yO�Yzz�s�X�zz���xGr� NLuqQu t�_ T h e L e g a l P r o t ection of the Outer Space Environment in the Risk Society ��Take the Pollution of the Space Debris as an Example HOU Rui-xue (School of Law, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001 China) Abstract: The humanity has stepped into the risk society at present. The protection of the outer space environment has been one of the global risks, it influences the survival of humanity and the safety of the international community seriously. The pollution of the outer space environment in the risk society has specificity, the risk society proposes many challenges for the legal protection of the outer space environment. The governance of the outer space environment (The space debris is the main form of the pollution) relies on the solid theory basis, the ideas and values adapted to the risk society are the prerequisites of designing good legal system. So in order to construct the perfect legal protection system of the outer space environment, we need to transfer the existing legal ideas and values. The idea of �world c o e x i s t p r o v i d e s a n e w v a l u e f o r t h e l e g i s l a t i o n o f t h e o u t e r s p a c e e n v i r o n m e n t a l p r o t e c t i o n . K e y w o r d s : T h e r i s k s o c i e t y ; t h e o u t e r s p a c e e n v i r o n m e n t ; s p a c e d e b r i s ; t h e i d e a o f w o r l d c o e x i s t hQtS�R�m�N�N�NKN���vnfM��N�_ �T�VKN�� g�N��eg��Y�vqQ TKNY��eR�N@w�y�bۏek�T�ef�SU\@b&^eg�v}YY � T�e_Nb�4N@wZ���N{|uX[�v�y�yhQt'`�0яt^eg �Yzz;m�R�vŏs�SU\�[zz���s�X �b�N%N͑qS�[ �yr+R/fzz���xGr�[zz���s�X�vZ���e�v�RgR0�k��xQ�W�v�N�O ��Y2 0 0 9 t^2 g1 0 �e�v��OkSf�v�d�N�N0�Vdk ��YUO gHe�ltzz���xGr��]�~b:NhQ�N{|qQ TsQ�_�vhQt'`�0�N�N _�Y��Ƌ0R �(W N�[z�^ Nb_b�W,gqQ T�vt�_�N�S6R�[qQ T�v�VE�L�:Nĉ� � N�N/f�_���v � �N/f'}도v0 �vMR �Yzz�s�X�O�b�eb�:ONfnx�v�l�_�Onc ��sX[�v�O�bYzz�s�X�v�vsQag�~�v�Q�[_N�_ N�[�U0[ `$] FO{�(Wdkv^ NsQ�lwQSO6R�^�YUO�^�g�v� � �/f��:NYzz�s�X�O�b�l�_6R�^�v�[�U g�~���OV��N�^�g�l�_6R�^�v`�`�W@x sS�e�v�l�_t�_�T�N
yOeg4NKNE� �(WYzz�W>W�]�~b:NNLu'`Θi���v�N)Y �Yzz�s�X�l�_�O�b\�YUO�^�[Θi�>yO�c�Q�vcb �ُ�R�_b:NYzz�s�X�O�b���W�v&q�p�0,g�eՋ�V�NΘi�>yOُ NƉ҉�Q�S �eg�c��Θi�>yO�[Yzz�s�X�l�_�O�b�c�Q�vcb ��N�SYzz�s�X�l�_�O�bt�_l��S�v�_��'` �v^�c�Q NLuqQu ُ N�e�vt�_0 N0Θi�>yO-N�vYzz�s�X� �_�VW� T>yOf[�[LN\̑ ^� �KQ��!k�c�Q�NΘi�>yOt�� �KNT T{v�e�v 0�s�N'`�vT�g0�N�SbS�f�v 0Θi�� N�y>yOf[t��0���b�y�b�T�s�XΘi��cGS:N�s�N'`ؚ�~6��k�v N�[�~�g'`/e�g �ُ�Nt���gb�NxvzΘi��sa��N�S�c��Θi�>yO-N�l�_6R�^KN�^�gI{��v͑��_0�KQ��:N�2 0 N�~TJS�S�Neg�N{|>yOۏeQ�NNLuΘi�>yO0�KQ��:N�s�N>yO/f N*NEQ�n�N�Spe�vΘi�>yO� (WNLu��V�Q �S_�N>yOck�~�S@w N:W9h,g'`�SS �ُ�y�SST�N/T��Џ�R:N�W@x�v�s�N'`�c�Q�Ncb � ���:_�X[(W�N�e�vvP6q'`0 YBg'`�T Nnx�['`KN-N�v�N{|��R�v*g�Q�0 [ 1 ] ( P 1 ) =\�{�yf[�b/g�v�SU\�cؚ�N�N{|9e ��6q�v���R �FO_N&^eg�N\o(W�v�b/g'`Θi� ��Yu`Θi�08hΘi�I{I{0ُ�NΘi��]�~b:NhQt'`�vv^\q_�T0RhQ�N{|�vuX[�T�SU\0Θi�>yO�v0Reg � N�N9e�S�N>yO�SU\�vЏL�;��� � �N�OO�N{|`�~�e_�TL�:N!j__N�Nu�N�SS0�f͑���v/f�ُ�NΘi�cb�N�N{|�e g�v�l�_6R�^�T�^�[Θi��vt�_�S�e�l0 N�S �Θi�>yO�veg4N ���b�N�^�zhQ�e�vt�_�T�N
yO�SU\�T�N{|L�:N�v͑���0 Θi��vxQ�W�[IN�SLu�[:Nq_�T*geg�N�N�Su�v�S��'`�ST�g�v�g�y Nnx�['` �_N�S(u�Qpeh�:y:N�N�N�Su�v�i�sNT�g�vXN�y �Θi��v,g(�/f Nnx�['` ��S��wQ g Nnx�['` �1\OX[(WΘi�0 [ 2 ] ( P 5 ) Θi��vyr�ph��s(W�1 0Θi�>yO-N�v Θi� ;N��c�N �Θi� �/f�]N�T�y�bۏek�[�6q�T�N{|�vqS�[ �/f�Nu�g�y_c�[�v�S��'`02 0Θi��vhQt'`�Tgd�k'`0Θi��S�� �b�vq_�T�TT�g N�Syr�[�ezz�vP�6R �ُ�NΘi������N0W�W�T�eS N�vP�6R �NLu N@b g�N���S���S0Rُ�NΘi��vq_�T� N�Nq_�TS_�N�N�v)R�v � �N\q_�Tpe�N�N�v)R�v03 0Θi��v㉳Q ���hQtqQ T�R�R04 0Θi�wQ g Nnx�['`0�_���Qnx��Km0RΘi��Su�v�Qnx�e�� �Θi� N�el�S:N�[E��v~p��'`�N�N ��lt�v���^�R'Y0 0 0hQtΘi�>yO-N�v�s�XqS:g/f g�z�Q�v�KN N �Θi�>yO-N�v�s�X�v^^�c�6q~p�[_�S�v�s�X� � �/fc1u�N�N{|;m�R�[�s�X �b�vq_�T �_N1\/f T{v�e@b��v 6R ��vΘi� �m a n u f a c t u r e d r i s k � �sS1u�N�N{|ꁫ��wƋ�v�X� ��[te*NNLu&^eg�v:_�p\O(u@bR ��vΘi� ��[�Nُ�yΘi��X�Q�N{|�QNN�l g�S�Sm�G��v�~��0[ 3 ] ( P 2 4 ) ُ�N�N ��v�s�X�;N��/f�]NS�v�SU\�yr+R/f�yf[�b/g�vۏek �@b�[�v ��k�Y�>e\'`al�g0u`�|�~v`S �b�v>yO�Ra�I{I{ �vQq_�T�]�~��Ǐ O�~aIN N�v�s�X�0Θi�>yO-N�v�_Y�s�X��]�����N�6qLu�v�b�O Y���R ��N�N�O`��e g�v�b/g�T�e g�v6R�^�]�~�e�l�O Ym�0R_c�[�v�s�X0�Vdk �hQtΘi�>yO-N�v�s�X�wQ g Nnx�['`�T N�S��Km'` �Θi� N�el��S:N�[E��v~p�� �vQ%N͑'`\���Q��Km�T㉳Q�v���R0 (WhQtΘi�>yON �Yzz�s�X��]b:N�b/gۏek&^eg�v�s�Xal�g�eb__KN N0\O:NYzz�s�Xal�g;N��b__�vzz���xGr�vMR�]�~b:N N�yhQt'`�� N�eb� ��QNN@b g�v*�)Y�V�[��6R �zz���xGr ����c6Rzz���xGr�vpeϑ ��Qzz���s�X�val�g � ���@b g*�)Y�V�[�vqQ T�R�RMb��㉳Q��S N�eb� �zz���xGr�[@b g*�)YhV���gbZ�� �'Y�Wzz���xGr�vh�=��f/f�m�ShQt@b g�V�[�v)R�v ��6q:N@b g�V�[@bsQ�_0 [ 4 ] ( P 1 1 9 ) ��@wzz���b/g�v N�e�SU\ �Yzz-NT�y �x�d �NEe�v���S �Yzz�s�Xal�g�vq_�T(W N�e�RgR ��[Yzz�s�X�v�l�_�O�b�_N�c N�N�ez0zz���xGral�g�vMR�]�~b:N*Yzzal�g�v͑��al�gb__ ��[�NO�[*Yzz�s�X�N�S�N{|;m�R�Nu�]'Y�vqS�['`0ُ�NqS�[;N��h��s(W�YN�eb��zz���xGr�[zz��h�S��val�g �S��OO0Wth�S��v�R:S�W N�QwQ g�S)R(u'` [ 5 ] ( P 1 4 9 ) �zz���xGr�]�~b:N�N �kSf�Th�S�zz���z�v\o(W@gKb �O�[*�XT�v�[hQ�S0R%N͑Z���zz���xGr�TЏL�-N�vzz��irSO�v�d�Q � �b%N͑�v*Yzz�v�d�N�N�[ a$] zzE��xGr؏�[0Wt�s�X�T�NXT�v�[hQ �b\o(WZ��0[ b$] T�T�Vzz���xGr�QcWSnx����Y�g�xGr(W͑ԏ0Wt'YlB\T�~�~X[(W ��[�[0Wb�_N g �b_c�[�vΘi�0[ 6 ] @b�N � T0Wb��s�X�O�b N7h �zz���s�X_N ����^�z N�y gHe�v�lt!j_0 �(WΘi�>yOƉ�-N �Yzz�s�X�v�l�_�O�bRb�4N@w��Ycb �1udk�f:N YBg�Tyr�k0 �N0Θi�>yO-NYzz�s�X�l�_�O�bb�4N�vcb Θi�>yO-N�vYzz�s�X�O�b g@w�f:Nyr�k�v�eb�0NΘi�>yO-NvQ�N�s�X��v�k �Yzz�s�Xal�g�yr+R/fzz���xGral�g �wQ g�NN�Q*Nyr�_� ��HQ �Yzz;m�R�[�s�X@b �b�val�gHT�sY7hS0Yzz;m�R �b�v�s�Xal�g �9hncal�g�n�v N T ��SR:NSf[al�g0uiral�g05u�xr^pb08h>e\al�g�N�Szz���xGral�g0[ 7 ] �P 1 3 0 �vQ-N �zz���xGral�g/f g%N͑�v�KN N0 vQ!k �zz���xGr �b�s�Xal�g�v�[a�/fyr�k�v �sS0Wth�S� ��:S�W^\�N�N{|qQ T"��N � N^\�N�NUO�V�[�v;NCg�{����V0zz���xGr�^\�NhQtlQ�W��V�Q�v�0hQtlQ�Wc�v/f N(W�V�[�{���T�c6RN�v���W0[ 8 ] ( P 1 9 3 ) zz���xGral�g/fY�NhQtlQ�W-N�vyr�k�s�Xal�g� ��l g�NUO�V�[�[YB\zz��-N�vyr�[:S�WwQ g;NCg �v^N(Wُ�Nyr�[�v:S�WKN-NL�O�{��Cg0 �Q!k �zz���xGr �b�vzz���s�Xal�g�v�i�_/fyr�k�v0N O�~�v�s�Xal�g�v�i�_ N T �zz���xGral�g/fc0Wth�S�X[(W'Yϑ�vzz���xGr�[�vQ�gb�Su�SS �q_�T�N0Wth�S��vck8^)R(u0[ 9 ] ( P 1 5 ) gT �;NSO�TR_#��vyr�k'`0�N�N{|ۏeQ*Yzz��N�v5 0 t^eg �W�Yu(W*Yzzh�S� N'Y'Y\\�v�xGr�]��Ǐ3 5 0 0 N*N0[ 1 0 ] zz���xGr�v�s�Xal�g�Nu�v�VE�#��N0R�^�^R_#��N�T*N;NSObT� 0Yzzag�~0,{mQag0,{Nag � 0#��NlQ�~0,{2 03 04 05 agĉ�[�Nzz���[SO�S\�V�^�[vQ�S\�vzz���[SO �b�v_c�[b�b#��N0ُ�Nĉ�[��^�8^!j�| ��(u'` N:_0 g�Nzz���xGr/f�S�N��feg�n�v �ُ�Nzz���xGr�Tzz��irSO N7hwQ g@b^\�v�V�[ �vQ_c�[T�P#��N:g6R ��S�kgqzz��irSO�(u�s g�v�VE�zz��ĉ�06q � �'YYpezz���xGr�v@b^\;NSO/f�e�lnx���v0�[�Nُ�N�e�l��feg�n�vzz���xGr ��_��\ُ�Nzz���xGr �b�v�s�Xal�g�v�VE�#��NR_#��N�g*NwQSO�V�[b�~�~0 hQtΘi�>yO�veg4NO�_Yzz�s�X�O�b�l�_6R�^�v�^�gb�4N@w%N�\�vcb0 ��HQ �Yzz�s�XΘi��vq_�T/fhQt'`�v0 я�Nt^eg �4O��@w�u[r�u�v��^0�yAma�v���Q0 9 . 1 1 �N�N0S A R S �vAmL� �~g_lal�g0 �q+s�p�� �u�k�v�O�[02uAm�v O�dI{I{ N�|R�N�N�v�Su �Θi�>yO�vt�_�n���N�N���S0hQtS�v�cۏONLuۏeQ0R N*N^�8^ Nnx�[�v�e�N �ُ�]�~b:N N�yhQtqQƋ0 hQtS�v�SU\O�_�N{|�v>yO;m�R��eg��HT�s�Q�v�N�OX['`0)R�vqQ T'`�N�SteSO'`0hQt'`Θi������N0W�W�T�eS�vP�6R �Θi�@b �b�vq_�T\ N�QP�6R(W O�~l�e�V�[�v�uLuKN�Q � �/fOŏ�0W�m�S0RvQ�N�V�[u�hQNLu �Θi� �b�v~p��'YY/f�e�l%_e��vhQt'`_c�[0�Nzz���xGr:N�O ��e(W1 9 6 5 t^zz���lf[Lu1\fnxc�Qzz���xGr�S��_w�\o(WqSi�0[ 1 1 ] ( P 2 0 0 ) zz���xGr �b�vqS�[�e�v�z�Q �b:N�O�bzz���s�X�v;N���0[ 1 2 ] ( P 1 3 5 ) �Vdk �zz���xGr&^eg�v�s�XΘi�/fhQt'`�v ������N�VLu�T2mLu ��Y�g N�y�g��2��T�ltzz���xGr&^eg�vqS�[ ���HNYzz�S��b:N�N{|�s�X��v͑~p:S0@b�N �zz���xGr��]b:N N*N�m�Sb��_^�vlQqQ� � N�N ���NLu@b g�V�[�Ǐ�$R�xFU�SN0RƖSOL��RKN-N � �N��Bl�N{|�_{�l��SYzz�s�X�O�b�vt�_00 vQ!k �Yzz�s�XΘi�wQ g Nnx�['`�T N�S��Km'`0 hQt'`Θi�OhQt>yOwQ g�N�N:N�v Nnx�['`0@b� �N:N�v Nnx�['` /fc�N�b/g0t'`0nx�[:N8h�_�v�N{|;m�RtS�Nu�N�Q�Na�e�v�b��~�g �OS_�N�N{|>yOb:NΘi�>yO�v͑���S�V/f�N{|;m�Rꁫ�0[ 1 3 ] ( P 1 1 4 ) Θi�vQ�[ /f�s�NS0�b/gS�T�~Nmۏz�v�g�zS N�e�RgR@b �b�vT�g [ 1 4 ] �P 1 2 5 �0�yf[��b�R �1\���S\�QvQꁫ��vnx�['`�eb��v@\P�0 ��yf[�b/g�[��,g���v Nnx�['`1\\oX[@w�]'Y�vΘi�0�Vdk ���@wYzz�y�b�vŏs�SU\ �1udk&^eg�vYzz�s�XΘi��vĉ6R���^��eg��'Y �vQq_�T�TT�g_N��eg�����N��Km�T�c6R0 gT �Θi�>yOƉ�-N�vYzz�s�X�R_#��vyr�k'`0 �KQЏ(u g�~�~0W N�#��N ( o r g a n i z e d i r r e s p o n s i b i l i t y ) ُ N�i�_egR�gΘi�>yON�v#��Nb�b�0lQ�S0?eV{6R�[��TN�[�~b�vT��v �6R ��NS_�N>yO-N�vqSi� �6qT�S�^�z NWY�eg�cxS#��N0ُ7h Neg ��N�N�b��]6R ��vqSi�l�S:N�g�y Θi� 0�O�Y N�e@b�c0R�v1 9 8 6 t^�Su(WLNKQpQ�vR\���)R8h5u�z�l2��NEe �vQ�[�N{| �b�vqS�[��N�N*g�[hQ�md� �u�ޏvz�z g�T�NqS�[��N�N*g�[hQdnZi0 (WΘi��e�N �>yO�Sb�NՋ���[ ��l g�N�[�[���v�~�g�#� � �l g�N/f;NSO � T�e�k*N�N�S��/f;NSO 0[ 1 5 ] Θi�(W�s�N>yO-N/f�NT�l�vb__�Nu�v ��s�X��Nu�v�[E�T�g�~8^b�4N NRR��~�v}v��@b g�N��R�b_c1Y�v�`�Q0Yzz�s�X� T7hb�4Nُ�y�`�Q �1\zz���xGral�g � � � g�_Yzz���xGr/f�e�l��f#��N;NSO�v ��Vdk(WR_#��e1\O�Q�s�e#��N;NSO�v�`b_0ُ1\�[Yzz�s�X�O�b�v#��N�SR�T6R�^�v�����c�Q�Ncb ��e�l�Q�N�s�N�lf[SO�|�v ��b�1u0#��N�� �v�SR:N�W�w0 N0Yzz�s�X�O�b�l�_t�_�vl��S�S NLuqQu t�_�v�c�Q �N{|�N
@ � � � � � � �ββ��β΅n�nRnR9R9n 0hL?� hL?� >*B*CJ KH OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 6j hL?� hL?� B*CJ KH OJ QJ U^J aJ ph -hL?� hL?� B*CJ KH OJ QJ ^J aJ ph /hL?� hL?� 5�B*CJ KH OJ QJ \�^J ph )hL?� hL?� B*CJ KH OJ QJ ^J ph 6j hL?� hL?� B*CJ KH OJ QJ U^J aJ ph -hL?� hL?� B*CJ KH OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 3hL?� hL?� 5�B* CJ KH OJ QJ \�^J aJ ph 3� : & > � � � � : q } � � � Z � � � t � � �" :# d# �# �$ &