�<��cBo@�gpZH�kWgpZH�`�gpZH�}�cBO �gpZH �gpZH�O��;igpZHwY!gpZHN�!i[�u�5�"�<���"gpZH�15$�cBqQh$�cB�y�$gpZH�^�$�cB�{#%�j�f�J)%gpZHzg%�cB�'gpZH�(+gpZHR?�+gpZH�I",�i�g@Y1.gpZH1)/gpZH�1g/gpZHa_�0gpZH�V�1gpZH{D�1�cB�an2=�| <�2gpZHl^3gpZHVk 4gpZH�+4� D %5�cB ]w5gpZHG,�5gpZHR@�5�cB{r6gpZH�<�6gpZH�B�6up�*B7\8)gq\7gpZH�La7gpZH��7{D�1�0�7�is UU�7gpZHV%h8\�m�F�8Y:~�Kuo�8gpZH�h�8gpZH�M~9gpZH�U�:gpZH�W�:gpZHPT�:gpZH2=�;gpZH�$o gpZH�c�?gpZHn�@gpZH�=AgpZH� [A�.X�AWkZ�;�AgpZH�R�A�cB�cBgpZHX5�BgpZHR+C�cB{CgpZH� �C��j@[�CgpZH�u�DgpZH�MEP0�ng8+EgpZH� 7EH2�m�^AFgpZH��F�15$!6�FgpZH�E)GgpZH�?GgpZH�~VGgpZH�{�GgpZHgpZHY:~,Nt�HgpZH�>I�cB�}�IgpZHZ)�IgpZH .�IgpZH� CKgpZH�kaLgpZH�+�L`q~'X�LgpZH2�MgpZHex�M�cBr�M�cB <=N�cB�jN�cB_UlN�cB5�NgpZH;�N�cB��O[Jh��OgpZH�\PgpZHgkPwu��7mP�cB� �QgpZH�*�RY:~,@�R�cB~ �RgpZH�sSgpZH%p:T-y'U TMTgpZH��T�cB�KUgpZH-y'U�cB,7DVgpZH��WgpZH�)XgpZHxM�YgpZHSz2Z�cB��ZgpZH*'P\�cB]gpZHp�]gpZHT^gpZH b_@�R dagpZH7�agpZH�$�bgpZHJ�bgpZH t�b�cB�Rd�cBve6�=�6egpZH�]�egpZH�j�f�cB�2]ggpZH�i�g�cBbG�g�cB�j�hgpZH =igpZH�WOigpZHsOjgpZH��j�cB�H�j�RdH2�m�cBJ$�mgpZH\�m�cBUn�do�\n�cBP0�n�cB$^ oR@�5b$ogpZH�do�cB[�ozg%Ln�ogpZHp}9p;�NW%:pgpZHMXzpgpZH�<�pqQh$� �p�O���%�pgpZHZqgpZH�q�7mPP]�qgpZH�<�q_UlNAkr��vO�rgpZH&sgpZHD\�s�cBiv?tgpZHBmtgpZHv�t�cB,)ugpZH�V5ugpZHi[�u�cB#8�ugpZH�x#vgpZH�EGv�cB�=�vgpZH��v�cBLB�vgpZH� CwgpZH�7iwgpZH�G�wgpZHz�wgpZH�hbygpZH�I�ygpZH]&zgpZHG |gpZH+,m|�cB=�|�cB�}gpZHz+�}gpZHY:~� �p� X�I~gpZH`q~�cBd4��cB��$:�&y�#��@����� �G�����  !'*8@FNOYZ[^`cefhosuy�y��PP P PPP"P$P(P.P4P6P8P:P<P@PBPFPHPJPVP\PxP�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P�P��Unknown������������G��:�Ax� �Times New Roman5��Symbol3&� �:�Cx� �Arial;���(�[SOSimSun 1��h�&g�&gd$p�'|�d$p�'|�!-!),.:;?]}����    & 6"0000 0 0 00000��� � �����=�@�\�]�^���([{�  0 0 00000��;�[����������X�X�2�HX��?��������������������#�2�� Administratoradmin�������Oh��+'��0`������� ��  ( 4@HPX�Administrator Normal.dotadmin2Microsoft Office Word@F�#@&5!m��@l�Dm��'d$p�����՜.��+,��D��՜.��+,���� X`lt|� ������|X�� �r 8@ _PID_HLINKS�A@r�-~eahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref53-~bahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref52-~_ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref51-~\ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref50-Yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref49-Vahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref48-Sahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref47-Pahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref46-Mahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref45-Jahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref44-Gahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref43-Dahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref428;Ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/ldq/->ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref41-;ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref40-x8ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref39-x5ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref38-x2ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref37-x/ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref36-x,ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref35-x)ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref34-x&ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref33-x#ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref32-x ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref31-xahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref30-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref29-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref28-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref27-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref26-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref25-y ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref24-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref23-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref22-yahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref21-y�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref20-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref19-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref18-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref17-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref16-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref15-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref14-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref13-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref12'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref11'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref10-r�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref9-s�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref8-|�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref7-}�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref6'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-~�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref5'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref4'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/'5�http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/-x�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref3-y�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref2-z�ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish _ftnref1 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn53 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn52 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn51 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn50 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn49 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn48 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn47 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn46 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn45 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn44 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn43 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn42 �ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn41 ~ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn40 {ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn39 xahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn38 uahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn37 rahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn36 oahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn35 lahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn34 iahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn33 fahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn32 cahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn31 `ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn30 ]ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn29 Zahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn28 Wahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn27 Tahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn26 Qahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn25 Nahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn24 Kahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn23 Hahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn22 Eahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn21 Bahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn20?ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn19<ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn189ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn176ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn163ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn150ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn14-ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn13*ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn12'ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn11$ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn109.!ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn99.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn89.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn79.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn69.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn59.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn49.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn39. ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn2'5 http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/9.ahttp://law.hit.edu.cn/website_admin/article/ewebeditor/ewebeditor.asp?id=content1&style=poorfish_ftn1'5http://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq/Vhttp://law.hit.edu.cn/sjq  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������     �������� !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ����\]^_`ab����defghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������Root Entry�������� �F02qNm����Data ������������1Table����tWordDocument����2$SummaryInformation(������������[DocumentSummaryInformation8��������cxsCompObj������������m������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ���� �FMicrosoft Office Word �ĵ� MSWordDocWord.Document.8�9�q

Baidu
map